Skip to content

Is it bad to be in a calorie deficit when sick? The immune system's verdict

4 min read

When you are sick, your body's energy needs increase as its immune system works harder to fight off infection, especially with a fever. This is why the common weight loss strategy of being in a calorie deficit is generally not advised when you're under the weather and trying to recover.

Quick Summary

Illness increases your body's energy demands to fuel the immune system, making calorie restriction during this time counterproductive and potentially harmful. Focusing on nutrient-dense foods and hydration is crucial for a faster recovery and preventing muscle loss.

Key Points

  • No Calorie Deficit: Your body requires extra energy when sick, so maintaining a calorie deficit can hinder recovery.

  • Immune System Needs Fuel: Illness and inflammation increase metabolic rate, necessitating more calories to support the immune system's fight.

  • Avoid Muscle Loss: When you don't eat enough, the body may break down muscle for energy, delaying healing and recovery.

  • Prioritize Hydration: Staying well-hydrated with fluids like broth and herbal tea is one of the most critical aspects of recovery.

  • Choose Nutrient-Dense Foods: Focus on easy-to-digest, nutrient-rich options like soup, yogurt, and fruits to provide essential vitamins and minerals.

  • Listen to Your Body: If your appetite is low, eat small, frequent meals rather than forcing yourself to eat large amounts.

In This Article

The Body's Increased Energy Demands During Sickness

When you fall ill, your body enters a state of heightened activity to combat the invading pathogens. This fight requires a significant amount of energy, which means your normal metabolic rate increases. For instance, a fever can raise your metabolic needs by about 10-13% for every 1°C increase in body temperature. This extra energy is needed for the production of immune cells, generating heat, and repairing tissue. A calorie deficit forces your body to find this energy from elsewhere.

How Illness Increases Calorie Burn

  • Fever: As your body temperature rises to create an inhospitable environment for germs, your metabolism speeds up to produce that heat.
  • Immune Response: The activation and proliferation of immune cells require energy. Without sufficient calories, this process becomes less efficient.
  • Inflammation: The inflammatory response, a critical part of the healing process, also increases the body's energy requirements.

Why a Calorie Deficit Hinders Recovery

Attempting to lose weight while sick is counterproductive. When your caloric intake is lower than what your body needs to fight an infection, it can pull from its own reserves in a way that is less than ideal. Rather than primarily burning fat stores as it might during a healthy deficit, your body may start breaking down muscle tissue for energy and protein when faced with the stress of illness and limited food.

This muscle breakdown, or catabolism, is undesirable for several reasons:

  • Delayed Healing: Protein is essential for tissue repair, and muscle loss can prolong recovery time.
  • Weakened Immunity: Nutrient deficiencies from a prolonged deficit can depress the immune system, making it more difficult to fight off the illness and increasing the risk of secondary infections.
  • Fatigue: Insufficient fuel exacerbates the exhaustion you already feel from being sick.

Comparison: Calorie Deficit vs. Nutrient Focus While Sick

Feature Calorie Deficit While Sick Nutrient Focus While Sick
Recovery Speed Slower, as the body lacks sufficient fuel to fight and repair effectively. Faster, as the immune system is adequately supported.
Immune Function Can be compromised due to malnutrition and stress. Strengthened by essential vitamins, minerals, and proteins.
Muscle Mass At risk of being broken down for energy, leading to muscle loss. Preserved by adequate protein intake.
Energy Levels Significantly lower, causing increased fatigue and weakness. Better sustained, improving comfort and reducing lethargy.
Overall Health Can lead to nutrient deficiencies and side effects like dehydration and headaches. Supports overall health and long-term well-being post-illness.

How to Nourish Your Body When You're Sick

Even with a poor appetite, it is crucial to focus on providing your body with the energy it needs. The goal is to consume small, frequent meals of easily digestible, nutrient-dense foods.

Prioritizing Hydration

Illness, especially with fever, vomiting, or diarrhea, can lead to dehydration. Adequate fluid intake is paramount. Instead of sugary drinks or caffeine, which can worsen dehydration, focus on options that provide electrolytes.

Best Hydration Options:

  • Water with lemon and honey
  • Broths and clear soups
  • Herbal teas like ginger or chamomile
  • Coconut water or electrolyte drinks

What to Eat When Appetite is Low

If you lack the appetite for large meals, concentrate on smaller, more frequent snacks. Aim for a balance of protein and carbohydrates to fuel your body and prevent muscle breakdown.

Easy-to-Digest Foods:

  • Chicken soup, which provides protein, hydration, and can help with congestion.
  • Bland carbohydrates like toast, rice, or crackers for nausea.
  • Protein-rich foods like yogurt, eggs, or tuna.
  • Fruits rich in Vitamin C, like berries or citrus fruits.

The Dangers of Extreme Calorie Restriction When Sick

While a short-term, mild calorie dip due to a lost appetite is not the end of the world, intentionally maintaining a large deficit while ill is risky. Extreme calorie restriction, often coupled with poor nutrition, can cause serious health problems. These risks include severe nutrient deficiencies, decreased metabolism, and a compromised immune system. For those with pre-existing conditions like diabetes or kidney issues, the dangers are even greater.

Separating Fact from Myth: "Feed a Cold, Starve a Fever"

The old adage "feed a cold, starve a fever" is outdated and medically inaccurate. Modern medicine confirms that your body needs energy to fight any illness, whether it comes with a cold or a fever. Starving yourself deprives your immune system of the resources it needs most, slowing down recovery and potentially making you feel worse. A gentle approach to eating and prioritizing fluids is best for any type of illness.

Conclusion

To effectively combat sickness, your body needs adequate fuel and nutrients. The priority is not to maintain a calorie deficit but to support your immune system's heightened demands with nourishing, easy-to-digest foods and ample fluids. Intentional calorie restriction while ill can hinder recovery, weaken your immune response, and lead to undesirable muscle loss. Listen to your body's cues and focus on providing it with the resources it needs to heal, so you can get back to feeling your best as quickly as possible. When in doubt, consult a healthcare professional for personalized advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, it is generally not recommended to diet while sick. Your body is already under stress and needs extra energy and nutrients to recover. Restricting calories can weaken your immune system and slow down the healing process.

Yes, illness, especially with a fever, increases your metabolic rate. Your body burns more calories to produce heat and fuel the immune response.

Not eating enough can lead to a compromised immune system, slower recovery, and the breakdown of muscle tissue for energy. It can also cause nutrient deficiencies that affect your overall health.

When your appetite is low, focus on small, frequent portions of easy-to-digest foods. Good options include broths, soups, yogurt, toast, rice, bananas, and smoothies.

No, this is a myth. Your body needs nourishment to fight both colds and fevers. Starving yourself can weaken your immune system and delay recovery.

Prioritize hydration with water, herbal teas, and electrolyte-rich fluids like coconut water or broths. Avoid sugary and caffeinated drinks, which can lead to dehydration.

It's best to return to a balanced, maintenance-level diet for a few days after recovering to fully replenish your energy stores and nutrients. Consult a healthcare provider for specific advice, especially after a long or severe illness.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.