Skip to content

Is it better to take NAD or nicotinamide riboside?

3 min read

Cellular NAD+ levels decrease by an estimated 10-65% with age, impacting cellular energy and repair functions. This decline has led to growing interest in supplements, but many people wonder: is it better to take NAD or nicotinamide riboside?

Quick Summary

This guide compares NAD+ and nicotinamide riboside (NR) supplementation, explaining why NR is generally a more practical and bioavailable option. It covers key differences in molecular structure, absorption, delivery methods, and cost, providing evidence-based insights into which supplement is better for boosting cellular NAD+ levels.

Key Points

  • Bioavailability favors NR: Nicotinamide riboside (NR) is a smaller molecule that can be efficiently absorbed orally and enters cells, unlike the larger NAD+ molecule which requires IV administration.

  • Oral vs. IV Delivery: NR is available in convenient oral supplements, while direct NAD+ is delivered via expensive, temporary IV infusions due to poor oral absorption.

  • Cost and Convenience: Oral NR is a far more affordable and practical solution for long-term use compared to the high cost and time commitment of IV NAD+ therapy.

  • Backed by Clinical Data: Multiple human trials have confirmed that oral NR effectively and safely increases cellular NAD+ levels, with dose-dependent results.

  • Mechanism of Action: NR acts as a precursor that is converted into NAD+ inside the cell, supporting vital functions like mitochondrial energy production and DNA repair.

  • Sustained vs. Rapid Effects: NR provides a gradual, sustained increase in NAD+ levels, whereas IV NAD+ creates a rapid spike that does not last long.

In This Article

Understanding the NAD+ Molecule

Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+) is a crucial coenzyme in every cell, powering numerous enzymatic reactions essential for cellular metabolism, DNA repair, and activating sirtuins. Sirtuins are proteins linked to healthy aging. As NAD+ levels decline with age, maintaining them is important in longevity research. However, the NAD+ molecule is large and doesn't easily cross cell membranes, especially when taken orally, leading to poor absorption. Direct NAD+ supplements are often given intravenously (IV) to bypass the digestive system.

The Role of Nicotinamide Riboside (NR) as a Precursor

Nicotinamide riboside (NR) is a smaller, more bioavailable NAD+ precursor from the vitamin B3 family. It's absorbed more efficiently by cells than NAD+. Inside the cell, NR converts to nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) and then to NAD+. This indirect route effectively raises cellular NAD+ levels, making it suitable for oral supplements.

NR vs. NAD+: A Head-to-Head Comparison

Comparing NR and NAD+ helps determine the best supplement choice based on absorption, delivery, and effect.

Absorption and Bioavailability

  • Oral Absorption: Oral NAD+ has low bioavailability as it's too large for effective digestive absorption and can break down in the gut. Oral NR is well-absorbed and shown to increase blood NAD+ levels in human studies.
  • Intracellular Conversion: NR easily enters cells via specific transporters and converts to NAD+, increasing the coenzyme pool. Direct NAD+ struggles to enter cells.

Delivery Methods

  • Intravenous (IV) Therapy: NAD+ is often given via IV for high blood concentrations. These infusions are expensive, time-consuming, and temporary. Side effects like discomfort, nausea, or headaches can occur.
  • Oral Supplements: NR is available in convenient oral forms like Niagen®, a studied and patented version. This allows for easy daily dosing for long-term health support.

Efficacy and Cost

  • Effectiveness: Clinical studies show oral NR safely and effectively increases NAD+ levels in adults, with doses from 100 mg to 1,000 mg showing dose-dependent increases in blood NAD+. While IV NAD+ causes a rapid spike, oral NR is more practical and sustained.
  • Cost: Oral NR is much more affordable for long-term use than IV NAD+ sessions.

Comparison Table

Characteristic Nicotinamide Riboside (NR) Direct NAD+ Supplementation
Molecular Structure Simpler, form of Vitamin B3 More complex, large molecule
Oral Bioavailability High; efficiently converted inside cells Very low; broken down in digestion
Primary Delivery Method Oral capsules/supplements Intravenous (IV) therapy
Speed of Action Gradual, sustained increase in NAD+ Rapid, but temporary spike in blood NAD+
Cost for Long-Term Use Lower and more accessible Significantly higher, per session
Side Effects Generally mild (nausea, fatigue, headaches) Infusion-related side effects more common (nausea, cramping)

Potential Benefits and Considerations

Increasing NAD+ through NR or IV NAD+ can offer similar benefits, including support for:

  • Mitochondrial Function: NR enhances cellular energy production.
  • DNA Repair: Higher NAD+ activates PARP1, important for DNA repair.
  • Sirtuin Activity: Boosting NAD+ activates sirtuins, linked to cellular health and longevity.
  • Metabolic Health: NAD+ precursors may improve insulin sensitivity and support metabolic health.
  • Neuroprotection: Research suggests NR may protect brain cells and support cognitive function.

Considerations for Choosing

For consistent, long-term, and affordable NAD+ level support, oral NR is generally the better choice due to its high bioavailability and sustained effect. IV NAD+ is less practical and more expensive, used mainly for immediate, short-term effects or specific clinical needs. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting supplements.

Importance of Quality

Supplement quality varies. For oral NR, choose reputable brands with ingredients like Niagen®, which is clinically tested. Third-party testing helps verify ingredients and potency.

Conclusion

Direct NAD+ supplementation is largely limited to costly, temporary IV infusions due to poor oral absorption. Nicotinamide riboside (NR), an orally effective precursor, is a much more practical way to boost cellular NAD+ for most individuals. Its high bioavailability supports energy metabolism, DNA repair, and cellular vitality, making it the preferred choice for long-term health and anti-aging goals. NR offers a science-backed, convenient, and cost-effective option for cellular health.

Visit this page for more information on the effects of Nicotinamide Riboside on various health conditions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Nicotinamide riboside (NR) is a precursor that the body converts into NAD+ inside cells, whereas NAD+ is the final, active coenzyme. The key functional difference lies in absorption; NR is efficiently absorbed orally, while direct NAD+ is poorly absorbed and typically requires IV administration.

Yes, oral NR supplementation is highly effective at boosting NAD+ levels. Due to its smaller size, NR can easily enter cells and be converted into NAD+ through a salvage pathway, leading to a sustained increase in the body's NAD+ pool.

NAD+ is a large molecule that cannot effectively cross the cell membranes of the digestive tract. When taken orally, it is largely broken down into its precursors before it can be absorbed, making it an inefficient method of supplementation.

NR is generally well-tolerated with mild, occasional side effects such as nausea, headaches, or fatigue. IV NAD+ infusions may cause more immediate side effects like nausea, cramping, and headaches, which can be mitigated by slowing the infusion rate.

When you take NR orally, it is absorbed and converted into NMN by specific kinases inside your cells. NMN is then rapidly converted to NAD+, effectively replenishing the cellular NAD+ supply.

Yes, oral NR is significantly more cost-effective for long-term use than IV NAD+ therapy. The cost of frequent IV infusions is much higher than that of daily oral supplements.

Nicotinamide riboside can be particularly beneficial for older adults, individuals with certain metabolic conditions, or those looking to support cellular energy, DNA repair, and overall cellular vitality.

By increasing NAD+ levels, NR activates sirtuins and supports cellular health, which may help counteract some age-related decline. While not a 'fountain of youth,' it supports several processes linked to healthy aging.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.