Skip to content

Is there any benefit to taking ketones? Unpacking the science of nutritional ketosis

5 min read

With the ketogenic diet’s immense popularity, a new class of supplements has emerged, promising a shortcut to a metabolic state called ketosis. Exogenous ketones, which are supplied from an external source, have gained significant attention for their purported ability to replicate the benefits of a low-carb diet without the strict eating regimen. However, a key question remains: Is there any benefit to taking ketones?

Quick Summary

Ketone supplements may offer benefits like enhanced mental clarity, appetite suppression, and relief from 'keto flu' symptoms. However, their impact on weight loss and athletic performance is mixed, and they do not replace the fat-burning effects of a true ketogenic diet. They can also cause side effects like gastrointestinal distress.

Key Points

  • Cognitive Enhancement: Ketones provide an alternative, clean fuel source for the brain that may improve focus, mental clarity, and memory, particularly in glucose-deficient states.

  • Appetite Control: Exogenous ketone supplements can reduce levels of the hunger hormone ghrelin, which may help suppress appetite and aid in calorie control.

  • 'Keto Flu' Relief: Taking ketone supplements can accelerate entry into ketosis and help alleviate the fatigue, headaches, and nausea associated with the transition to a very low-carb diet.

  • Inconclusive Athletic Performance: Research on ketone supplements for athletic performance is mixed, with some studies suggesting benefits for endurance but others showing potential impairment in high-intensity efforts.

  • Gastrointestinal Side Effects: Especially with ketone salts, users may experience gastrointestinal issues like nausea, diarrhea, and stomach discomfort, which can limit the dosage.

  • Not a Direct Weight Loss Method: Ketone supplements do not directly cause your body to burn its own fat stores. When exogenous ketones are present, the body’s own fat-burning is reduced.

  • Variety in Supplements: Ketone salts, esters, and MCT oil offer different potencies and come with varying costs and side effect profiles.

In This Article

What Are Ketones and How Do Supplements Work?

Ketones, or ketone bodies, are molecules produced by your liver when carbohydrate intake is low. In this state, known as nutritional ketosis, your body switches from using glucose (sugar) for fuel to burning fat. The body produces its own endogenous ketones when fasting or on a ketogenic diet. Exogenous ketones, by contrast, are supplements that provide pre-formed ketones from an external source.

The two most common types of exogenous ketone supplements are ketone salts and ketone esters. Ketone salts, which are more widely available and affordable, bind ketones to a mineral (often sodium, potassium, or calcium). Ketone esters are pure ketone bodies and are considered more potent, but they are also more expensive and have a notably unpleasant taste. Another popular supplement, medium-chain triglyceride (MCT) oil, is not a ketone itself but is easily converted into ketones by the liver, albeit at lower levels than salts or esters.

Potential Benefits of Taking Ketones

While the full range of effects is still under investigation, several areas show promising, though often limited, benefits from taking ketone supplements.

  • Enhanced Brain Function: The brain can use ketones as an efficient and clean source of energy, especially when glucose is limited. Some studies suggest that this can lead to improved mental clarity, focus, and potentially protect against cognitive decline in certain neurodegenerative conditions. For example, ketone monoester supplementation has shown promise in improving memory and verbal fluency in older adults with metabolic syndrome. This provides a stable energy supply that avoids the peaks and crashes associated with blood sugar fluctuations.

  • Appetite Suppression: For those aiming for weight management, exogenous ketones may offer an advantage by helping to control appetite. Research has shown that ketone supplements can lower levels of the hunger hormone ghrelin, leading to reduced feelings of hunger. This effect is most pronounced when taken in a fasted state and could be a useful tool for adhering to a restricted-calorie diet.

  • Easing 'Keto Flu' Symptoms: The transition to a ketogenic diet can be challenging, often accompanied by unpleasant symptoms like headaches, fatigue, and nausea, collectively known as the 'keto flu'. By raising blood ketone levels rapidly, exogenous ketones can help reduce these symptoms and accelerate the body's adaptation to using ketones for fuel.

  • Athletic Performance: The evidence regarding athletic performance is mixed. Early studies suggested exogenous ketones could enhance endurance performance by providing an alternative fuel source and 'sparing' muscle glycogen stores. However, later research has shown inconsistent results, with some studies even indicating an impairment in high-intensity, short-duration performance, potentially due to gastrointestinal issues. Athletes in different sports may experience varying results, and timing of the supplement relative to exercise is a crucial factor.

Limitations and Risks to Consider

It is important to understand that exogenous ketones are not a magic solution and come with potential drawbacks.

  • Not a Direct Weight Loss Aid: Contrary to popular belief, taking ketone supplements does not directly cause your body to burn its own fat stores for energy. When you ingest ketones, your body uses them as an available fuel source, which signals your body to decrease its own fat breakdown. The best-documented pathway for weight loss still involves adhering to a calorie-restricted diet, whether ketogenic or not.

  • Gastrointestinal Distress: A significant downside, particularly for ketone salts, is the high risk of stomach upset. Side effects can include nausea, diarrhea, and other forms of gastrointestinal discomfort. The mineral load in ketone salts is often the culprit for these issues.

  • Electrolyte Imbalances: Ketone salts, which contain electrolytes like sodium, can be problematic for individuals with conditions like high blood pressure or kidney disease. Taking large doses can lead to an excess mineral load that disrupts the body's delicate electrolyte balance.

  • High Cost and Poor Taste: Ketone esters, the most effective form for rapidly raising blood ketones, are often prohibitively expensive. Additionally, many people report an unpleasant taste for both esters and salts, making consistent supplementation difficult.

Comparing Different Ketone Supplement Types

Here is a comparison of the main types of ketone supplements available on the market:

Feature Ketone Salts (e.g., BHB + minerals) Ketone Esters (e.g., pure BHB) MCT Oil (Medium-Chain Triglycerides)
Effectiveness Mild to moderate increase in blood ketones. Rapid, potent increase in blood ketones (can reach 3-5 mM). Gentle, slower increase in ketone levels (typically 0.5-1 mM).
Cost More affordable and widely available. Expensive, mainly used in research or by elite athletes. Inexpensive and readily available.
Side Effects Can cause gastrointestinal distress, high mineral load. Less risk of electrolyte issues but can cause GI upset. Can cause gastrointestinal issues with large doses.
Best For Easing keto transition, general energy boost. Maximizing ketone levels for performance or therapeutic use. Gentle keto support, cognitive boost, and calorie addition.

Who Might Benefit from Ketone Supplements?

Ketone supplementation is not for everyone. However, some individuals might find them useful for specific purposes:

  • Individuals new to the ketogenic diet: To ease the transition period and minimize the symptoms of the keto flu.
  • Biohackers seeking cognitive enhancement: For those interested in improving mental clarity and focus, particularly when fasting or following a low-carb diet.
  • Endurance athletes: Some endurance athletes may benefit from a strategic approach to ketone supplementation, though this area has mixed results.

Conclusion: A Tool, Not a Shortcut

In summary, the benefits of taking ketones depend heavily on the supplement type, dosage, and your specific goals. While they can effectively raise blood ketone levels, support cognitive function, and help mitigate 'keto flu' symptoms, the evidence for direct weight loss or performance enhancement is not conclusive. Exogenous ketones are best viewed as a tool to support certain metabolic processes rather than a shortcut to the full benefits of a well-executed ketogenic diet. For most people, a whole-foods ketogenic diet remains the most effective and sustainable way to achieve and maintain nutritional ketosis. Always consult a healthcare professional before beginning any new supplement regimen, especially if you have underlying health conditions.

How to Use Exogenous Ketones Effectively

  1. Understand Your Goal: Decide if you want to ease the keto transition, boost mental clarity, or experiment with athletic performance enhancement. Your goal will determine the best type and timing for supplementation.
  2. Start with a Low Dose: Begin with a smaller serving than recommended to assess your tolerance and avoid gastrointestinal side effects.
  3. Choose the Right Type: For gentle keto support and fewer side effects, start with MCT oil. For a more potent effect, consider ketone salts, and if taste and cost are not an issue, ketone esters.
  4. Time Your Intake: For a mental boost, take them in the morning or during the mid-afternoon slump. For exercise, take them 30-60 minutes beforehand. For faster entry into ketosis, take them during the initial days of carbohydrate restriction.
  5. Monitor Your Body: Pay attention to how your body reacts. Monitor your energy levels, cognitive function, and any side effects. This personalized approach will help you determine the real-world benefits for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

While ketones may suppress appetite, exogenous ketone supplements do not directly cause weight loss by burning body fat. When you consume them, your body uses these external ketones for energy instead of your stored fat.

Common side effects, particularly with ketone salts, include gastrointestinal issues like nausea, diarrhea, and stomach discomfort. There is also a risk of electrolyte imbalance due to the high mineral content.

Yes, taking exogenous ketones can help alleviate the symptoms of the 'keto flu,' such as fatigue and headaches, by providing an immediate energy source and accelerating the body's transition into ketosis.

A ketogenic diet induces ketosis by restricting carbohydrates and prompting your body to burn its own stored fat, which is generally more effective for long-term weight management. Exogenous ketones offer a rapid, temporary boost in blood ketones but do not replicate this process.

Results are mixed. Some endurance athletes may see benefits, but performance in high-intensity activities could be impaired. The specific supplement type and timing are crucial, and more research is needed.

Ketone salts are ketones bound to minerals, making them more affordable but less potent and prone to causing gastrointestinal issues. Ketone esters are pure ketones, more powerful, but also more expensive and have a stronger taste.

Yes, ketones can serve as an efficient fuel for the brain, potentially improving mental clarity, focus, and memory, and offering a stable energy source compared to glucose fluctuations.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.