Skip to content

Is There Any Candy Without Red Dye? A Comprehensive Guide

4 min read

According to a 2010 study published in The Lancet, certain artificial food colorings have been linked to potential health concerns, prompting many consumers to seek out alternatives. For candy lovers with sensitivities or those who prefer natural ingredients, finding sweets without red dye can be a challenge. Fortunately, an increasing number of companies are using natural colorings derived from fruits, vegetables, and other natural sources to create vibrant and delicious confections.

Quick Summary

This guide provides a detailed overview of candy options free from red dye, including products from popular brands and lesser-known natural alternatives. It offers information on how to identify these candies by reading labels and using natural substitutes at home. Practical tips for safe indulgence are included for all ages.

Key Points

  • Know Your Brands: Look for companies like YumEarth, UNREAL, and SmartSweets that specialize in candies free from artificial dyes.

  • Read Labels Closely: Always check the ingredients list for specific color additives like 'Red 40' or 'Red 3.' If it just says 'artificial colors,' be cautious.

  • Embrace Natural Colorings: Identify products that use natural sources like fruit and vegetable juices, turmeric, or spirulina for coloring.

  • DIY Options Exist: You can make your own dye-free candies at home using concentrated juices from beets, carrots, or other colorful produce.

  • Muted vs. Vibrant: Naturally colored candies often have a softer, more muted appearance compared to the vivid shades of their conventional counterparts.

  • Beyond Red Dye: Many natural candy brands also avoid other artificial ingredients, making them a cleaner choice overall.

  • Cost vs. Quality: Be aware that naturally colored candy may be slightly more expensive due to the cost of sourcing natural, premium ingredients.

In This Article

Navigating the Dye-Free Candy Aisle

Finding candy without artificial red dye has become easier as consumer demand for cleaner labels has grown. Many brands now offer products colored with ingredients like beet juice, paprika, and spirulina. The key is to know what to look for and where to find these alternatives. While some brands, like Hershey's, have moved away from using certain dyes in specific products, it's always wise to check the ingredient list for specific color additives, such as Red 40 or Red 3.

Popular Brands with Dye-Free Options

Several major and specialty candy companies now cater to the dye-free market. For example, YumEarth is a brand widely known for its commitment to using only natural ingredients and colors derived from real fruit and vegetable juice concentrates. Their products include lollipops, fruit snacks, and chewy candies. Another company, UNREAL, focuses on creating chocolate-based treats and offers dye-free options. For gummy lovers, Albanese offers a range of all-natural gummy bears.

Reading Labels for Artificial Colors

To ensure a product is free of red dye, always check the ingredients list. Look for specific color names that begin with "Red," followed by a number, such as Red 40 or Red 3. If the label simply says "artificial colors" or "color added," it's best to avoid it unless the manufacturer provides more specific information. Conversely, products that use natural colorings will list them explicitly, such as "colored with fruit and vegetable juice," "turmeric," or "annatto".

Naturally Colored Candy Brands

  • YumEarth: Offers a wide range of organic and allergy-friendly candies, including lollipops, gummy bears, and fruit snacks, colored with real fruit juice.
  • UNREAL: Specializes in chocolate candies and uses natural ingredients and colors.
  • SmartSweets: Known for low-sugar gummy candies that are free from artificial sweeteners and colors.
  • Black Forest: Their Juicy Burst fruit snacks are colored with real fruit juice and spirulina, not artificial dyes.
  • Heaven & Earth: This brand offers a variety of taffy and other candies made with natural colors and flavors.
  • Zollipops: Created by a young entrepreneur, these lollipops and taffies are known for being dye-free.
  • No Whey! Foods: Offers a range of allergy-friendly, vegan chocolate candies that are free from artificial colors.

Comparison of Naturally Colored vs. Conventionally Colored Candies

Feature Naturally Colored Candies Conventionally Colored Candies
Color Source Fruits, vegetables, plant extracts (e.g., beet, spirulina) Synthetic, petroleum-based dyes (e.g., Red 40, Yellow 5)
Color Intensity Often more muted, with earthy or pastel tones Generally brighter, more vibrant, and consistent shades
Potential Allergies Lower risk for those sensitive to synthetic additives Higher potential for allergic reactions or sensitivities in some individuals
Flavor Profile Can sometimes have a subtle, natural flavor from the coloring agent Typically have no noticeable impact on flavor
Availability Primarily found in health food stores, specialty markets, or online Widely available in most grocery stores and convenience shops
Cost Can sometimes be more expensive due to natural ingredient sourcing Generally more budget-friendly

Making Your Own Dye-Free Sweets at Home

For those who love to bake or experiment in the kitchen, creating your own dye-free candy is a fun and safe alternative. You have complete control over the ingredients and can achieve beautiful colors using common, natural foods. Here's a simple guide for making your own naturally colored treats.

Step-by-Step Natural Coloring

  1. Gather Your Natural Sources: Purchase fruits, vegetables, and spices that yield vibrant colors. For red and pink, think beet juice, pomegranate juice, or raspberry puree. For other colors, consider turmeric for yellow, spirulina for blue or green, and carrot juice for orange.
  2. Extract the Color: Boil or blend your chosen ingredient to extract the pigment. For example, simmering beet chunks in water and straining the liquid will give you a concentrated red dye. Reduce the liquid until it's a syrup-like consistency for a more potent color.
  3. Create Your Candy Base: Choose a simple candy recipe that doesn't rely on synthetic colors. A simple sugar syrup for hard candy or a coconut oil base for chews works well. For hard candy, combine sugar, water, and corn syrup, cooking to the hard-crack stage.
  4. Incorporate the Dye: Once your candy base is ready, mix in a few drops of your homemade natural coloring until the desired shade is achieved. Start with a small amount and add more gradually to control the intensity.
  5. Set and Enjoy: Pour the mixture into candy molds or onto a lined baking sheet to set. Once cooled, you'll have delicious, vibrant, and completely dye-free candy.

A Final Word on Red Dye-Free Indulgence

Choosing candy without red dye is a simple step many people take for health reasons or personal preference. The market has responded with numerous delicious and creative options, from well-known brands offering natural alternatives to dedicated health-focused companies. By learning to read labels carefully and exploring DIY methods, you can satisfy your sweet tooth without compromising your dietary choices. As consumer awareness continues to grow, expect to see even more innovative and tasty dye-free candies in the future. Finding sweets that are both delightful and naturally colored is a goal that is more achievable than ever before.

Frequently Asked Questions

YumEarth products (lollipops, gummy bears), UNREAL chocolates, SmartSweets gummies, Heaven & Earth taffy, and Black Forest Juicy Burst fruit snacks are known to be free of artificial dyes, including red dye.

No. The term "natural flavors" on an ingredient list does not guarantee the absence of artificial colors. You must read the specific color additives section of the label to confirm.

No. Hershey's has removed Red 3 from their products since 2021. However, since recipes and ingredients can change, and other red dyes might be used, it's always best to check the label for each specific product.

Red 40, or Allura Red AC, is a synthetic red azo dye. Some people avoid it due to potential links to hyperactivity in children and other sensitivities, though it is FDA-approved.

You can find these candies in health food stores like Whole Foods, specialty online retailers, and often in the natural or organic section of major supermarkets.

To get a natural red color for homemade treats, you can use beet juice, raspberry puree, or concentrated pomegranate juice.

Generally, yes. By definition, organic products cannot use artificial colors. They rely on natural colorings from fruits, vegetables, and other plant sources, making them a reliable choice for dye-free candy.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.