Should I Take Omega-3 Even If I Eat Fish?

December 20, 2025 •

4 min read

According to the American Heart Association, most adults should eat two servings of fatty fish per week. For those who meet or exceed this recommendation, the question remains: should I take omega-3 even if I eat fish? The answer largely depends on your individual health needs and the type of omega-3 you are consuming.

Quick Summary

This article explores the key differences between omega-3 from food versus supplements, identifying who may benefit from supplementation even with adequate fish intake, and highlights the pros and cons of each source. It details factors like nutrient synergy and potency to help you make an informed decision.

Key Points

Food First, Supplements Second: For general wellness, getting omega-3 from whole fatty fish is superior due to the complementary nutrients like protein, vitamins, and minerals.
Supplements for Therapeutic Doses: For specific health issues, such as very high triglycerides, targeted high-dose supplements are often necessary and impractical to achieve with diet alone.
Consult a Professional: Always consult a doctor before starting supplements, especially if you have an existing health condition, are on medication, or are pregnant.
Check Your Fish Intake: If you eat the recommended two or more servings of fatty fish weekly, you likely receive sufficient omega-3s for general health.
Purity and Contaminants: Quality omega-3 supplements are purified to remove contaminants like mercury, which can be a concern with certain types of whole fish.
Algal Oil is an Alternative: Plant-based options like algal oil provide EPA and DHA, making them suitable for vegetarians, vegans, or those with fish allergies.

Fish vs. Supplements: Unpacking the Nutrient Differences

For most healthy individuals, getting omega-3 fatty acids directly from whole food sources like fatty fish is the superior option. The benefits of eating fish are not solely due to the omega-3s, but come from a synergistic "orchestra" of nutrients, including high-quality protein, vitamin D, and various minerals. Fish oil supplements, by contrast, are concentrated sources of specific omega-3s, namely eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), with fewer of these complementary components.

The Whole-Food Advantage: Beyond Just EPA and DHA

Whole fish offers a comprehensive nutrient package that supplements cannot replicate. For example, sardines provide calcium, potassium, iron, magnesium, and iodine in addition to their rich omega-3 content. These extra components work together to support overall health in ways that isolated nutrients might not. Furthermore, the bioavailability of omega-3s can differ between food and supplement forms, with triglycerides in whole fish generally being well-absorbed by the body.

The Supplement Advantage: Targeted Potency

Supplements offer a distinct advantage for those with specific health goals or dietary restrictions. For instance, achieving the higher daily doses of EPA and DHA (e.g., 2–4 grams) often recommended for therapeutic effects on conditions like high triglycerides would be impractical through diet alone. Prescription-strength omega-3 formulations, regulated for quality and safety by the FDA, are used specifically to treat very high triglyceride levels. Quality supplements also undergo molecular distillation to minimize contaminants like mercury and PCBs, which can be a concern with certain larger or predatory fish. Algal oil offers a plant-based alternative for vegans or those with seafood allergies, providing DHA and EPA directly without the need for conversion from ALA.

Who Needs Omega-3 Supplements Even with Fish in Their Diet?

Even if you eat fish, there are several scenarios where supplementation might be necessary or beneficial:

High Triglyceride Levels: For individuals with very high triglycerides (above 500 mg/dL), a doctor might prescribe a high-dose, pharmaceutical-grade omega-3 supplement to help lower levels, often in conjunction with other treatments.
Existing Heart Conditions: The American Heart Association suggests around 1 gram per day of combined EPA and DHA for people with existing coronary heart disease, which may be difficult to achieve with diet alone.
Cognitive Support: Some studies suggest that regular omega-3 supplementation may help protect cognitive function and reduce the risk of dementia in older adults, though more research is needed.
Dietary Gaps: If your fish intake is inconsistent, a supplement provides a reliable, measurable dose of EPA and DHA to fill nutritional gaps.

Comparison: Fish vs. Omega-3 Supplements


Feature	Whole Fish	Omega-3 Supplements (Fish Oil)
Nutrient Profile	Comprehensive source including high-quality protein, vitamins (D, B2), calcium, and minerals.	Concentrated source primarily containing EPA and DHA.
Potency (EPA/DHA)	Varies greatly by species; generally lower dose per serving compared to therapeutic supplements.	High and consistent dosage; ideal for addressing specific therapeutic needs.
Bioavailability	Excellent, as omega-3s are in natural triglyceride form.	Can be excellent (e.g., reformed triglycerides, krill oil) or slightly lower (ethyl esters).
Contaminants	Potential for environmental contaminants like mercury, especially in larger predatory fish.	Purified to remove mercury and PCBs; look for third-party testing (e.g., IFOS certified).
Additional Benefits	Synergy of multiple nutrients for overall health.	Provides a targeted, convenient, and measurable dose of specific fatty acids.
Drawbacks	Concerns over contaminants and environmental impact with certain fish choices.	Some individuals report side effects like burping, reflux, or digestive issues.

Making the Right Choice for Your Health

Determining whether to take an omega-3 supplement, even with a diet that includes fish, involves assessing your personal health needs, diet, and risk factors. If you consistently eat two or more servings of fatty fish weekly, you likely meet the general recommendations for heart health and may not need a supplement for basic nutritional support. However, if you have very high triglycerides, a diagnosed heart condition, or other specific health concerns, a supplement may provide the higher, therapeutic dose of EPA and DHA needed. Consult with your healthcare provider to evaluate your needs and determine if a supplement is a beneficial addition to your diet. They can help you select the right dosage and form, and monitor any potential interactions with medications, particularly if you are on blood thinners. Making an informed decision prioritizes a balanced, holistic approach to your health.

Conclusion: Personalized Health Is Key

Eating whole fish remains the best way for most people to get a comprehensive array of beneficial nutrients alongside their omega-3s. For those with specific health conditions or therapeutic needs that require higher, concentrated doses of EPA and DHA, supplements can play a crucial role as an adjunct treatment, not a replacement for a healthy diet. Consulting a healthcare provider is essential for tailoring any supplementation strategy to your unique circumstances. Ultimately, the choice between relying on fish or adding a supplement depends on your health goals, dietary habits, and professional medical advice.

Take the next step:

Frequently Asked Questions

For most healthy people, yes. The American Heart Association recommends eating two servings of fatty fish per week, which is typically enough to meet the necessary intake of EPA and DHA for general health. However, individuals with specific health conditions might need more than can be easily obtained from diet alone.

You might need a supplement if you have very high triglyceride levels, as a doctor may prescribe a high-dose omega-3 medication. Additionally, if you have existing coronary heart disease, your doctor might recommend a supplement to reach the higher daily EPA and DHA levels needed.

For overall nutrition, whole fish is generally superior because it provides a complete package of nutrients, including protein, vitamins, and minerals, that work synergistically. Supplements, while offering concentrated EPA and DHA, lack these other beneficial components.

Yes, potential risks and side effects exist, especially with high doses. These can include gastrointestinal discomfort, acid reflux, and a mild increase in the risk of bleeding, especially if you are on blood-thinning medication. Always discuss supplementation with a healthcare provider first.

Look for supplements that are third-party tested for purity and potency, such as those with an IFOS certification. Check the label for the specific amounts of EPA and DHA, and ensure the product is fresh to avoid rancidity.

If you don't eat fish, you can get omega-3s from plant-based sources like flaxseed, chia seeds, and walnuts, which contain ALA. For a direct source of EPA and DHA, algal oil is an excellent vegetarian and vegan-friendly option.

While omega-3 has an antiplatelet effect that can thin the blood, recent meta-analyses suggest no clinically significant increased risk of bleeding from standard doses. However, if you are on anticoagulant medication, it is crucial to consult your doctor before starting omega-3 supplements.