What are the three types of umami?
Umami, often described as a savory, rich, or meaty taste, is one of the five basic tastes alongside sweet, sour, salty, and bitter. Its complex flavor profile is derived from three primary compounds: glutamate, inosinate, and guanylate. These substances are naturally present in many foods and are also responsible for the synergistic effect that makes certain dishes taste exceptionally delicious. Understanding these components is key to mastering flavor in cooking, from simple homemade meals to gourmet creations.
Glutamate: The Foundation of Umami
Glutamate is an amino acid, a fundamental building block of protein, and the most abundant umami substance. It was the first of the umami compounds to be identified scientifically in 1908 by Kikunae Ikeda. While glutamate is found bound within proteins, it is the 'free' form of glutamate that provides the umami flavor. As foods ripen, age, or are fermented, enzymes break down proteins, releasing free glutamate and intensifying the savory taste.
Sources of Glutamate:
- Vegetables: Tomatoes are famously rich in glutamate, especially when ripe. Other vegetables include seaweed (like kombu), mushrooms, and carrots.
- Fermented Foods: Soy sauce, miso, and aged cheeses like Parmesan owe their deep, savory flavors to high concentrations of glutamate.
- Proteins: Meats and fish contain moderate levels of glutamate.
Inosinate: The Umami Enhancer from Animal Sources
Inosinate (specifically 5'-inosinate) is a nucleotide primarily responsible for the umami taste in meat and fish. It was discovered as an umami compound in dried bonito flakes in 1913 by Ikeda's student, Shintaro Kodama. Inosinate is most effective when paired with glutamate, exhibiting a powerful synergistic effect that can multiply the intensity of umami perception. This is why combining ingredients like meat and mushrooms, or bonito dashi and kombu, creates a much more profound flavor than either ingredient alone.
Sources of Inosinate:
- Animal Products: Dried bonito, sardines, tuna, chicken, and pork are excellent sources of inosinate.
- Processed Foods: Some processed fish products and certain broths are rich in inosinate.
Guanylate: The Umami Enhancer from Plant Sources
Guanylate (specifically 5'-guanylate) is another nucleotide that delivers a strong umami taste, particularly when paired with glutamate. It was identified in 1957 by Akira Kuninaka, who found it in dried shiitake mushrooms. Like inosinate, guanylate is most potent when combined with glutamate, and this synergy is a fundamental principle in Japanese cooking. Dried shiitake mushrooms are an especially concentrated source, making them a common ingredient in vegetarian dashi stock.
Sources of Guanylate:
- Mushrooms: Dried shiitake, porcini, and morel mushrooms are the most significant sources of guanylate.
- Other Plants: Lesser amounts can be found in certain fermented products.
The Synergistic Effect of Umami
The most important aspect of umami is the powerful synergistic effect that occurs when glutamate is combined with either inosinate or guanylate. This phenomenon was first described by Kuninaka, who noted that the perceived umami intensity is dramatically amplified when a ribonucleotide is present alongside glutamate. This principle explains why many classic flavor combinations work so well, such as:
- Dashi Stock: Kombu (rich in glutamate) and bonito flakes (rich in inosinate) are combined to create a stock with a deep, complex umami flavor.
- Western Cuisine: The classic combination of meat (inosinate) and tomatoes (glutamate) in a sauce creates a savory depth far beyond the sum of its parts.
- Miso Soup: The glutamate from the miso paste is enhanced by the inosinate from the dashi stock, resulting in a rich, satisfying flavor.
Comparison of the Three Types of Umami
| Feature | Glutamate (MSG) | Inosinate (IMP) | Guanylate (GMP) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Source | Plant and animal foods (e.g., tomatoes, Parmesan, seaweed) | Animal foods (e.g., bonito flakes, meat, fish) | Plant foods (e.g., dried shiitake mushrooms) |
| Chemical Type | Amino Acid | Nucleotide | Nucleotide |
| Effect Alone | Provides umami taste; considered the foundational umami flavor. | Weak umami taste on its own. | Weak umami taste on its own. |
| Synergistic Effect | Combines with inosinate and guanylate to exponentially enhance umami. | Greatly amplifies glutamate's umami flavor. | Greatly amplifies glutamate's umami flavor. |
| Best Paired With | Inosinate or guanylate-rich ingredients | Glutamate-rich ingredients | Glutamate-rich ingredients |
Conclusion
The three types of umami—glutamate, inosinate, and guanylate—are the key to the savory depth that makes food so enjoyable. Glutamate serves as the primary umami compound, with inosinate and guanylate acting as powerful enhancers through a remarkable synergistic effect. By intentionally combining these umami-rich ingredients, both home cooks and professional chefs can unlock new dimensions of flavor and create more delicious, satisfying dishes. Next time you enjoy a savory meal, take a moment to consider how these three compounds might be working together on your palate.
For more in-depth scientific information on the umami taste mechanism and its history, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) website offers a comprehensive article.