Skip to content

Understanding the Effects of Over Greasing

4 min read

According to a recent industry survey, approximately 70% of maintenance professionals believe over greasing is a significant problem at their plants, leading to costly and avoidable failures. This common mistake, while often made with good intentions, can cause more damage than under-greasing, triggering a cascade of destructive effects on machinery and critical components like bearings.

Quick Summary

Excessive lubrication can cause severe damage to machinery through heat generation, grease churning, and seal damage. Over greasing bearings and other components leads to friction, reduced lubricant effectiveness, and premature failure, often stemming from misinformed maintenance practices.

Key Points

  • High Operating Temperatures: Excessive grease creates friction and churning, leading to high internal temperatures that degrade the lubricant and shorten component life.

  • Grease Churning and Aeration: Overfilling causes the rotating elements to churn the lubricant, aerating it and reducing its effectiveness and load-carrying capacity.

  • Seal Damage and Contamination: The high pressure from excess grease can rupture seals, allowing external contaminants like dirt and water to enter the bearing and accelerate wear.

  • Increased Energy Consumption: The added drag from over-lubrication forces machinery to consume more energy, reducing efficiency and raising operational costs.

  • Lubricant Degradation: High temperatures cause the oil to separate from the thickener, leaving a hardened, crusty residue that can block new grease and cause lubrication failure.

  • Reduced Component Lifespan: The combined effects of heat, friction, and contamination lead to premature wear and failure of critical components like bearings.

In This Article

The Core Problem: How Over Greasing Starts

Many assume that more grease offers better protection, a misconception that is a leading cause of premature equipment failure. The primary issue with over greasing is that it creates excessive pressure and friction within a component, most notably in bearings. When a cavity is overfilled, the rotating elements must forcefully push through the lubricant, a process that is both energy-intensive and damaging. The common causes of this issue include:

  • Lack of Knowledge: Maintenance personnel, believing 'too much is better than not enough,' often add excess lubricant without understanding the correct volume needed.
  • Incorrect Equipment: Using uncalibrated grease guns or applying grease too quickly can inject more lubricant than required.
  • Blocked Relief Ports: In many cases, excess grease has nowhere to go if the relief or purge port is blocked by old, hardened grease, leading to significant pressure build-up.

The Damaging Effects of Excess Lubrication

Once the over greasing process begins, it sets off a chain reaction of negative consequences that degrade equipment performance and lifespan. Understanding these effects is the first step toward implementing better maintenance practices.

Increased Heat Generation

One of the most immediate and harmful effects of over greasing is the generation of excessive heat. The constant churning of surplus grease creates friction, significantly raising the operating temperature inside the bearing housing. This isn't a minor increase; for every 10°C temperature rise above 65°C, the lifespan of the lubricant can be halved. This accelerated thermal degradation causes the grease's base oil to separate from its thickener, losing its ability to protect moving parts.

Grease Churning and Aeration

In an over-filled bearing cavity, the rotating elements struggle to move, causing them to push and churn the excess grease. This churning effect can aerate the grease, creating a foam-like consistency that is far less effective as a lubricant. The churning not only generates more heat but also reduces the grease's load-carrying capacity, accelerating wear on the components. The aerated grease can't effectively provide a protective film, leaving metal surfaces vulnerable.

Seal Damage and Contamination

High-pressure grease guns can exert thousands of pounds per square inch (psi) of pressure, far exceeding the design limits of most bearing seals. This extreme pressure can rupture or deform lip seals, allowing the excess grease to leak out and, more critically, permitting contaminants like water, dirt, and dust to enter the bearing cavity. This ingress of foreign particles drastically accelerates wear and reduces the bearing's lifespan.

Increased Energy Consumption

The extra drag caused by excessive lubricant forces the machinery to work harder, leading to higher energy consumption. This inefficiency not only drives up operational costs but also contributes to additional heat generation, compounding the problem. This is a particularly notable effect in electric motors, where the excess grease can reach the motor windings, causing further issues.

Hardening of Grease and Lubrication Blockages

When the base oil separates from the thickener due to excessive heat, the remaining thickener can harden and form a crusty, solid residue. This crusty buildup can block the pathways for new grease to reach the core of the bearing, effectively starving it of fresh lubricant. The result is accelerated wear and potential component seizure, even when regular re-greasing is performed.

Comparison of Over Greasing vs. Under Greasing

Feature Over Greasing Under Greasing
Primary Cause Misguided belief that more is better, incorrect procedures, blocked relief ports. Lack of scheduled maintenance, not enough lubricant applied, neglecting lubrication points.
Effect on Seals Can rupture or damage seals due to excessive pressure, allowing contamination. Seals remain intact, but lack of lubrication and eventual hardening of old grease can lead to contamination ingress.
Heat Generation High heat generated by churning excess lubricant. High heat generated by metal-to-metal friction.
Energy Consumption Increased drag from excess lubricant leads to higher energy use. Increased friction causes higher energy consumption.
Contamination Ruptured seals allow external contaminants in. Inadequate lubrication and seal wear can lead to contamination.
Component Lifespan Significantly reduced due to high heat, churning, and seal damage. Significantly reduced due to metal-on-metal friction and heat.

Preventing the Damaging Effects of Over Greasing

Preventing over greasing requires a proactive and educated approach to maintenance. By following these best practices, you can protect your machinery and extend its operational life:

  • Establish a lubrication program: Create a structured maintenance schedule that specifies the correct type, amount, and frequency of grease for each component.
  • Calculate the correct volume: Use formulas based on bearing dimensions to determine the precise amount of grease needed.
  • Use the right tools: Utilize calibrated grease guns with gauges and consider installing pressure relief fittings to prevent excessive pressure buildup.
  • Educate maintenance staff: Ensure all personnel understand the risks of over greasing and are trained in proper lubrication techniques.
  • Clean purge ports: Always clean the area around purge or relief ports to ensure excess grease can exit the bearing housing.
  • Use ultrasonic instrumentation: Tools that listen to the sound of the bearing can help maintenance staff determine the ideal time to stop greasing, preventing over-application.

Conclusion

Over greasing, a seemingly benign maintenance error, can have catastrophic effects on industrial equipment, from increased operating temperatures and energy consumption to irreparable seal and bearing damage. By understanding the causes and consequences, maintenance teams can move away from the 'more is better' mentality and adopt a precise, calculated approach to lubrication. Implementing proper procedures, using the right tools, and providing continuous education are the most effective strategies for preventing over greasing, ensuring the longevity and reliable performance of critical machinery components. Taking these steps is not just good practice; it's an essential investment in the health of your equipment and the efficiency of your operations.

Frequently Asked Questions

The primary cause is often a lack of knowledge or an assumption that 'more is better,' leading maintenance staff to apply more lubricant than necessary. Other factors include using the wrong equipment or having blocked purge ports.

Excessive grease causes the rotating elements inside a component, such as a bearing, to churn through the lubricant. This churning creates significant friction, which in turn generates excessive heat.

Yes, excessive grease can build up high pressure within a housing, which can rupture or deform seals. This breach allows contaminants to enter the component, causing accelerated wear.

Both can lead to equipment failure, but over greasing can be a more insidious problem as its effects, such as churning and high temperatures, may not be immediately audible. Under greasing's metal-on-metal friction is often more obvious.

Signs include grease purging from the seals, high operating temperatures, and increased drag or resistance when pumping new grease. Ultrasonic tools can also detect the specific sounds of over-lubricated bearings.

Grease churning is the forceful pushing of lubricant by rotating elements in an over-filled cavity. It generates heat and aerates the grease, degrading its lubricating properties and increasing wear.

Prevention involves implementing a precise lubrication program with calculated volumes for each point, using calibrated grease guns, ensuring relief ports are clear, and training personnel on proper techniques.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.