The Origins of the Human Diet: The Omnivore's Tale
For millions of years, the diets of our human ancestors have been a topic of fascination and debate. Far from a single-diet scenario, evidence from fossil records, archaeological sites, and comparative anatomy paints a picture of extreme dietary flexibility. Early hominins consumed a mixed diet of plants and whatever animal food they could acquire, with the proportion changing based on technology, climate, and available resources.
Anatomical Evidence in Our Bodies
Our own biology provides powerful clues about our diet. The human body is a testament to millions of years of omnivorism. Unlike true herbivores with specialized digestive systems for fermenting cellulose, or obligate carnivores with short, simple guts, humans possess features of both. Our teeth, for example, include a versatile set: incisors for cutting plants, pointed canines for tearing meat, and molars for grinding. Furthermore, the evolution of a smaller intestinal tract and a larger brain is believed to have been fueled by the nutrient-dense, high-calorie foods gained from meat consumption.
A Look at Prehistoric Kitchens: Archaeological Discoveries
Evidence from early archaeological sites provides direct proof of our omnivorous past. Stone tools used for butchering and processing animal carcasses date back at least 2.6 million years. In fact, microscopic analysis of dental calculus from Neanderthals has shown they ate not only meat but also cooked plants, including legumes and seeds. These findings demonstrate that plant-based foods were a critical supplement but never the exclusive source of nutrition for our ancient relatives.
You Are What You Eat: The Chemistry of Fossils
Stable isotope analysis of ancient bones and teeth reveals the chemical signatures of the foods our ancestors ate. Studies on Neanderthal remains, for instance, show a high ratio of nitrogen isotopes characteristic of carnivores, suggesting they ate a significant amount of meat. While the specific ratio of plants to animals varied greatly between groups depending on location and environment, the overwhelming chemical evidence supports a consistent and long-standing omnivorous diet across the human lineage.
Anatomy Comparison: Herbivores, Carnivores, and Humans
| Feature | Herbivores (e.g., cow) | Carnivores (e.g., wolf) | Humans (Omnivore) | 
|---|---|---|---|
| Teeth | Large, flat molars for grinding plants; no canines. | Sharp canines for tearing flesh; pointed molars for shearing. | Mixed: Incisors for cutting, pointed canines for tearing, and molars for grinding. | 
| Jaw Movement | Side-to-side and front-to-back motion for grinding. | Simple up-and-down motion for shearing. | Versatile motion, capable of grinding and tearing. | 
| Intestine Length | Very long relative to body size to allow maximum time for plant digestion. | Short relative to body size for quick digestion of meat. | Intermediate length, balanced for digesting both plant and animal matter. | 
| Stomach Acidity | High pH, less acidic to accommodate plant fermentation. | Very low pH, highly acidic to break down meat and kill bacteria. | Moderate acidity, suitable for mixed foods. | 
A Historical Look at Modern Veganism
It is important to distinguish the evolutionary human diet from the modern ethical and dietary movement of veganism. The practice of abstaining from meat for philosophical or religious reasons dates back thousands of years to figures like Pythagoras and early Buddhist and Hindu traditions,. However, the term “vegan” and the modern movement were officially established in 1944 by Donald Watson in the United Kingdom, specifically to differentiate from vegetarians who consumed dairy and eggs. This was an entirely modern, conscious decision based on ethics and health, not a continuation of an ancestral diet.
Conclusion: The Answer is Clear
So, were humans ever vegan? The overwhelming body of evidence from anthropology, archaeology, and biology indicates that the answer is no. While our ancient ancestors relied heavily on plants, they were always opportunistic omnivores, consuming both plant and animal foods to survive and thrive across diverse environments. This omnivorous flexibility was a key evolutionary advantage, contributing to the development of our large brains and allowing our species to disperse across the globe. While a modern, well-planned vegan diet can be a healthy choice, it does not reflect the dietary patterns of our prehistoric ancestors. The human story is, and has always been, the story of an omnivore. To learn more about how scientists study prehistoric diets, visit The Australian Museum.