Understanding the Different Types of Bottled Water
Navigating the bottled water aisle can be confusing, with labels promoting a variety of attributes like 'purified,' 'spring,' and 'mineral.' Knowing the source and processing method is key to determining if a product is truly natural. The term 'natural' most accurately applies to spring water and natural mineral water, which come from protected underground sources and undergo minimal treatment.
Natural Spring Water
Spring water is derived from an underground formation from which water naturally flows to the Earth's surface. The water is collected directly at or from the spring. While it is treated to ensure microbiological safety, it retains its original mineral content. This minimal processing allows the water to maintain the unique taste profile and composition it gained from its subterranean journey through natural rock and soil.
Natural Mineral Water
Like spring water, natural mineral water originates from a protected underground source. However, it is defined by its constant and distinctive mineral composition, which must be stable and originate from the water source itself. The mineral content must remain unaltered from the source to the bottle. In the EU, for example, treatments are limited to removing unstable elements like iron, manganese, or sulfur compounds, and using ozone-enriched air. The label must state the place of origin and the source.
Purified and Other Processed Water
Many popular bottled water brands are not natural at all; they are purified water. This can come from any source, including municipal water supplies, and is then extensively treated to remove impurities. Purification methods include reverse osmosis, distillation, and deionization. Some companies may add a blend of minerals and electrolytes back in for taste, as seen with brands like Dasani and Smartwater. While safe to drink, this water lacks the naturally occurring mineral composition found in spring or mineral water.
Key Differences Between Water Types
| Feature | Natural Mineral Water | Natural Spring Water | Purified Water |
|---|---|---|---|
| Source | Protected underground aquifer/well | Underground spring formation | Any source, including tap water |
| Treatment | Minimal; may remove unstable elements, UV treated | Filtered to remove bacteria; retains original minerals | Rigorous multi-stage process (RO, distillation) |
| Mineral Content | Naturally high, constant mineral composition from source | Naturally occurring; varies by source | Removed during purification, often artificially added back |
| Taste | Distinctive, based on mineral content | Crisp, fresh; varies by source | Neutral, can taste 'flat' or metallic |
| Labeling | Specifies "Natural Mineral Water" and source | Must state "Spring Water" and location of source | Labeled "Purified" or "Drinking Water" |
Identifying a Genuinely All Natural Product
To be sure you are drinking genuinely natural bottled water, follow these steps:
- Read the Label: Look for specific phrasing such as "Natural Mineral Water" or "Natural Spring Water." If it just says "Drinking Water" or "Purified Water," it is not naturally sourced and processed.
- Check the Source: The label must legally identify the location of the spring or aquifer from which the water was drawn. Brands like Evian (French Alps), Fiji (Fiji), and Icelandic Glacial (Iceland) all clearly list their protected sources.
- Review the Mineral Analysis: Authentic mineral water labels typically provide a detailed breakdown of the mineral composition, including Total Dissolved Solids (TDS). A stable, naturally occurring mineral balance is a hallmark of natural mineral water.
- Taste Profile: True spring and mineral waters have unique flavor profiles influenced by their mineral content. For example, some may taste slightly salty, while others are earthy or crisp. Purified waters, having been stripped of their minerals, often taste flat.
Popular All Natural Bottled Water Brands
Several brands are widely recognized for their natural origins. While product ranges can vary, these are generally known for being sourced from specific, protected springs or artesian wells:
- Evian: Sourced from the French Alps, known for its specific mineral balance.
- Fiji Water: Comes from an artesian aquifer in Viti Levu, Fiji.
- Icelandic Glacial: Sourced from Iceland's Olfus Spring, known for its high natural pH.
- Mountain Valley Spring Water: Sourced from the Ouachita Mountains in Arkansas, bottled since 1871.
- Acqua Panna: Italian still mineral water from a spring in the Tuscan Apennine Mountains.
- San Pellegrino: Italian carbonated natural mineral water.
- Volvic: Natural mineral water from the Auvergne region in France.
Environmental and Health Considerations
While natural water sources offer pure, mineral-rich water, consumers should be aware of the wider context of bottled water consumption. A major concern is the environmental impact, from plastic pollution to the carbon footprint of transportation. The long-term storage of water in plastic bottles can also lead to chemical leaching, introducing substances like microplastics and phthalates into the water.
For consumers, drinking natural water from a spring can offer beneficial minerals that contribute to hydration and overall health. However, the cost of bottled water is significantly higher than tap water, and many of the minerals can be obtained through a balanced diet. Choosing natural water in glass or other sustainable packaging and recycling properly can help mitigate some environmental concerns, but the most eco-friendly option is always to use a filter on your tap water.
Conclusion Choosing bottled water that is all natural means opting for spring or mineral water. These waters are sourced from protected underground formations and retain their innate mineral content with minimal processing. Brands like Evian, Fiji, and Icelandic Glacial are reliable examples. By carefully reading labels, consumers can distinguish between genuinely natural products and purified tap water, ensuring they get the purity and mineral benefits they seek. As with any product, balancing personal preferences with environmental impact is key to making a responsible choice. For more details on regulatory standards, the FDA maintains strict guidelines on bottled water labeling, which can be found in the Code of Federal Regulations.