Skip to content

What Happens if We Consume Silicon? Separating Fact from Fiction

4 min read

While silicon is the second most abundant element in Earth's crust, what happens if we consume silicon largely depends on its form. The elemental form used in electronics and toxic industrial compounds like silicon carbide pose dangers, whereas the common dietary form, silica, is safely processed by the body and is a key nutrient.

Quick Summary

This article explains the different forms of silicon and their effects on the human body, clarifying the distinction between elemental/industrial silicon and common dietary silica. It covers health implications, safe consumption levels, and potential risks associated with inhalation or accidental exposure to harmful forms.

Key Points

  • Form Matters: The health effects of consuming silicon depend entirely on its chemical form, distinguishing safe dietary silica from harmful industrial silicon or synthetic silicones.

  • Dietary Silica is Beneficial: The silicon naturally found as silica (silicon dioxide) in whole grains, fruits, and vegetables is safely absorbed and helps build healthy bones and connective tissues.

  • Industrial Silicon is Toxic: Inhaling crystalline silica dust is highly dangerous, leading to severe and irreversible lung diseases like silicosis.

  • Synthetic Silicones Have Risks: While approved for cookware, some evidence suggests synthetic silicone can leach harmful compounds, especially under high heat or with fatty foods.

  • Body Safely Excretes Dietary Form: In healthy individuals, excess water-soluble silica consumed from food is efficiently excreted by the kidneys, preventing accumulation.

  • Accidental Ingestion Can be Dangerous: Swallowing non-food-grade silicone or industrial silicon is not recommended and can cause internal damage or toxicity, requiring immediate medical attention.

  • Symptoms of Silicone Toxicity: Leakage from silicone implants can cause serious autoimmune symptoms like chronic fatigue, joint pain, and brain fog.

In This Article

Understanding the Forms of Silicon

Most people are familiar with silicon (Si) as the element used in computer chips, but this is different from what is encountered in food. The key distinction is between pure elemental silicon, silicon compounds, and synthetic silicone materials.

Elemental silicon is a semi-metallic substance rarely found in nature. Ingesting this in its raw form is extremely unlikely, and the abrasive, sharp edges of its industrial counterpart, silicon carbide, could cause internal damage. Silicone, a synthetic polymer used in bakeware, implants, and sealants, is generally considered safe but can leach harmful siloxanes when exposed to extreme heat or fatty foods. On the other hand, the dietary form of silicon is silica, or silicon dioxide (SiO2), a natural compound of silicon and oxygen found widely in plants and water.

The Role of Dietary Silica (Silicon Dioxide)

Dietary silica is naturally present in many plant-based foods, including whole grains, green beans, and leafy greens. This is the form your body can absorb, and it plays a surprising role in health. Research has shown that dietary silicon is essential for the synthesis of collagen, a crucial protein for connective tissues, bones, hair, and nails. Studies also suggest a link between higher silicon intake and increased bone mineral density. When consumed in food or regulated supplements, silica is absorbed by the intestines, and any excess is safely flushed out by the kidneys within hours in healthy individuals.

Dangers of Industrial and Synthetic Silicones

While dietary silica is largely harmless, exposure to industrial forms can be toxic. Inhalation of crystalline silica dust, common in occupations like mining and construction, can lead to serious lung diseases like silicosis, lung cancer, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Similarly, injecting liquid silicone for cosmetic purposes is dangerous and can cause serious health complications. The safety of synthetic silicone products, such as cookware, is also under scrutiny. While approved for food contact, some studies have found that siloxanes can leach into food, especially at high temperatures and when in contact with fatty substances.

The Risk of Accidental Ingestion

What if you accidentally consume a non-food-grade silicone product? In most cases, if it's a small, non-reactive solid piece, it will likely pass through the digestive system without harm, though larger or sharp pieces could cause irritation. If liquid silicone is ingested, it should be treated as a medical emergency as it may block blood vessels and cause severe consequences. The key is to differentiate between the forms and their intended uses. Food-grade silicone for kitchenware is different from industrial-grade silicone sealants or lubricants, which should never be consumed.

Potential Health Effects and Considerations

Type of Silicon Compound Typical Exposure Route Potential Health Effects
Dietary Silica (in food/supplements) Oral Ingestion Generally safe; enhances bone, hair, skin, and nail health.
Crystalline Silica (dust) Inhalation Severe lung damage (silicosis, COPD), autoimmune diseases, cancer.
Liquid Silicone (implants/injections) Injections, Implant Leakage Autoimmune disorders, cancer risk (BIA-ALCL), systemic illness.
Synthetic Silicone (cookware) Oral Ingestion (leaching) Low-level leaching of siloxanes, especially with heat and fat.
Silicon Carbide (industrial) Ingestion, Inhalation Abrasive damage to digestive tract, pneumoconiosis from dust.

How Your Body Processes Different Silicon Compounds

Your body's ability to process and excrete silicon depends on its chemical form. Water-soluble orthosilicic acid, found in plant-based foods, is readily absorbed in the intestinal tract and then efficiently eliminated by the kidneys. In contrast, large, polymerized silica molecules and elemental silicon are poorly absorbed. In healthy individuals with functioning kidneys, an accumulation of dietary silicon is unlikely. However, this natural filtration system is ineffective against inhaled crystalline silica dust, which can become trapped in the lungs and cause progressive, irreversible damage over time. The body's immune response to silicone implants is also a different mechanism, leading to systemic inflammation and other symptoms.

Conclusion: A Matter of Context and Form

In conclusion, understanding what happens if we consume silicon requires careful attention to its chemical form and context. Consuming silica as part of a healthy diet is not only safe but may offer benefits for bone and connective tissue health. The risks are primarily associated with the accidental ingestion of non-food-grade silicones or, more significantly, the inhalation of industrial silica dust in occupational settings. Always prioritize food sources of dietary silica and be mindful of proper usage for all products containing silicon-based materials. If you have concerns about silicon exposure or suspect an adverse reaction, seeking professional medical advice is the safest course of action. For more information on the dangers of inhaled silica dust, visit the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) [https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/silica/default.html].

Frequently Asked Questions

No, silicon dioxide used as a food additive (E551) to prevent clumping is generally considered safe for consumption by regulatory bodies like the FDA and EFSA, which have set limits on its use.

No, silicosis is a lung disease caused by inhaling crystalline silica dust, not from ingesting dietary silica. The body processes and excretes dietary silica safely.

Silicon (Si) is a natural chemical element, while silicone is a synthetic polymer derived from silicon, oxygen, and other elements. They have very different chemical and physical properties.

Food-grade silicone bakeware is deemed safe for cooking under normal conditions. However, some studies suggest that prolonged exposure to very high temperatures, especially with fatty foods, can cause some chemical leaching.

Ingesting industrial silicon, such as silicon carbide, is dangerous. Its abrasive, sharp particles can irritate or damage the digestive tract, and repeated ingestion is not recommended.

Yes, silicon is an essential trace mineral involved in forming collagen and mineralizing bones. Our bodies get a sufficient supply from a balanced diet rich in whole grains, fruits, and vegetables.

Silicon from food is unlikely to cause an overdose, as excess amounts are excreted by the kidneys. While oral toxicity is low, it's best to consult a healthcare provider before taking high-dose supplements, as long-term effects are not well-studied.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.