The Defining Factor: Myoglobin
The most significant factor determining whether a meat is red or white is its myoglobin content. Myoglobin is an iron-containing protein in muscle tissue that stores and carries oxygen. The more active the muscle, the higher its oxygen demand and, consequently, its myoglobin concentration. This is why flightless birds like chickens have white breast meat (less used muscle) and darker thigh and leg meat (more used muscle). In mammals, the muscles are generally used more extensively for movement, resulting in uniformly higher myoglobin levels and red-colored meat. White meat contains far less myoglobin, which is why it appears paler both before and after cooking.
The Role of Myoglobin in Meat Color
- High Myoglobin: Leads to a deep red color. Associated with red meats like beef and venison.
- Low Myoglobin: Leads to a pale or whitish color. Characteristic of white meats like chicken breast.
- Exposure to Oxygen: Myoglobin turns bright red when exposed to oxygen, a reason raw meat changes color when packaged.
What is Not White Meat? The Red Meat Category
Based on myoglobin and standard classifications by nutritional and health organizations, several meats are definitively not white meat:
- Beef: Coming from cattle, beef is a classic example of red meat, with high myoglobin content giving it a deep cherry-red color.
- Veal: Although younger cattle produce paler meat with less myoglobin than beef, it is still classified as red meat because it comes from a mammal.
- Lamb and Mutton: Meat from sheep is always considered red meat, with lamb being the meat from younger sheep and mutton from older ones.
- Pork: As officially classified by the USDA, pork is red meat, despite some cuts appearing pale when cooked. This is due to its myoglobin content being higher than poultry or fish.
- Venison: The meat of deer and other wild game is also red meat, known for its deep color and distinct flavor.
- Goat: Similar to other mammals, goat meat is a red meat, though often leaner than beef or lamb.
The Case of Pork: "The Other White Meat" Misconception
In the late 1980s, the National Pork Board launched a highly successful marketing campaign with the slogan, "Pork. The other white meat". This campaign was designed to promote leaner cuts of pork and capitalize on the growing health-consciousness of consumers. While it significantly influenced public perception, it created a lasting confusion that persists today. From a scientific and regulatory standpoint, including by the USDA, pork is and has always been red meat because it is livestock and contains higher levels of myoglobin than poultry or fish.
Seafood and Meat Classification
Seafood presents a unique case, as it is treated as a separate category by many food authorities, including the USDA, and is not classified as either red or white meat in the traditional sense. However, based on color, some fish could be colloquially divided:
- Dark-Fleshed Fish: Certain species, such as tuna and salmon, have flesh that appears red or pink due to compounds from their diet. While they contain myoglobin, they are not categorized as mammalian red meat.
- White-Fleshed Fish: Many fish, including cod, halibut, and tilapia, are known for their pale, flaky flesh. These are not considered red meat.
A Comparison of Meat Classifications
| Feature | Red Meat (e.g., Beef, Lamb) | Pork | White Meat (e.g., Chicken Breast) | Seafood (e.g., Salmon) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Source Animal | Mammals (cattle, sheep) | Mammal (pig) | Avians (chicken, turkey) | Fish, shellfish |
| Myoglobin Level | High | Higher than poultry/fish | Low | Varies (e.g., high in tuna) |
| Raw Appearance | Dark red | Grayish-pink | Bluish-white to yellow | Varies (red/pink to white) |
| Cooked Appearance | Darker pink/brown | Can be paler/white | White | Varies (remains pink or turns white) |
| Culinary View | Generally red meat | Traditionally white meat | White meat | Considered separate |
| Nutritional/Scientific View | Red meat | Red meat (livestock) | White meat | Considered separate |
Navigating Culinary vs. Scientific Definitions
Understanding what is not considered white meat often depends on the context. A chef might use the terms red and white meat based on tradition or how a certain cut cooks, while a nutritionist will rely on scientific classifications based on myoglobin content and animal type. This is why pork is traditionally cooked like a white meat but classified nutritionally as red meat. It's important to be aware of the distinction, especially when adhering to specific dietary guidelines.
Conclusion
Ultimately, what is not considered white meat encompasses all red meats from mammals, such as beef, veal, lamb, goat, and venison. Pork, despite a long-standing marketing campaign suggesting otherwise, is also scientifically classified as a red meat by organizations like the USDA. Furthermore, seafood is generally considered a distinct category. The core determinant is the level of myoglobin, the protein responsible for a meat's red color. The next time you're at the butcher or reading a health article, you'll know that the classification of red vs. white meat is more about biology than just how it looks on your plate.
For more detailed information on government classifications, visit the USDA Ask website.