The Role of Oral Rehydration in Clinical Nutrition
Oral rehydration solutions (ORS) are vital for managing dehydration by replacing lost fluids and electrolytes. While many commercial products are available for general use, specific clinical conditions, such as intestinal failure or high-output stomas, require a specialized approach. These unique nutritional needs are the reason St Mark's solution was developed, setting it apart from standard preparations like Dioralyte. Understanding the differences is critical for ensuring patients receive appropriate care based on their specific health status.
What is St Mark's solution?
Developed at St Mark's Hospital in London, St Mark's solution is a potent, potassium-free ORS designed for patients with complex gastrointestinal conditions, most notably short bowel syndrome (SBS) and intestinal failure. SBS and related conditions impair the small intestine's ability to absorb water and electrolytes, leading to significant fluid and sodium loss. Regular ORS or plain water can worsen dehydration by drawing sodium from the body into the bowel, but the high sodium concentration in St Mark's solution counteracts this effect, boosting fluid absorption and minimizing fluid losses.
St Mark's solution is not available commercially; patients must prepare it fresh daily using a specific recipe. The ingredients are typically purchased from supermarkets or pharmacies. The standard recipe for one litre of solution includes:
- 20g of glucose powder
- 3.5g of sodium chloride (table salt)
- 2.5g of sodium bicarbonate (baking soda)
Patients are advised to sip the solution slowly throughout the day. Because the sodium bicarbonate can give the solution a bitter taste, chilling it, sipping through a straw, or adding a small amount of low-sugar squash can improve palatability. In some cases, sodium citrate is used as a substitute for sodium bicarbonate if the taste is intolerable.
What is Dioralyte?
Dioralyte is a brand of commercially available ORS sachets used for correcting fluid and electrolyte losses. It is widely used for treating dehydration resulting from diarrhoea, vomiting, or excessive sweating, such as during intense exercise. Dioralyte is formulated according to standard guidelines for general dehydration and includes a balance of key electrolytes, including potassium, which is not present in St Mark's solution.
Available in different flavours and formulations, such as Dioralyte Relief which contains rice starch to help harden stools, Dioralyte is intended for a broader range of patients, including adults and children. While effective for general use, its lower sodium content and inclusion of potassium make it unsuitable for the specific high-sodium, potassium-free requirements of patients with severe intestinal failure.
St Mark's vs Dioralyte: A Comparative Table
| Feature | St Mark's Solution | Dioralyte | 
|---|---|---|
| Primary Use Case | Clinical conditions like Short Bowel Syndrome, intestinal failure, and high-output stomas. | General dehydration from diarrhoea, vomiting, or exercise. | 
| Availability | Prepared at home from individual ingredients; not commercially sold. | Commercially available in pre-measured sachets from pharmacies and supermarkets. | 
| Sodium Concentration | High (approx. 90-120 mmol/L) to boost absorption in compromised intestines. | Standard (approx. 60 mmol/L in some formulations), sufficient for general rehydration. | 
| Potassium Content | Potassium-free, crucial for patients at risk of hyperkalaemia. | Contains potassium (approx. 20 mmol/L), a necessary electrolyte for most people. | 
| Preparation | Needs to be made fresh daily with accurate measurements of powders and water. | Simply dissolve one sachet in 200ml of water. | 
| Taste | Can be salty or bitter, often needs flavouring additives like small amounts of squash. | Comes in pre-formulated flavours to improve palatability. | 
Preparation and Administration: The Critical Differences
Patient safety and treatment efficacy depend on understanding the distinct preparation methods for each solution. For St Mark's solution, precise measurement is non-negotiable. Using standard measuring spoons as directed by a healthcare professional is vital, as incorrect ratios can diminish its effectiveness. Drinking it chilled or through a straw can improve the taste, which can be challenging for some due to the high sodium content. Patients with intestinal failure should avoid drinking plain water or low-sodium fluids, which can exacerbate fluid loss.
Dioralyte, on the other hand, is a simple, ready-to-mix solution. The sachet's convenience makes it a quick and accessible option for addressing fluid loss. However, it's crucial to follow the instructions for reconstitution correctly to maintain the right electrolyte balance. Using the wrong amount of water will render the solution ineffective.
The Importance of Specialised Nutritional Guidance
The comparison between St Mark's solution and Dioralyte highlights the need for specialized nutritional guidance in clinical care. While Dioralyte is an excellent and readily available tool for managing common dehydration, it is not a substitute for the customized, high-sodium, potassium-free formula of St Mark's solution required by patients with intestinal failure. The development of solutions like St Mark's was a direct response to the inadequacy of standard treatments for a vulnerable patient population. Always consult a doctor or dietitian before choosing or preparing any ORS for a specific medical condition.
Conclusion
While both St Mark's solution and Dioralyte are oral rehydration therapies, they serve fundamentally different purposes and patient populations. St Mark's solution is a clinical-grade, homemade, high-sodium, potassium-free formula for managing severe intestinal fluid loss in conditions like short bowel syndrome. In contrast, Dioralyte is a commercially available, balanced electrolyte mix for treating standard dehydration from conditions like diarrhoea. The distinction underscores how a 'nutrition diet' can be a highly tailored aspect of medical care, moving beyond general advice to meet precise and life-sustaining needs. For further clinical guidance on St Mark's solution, resources from organizations like the NHS are invaluable.
- Outbound link: Using St Mark's electrolyte solution – SPS