What is the best my protein powder flavour? A Guide to Finding Your Perfect Shake

October 17, 2025 •

4 min read

According to Myprotein's own data and widespread community reviews, classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate frequently rank among the most popular choices, providing a versatile and reliable protein source. Finding what is the best my protein powder flavour ultimately depends on your personal taste, mix-in preferences, and desired shake type.

Quick Summary

This guide compares top-rated Myprotein protein powder flavors, covering creamy Impact Whey classics and refreshing Clear Whey alternatives. Learn how to choose the right flavor for your goals based on taste profile, mixability, and community feedback.

Key Points

Chocolate Smooth: A versatile and consistently popular classic that delivers a creamy, milkshake-like flavor.
Clear Whey Options: For a light, refreshing, and juice-like alternative to creamy shakes, popular choices include Vimto and Orange Mango.
Vanilla's Versatility: The vanilla flavor is perfect for mixing with other ingredients in smoothies or baking, as its neutral taste won't overpower other components.
Test with Sample Packs: Before buying a large bag, trying sample sachets is the most cost-effective way to find a flavor you love without risk.
Taste Is Subjective: The 'best' flavor varies by individual preference, so community recommendations are a helpful starting point but not a definitive answer.
Salted Caramel: A consistently well-liked and indulgent dessert-inspired flavor with a balance of sweet and savory notes.

While asking what is the best my protein powder flavour is a common question, the answer is far from one-size-fits-all. Myprotein offers a vast array of flavors across its different product lines, from the traditional, milkshake-style Impact Whey to the light, juice-like Clear Whey Isolate. Your perfect flavor depends on several factors, including whether you prefer classic, indulgent tastes or something more refreshing, and how you plan to use your protein powder.

The Classics: Best Myprotein Impact Whey Flavours

Myprotein's Impact Whey protein is the brand's flagship product, known for its milky, satisfying texture and a wide selection of dessert-inspired and traditional flavors. These are often best when mixed with milk or used in recipes for a richer result.

Chocolate Smooth: A consistent fan favorite, this flavor provides a rich, creamy chocolate taste that many compare to a classic chocolate milkshake. It's a reliable all-rounder that mixes well with milk or water.
Vanilla: Often cited for its versatility, vanilla offers a subtle sweetness that makes it a perfect base for smoothies, oatmeal, and baking. For those who get bored of intense flavors, vanilla is a dependable and easy-to-use option.
Chocolate Brownie: For a richer and more intense chocolate experience, Chocolate Brownie is a top contender. It delivers a deep, dessert-like cocoa flavor that testers often praise for its indulgence.
Salted Caramel: A perennial favorite for those who enjoy a mix of sweet and savory, Salted Caramel offers a rich, butterscotch-like flavor with a hint of salt. It is often praised as a standout flavor for both shakes and baking.
Cookies & Cream: This flavor is a popular choice for sweet-toothed users, providing a creamy, vanilla-based flavor with cookie pieces. However, reviews are mixed, with some finding it too sweet or the flavor artificial.
Chocolate Mint: This cult classic offers a refreshing, ice-cream-like combination of rich chocolate and cool mint. It's a great post-workout option for a refreshing treat, especially when mixed with milk.

Something Different: Top Clear Whey Isolate Flavours

For those who prefer a lighter, more juice-like protein drink, Myprotein's Clear Whey Isolate is the perfect alternative. It delivers a high protein content without the milky, creamy texture of traditional whey. These are ideal for refreshing post-workout shakes or for a lighter protein boost throughout the day.

Orange Mango: A clear winner in community polls, Orange Mango is a tropical, summery flavor that provides a refreshing and flavorful experience. It's an excellent choice for a hot day.
Vimto: This popular British soda-inspired flavor is a fan-favorite, offering a distinct berry and blackcurrant taste that is both nostalgic and refreshing.
Cranberry & Raspberry: A juicy and tart flavor that tastes similar to squash or juice, making it a very easy and light protein drink.
Peach Tea: For those who prefer a subtler, tea-based flavor, Peach Tea offers a light and refreshing option that many users enjoy.
Mojito: With its zesty lime and cooling mint notes, this flavor is a favorite for creating mocktail-style protein drinks.

Comparison of Popular Myprotein Flavours


Flavour	Type	Best Mixed With	Typical Feedback
Chocolate Smooth	Impact Whey	Milk or Water	Classic, versatile, tastes like milkshake.
Vanilla	Impact Whey	Smoothies, Oats, Milk	Neutral and versatile, great for mixing.
Salted Caramel	Impact Whey	Milk or Oats	Rich, sweet and salty, dessert-like.
Cookies & Cream	Impact Whey	Milk	Sweet, dessert-like, but can be too sweet for some.
Orange Mango	Clear Whey	Water	Refreshing, tropical, juice-like.
Vimto	Clear Whey	Water	Nostalgic, fruity, like the soda.
Peach Tea	Clear Whey	Water	Light, subtle tea flavor, refreshing.
Chocolate Mint	Impact Whey	Milk	Rich, minty, similar to ice cream.

How to Choose the Best Myprotein Flavour for You

With such a wide variety, finding the right flavor is about more than just reading reviews. Consider these factors to narrow down your options:

Your Preferred Mix: Do you primarily mix your protein with milk for a rich shake, or water for a leaner option? Impact Whey flavors like Chocolate Smooth perform well in both, while Clear Whey flavors like Orange Mango are specifically designed for water.
Use-Case Versatility: If you plan on adding protein to many different recipes—such as oatmeal, smoothies, or baked goods—a versatile flavor like vanilla is a great choice. Its neutral profile won't overpower other ingredients. For shakes-only drinkers, you can be more adventurous with dessert flavors like Chocolate Brownie.
Sweetness Preference: Some users find Myprotein's flavors quite sweet, especially some of the dessert or fruit flavors. If you are sensitive to sweetness, consider starting with the standard Vanilla or Natural Chocolate options, which are often less intense, or use sample sachets first.
Test with Sample Packs: The best way to avoid committing to a large bag of a flavor you don't like is to purchase a sample pack. These small sachets allow you to taste a variety of options without breaking the bank and are especially useful for testing unique or divisive flavors.

Navigating Flavour Preferences: Community Insights

Community forums like Reddit can offer valuable insights into user experiences beyond official reviews. For example, some users have reported mixed experiences with flavors like Cookies & Cream, while others praise unique options like Pistachio. The popularity of Clear Whey flavors is particularly highlighted in these communities for their refreshing change from traditional milky shakes.

Conclusion: The Final Verdict

Ultimately, there is no single best Myprotein flavor. The ideal choice is a personal preference based on your taste, how you plan to consume it, and whether you prefer a creamy milkshake or a refreshing juice-like drink. For those who enjoy a traditional, rich shake, Chocolate Smooth and Salted Caramel remain consistently popular and well-regarded choices among Impact Whey users. If you prefer a lighter, more hydrating protein option, a fruity Clear Whey flavor like Orange Mango is an excellent and widely praised alternative. For the undecided, purchasing a variety of sample sachets is the smartest strategy to find a flavor that you'll genuinely enjoy every day.

Frequently Asked Questions

For those who mix with water, Clear Whey Isolate flavors like Orange Mango and Vimto are excellent choices, as they are designed to be refreshing and juice-like. For Impact Whey, many users find Chocolate Smooth or Vanilla to be palatable with water, though the creamy texture is reduced.

Myprotein offers sample sachets of many of their flavors. Purchasing these is a smart way to try different options and determine your preference before committing to a larger, more expensive bag.

Vanilla is generally more versatile because its neutral flavor profile blends well with a wider variety of ingredients, such as fruits, vegetables, and other flavorings. Chocolate is more pronounced and works best in dessert-focused mixes.

Impact Whey flavors are designed to be rich and creamy, similar to a milkshake, while Clear Whey Isolate flavors are light, refreshing, and taste more like fruit juice or squash. The choice depends on whether you prefer a milky or a clear, light protein drink.

Many Myprotein flavors are on the sweeter side, especially the dessert-inspired options, which some users find too sweet. For a less sweet taste, consider the 'Natural' versions or start with a classic flavor like Vanilla, which offers a more balanced sweetness.

Top-rated fruity Clear Whey flavors include Orange Mango, Vimto, Cranberry & Raspberry, and Peach Tea, all praised for their refreshing and juicy taste.

Popular dessert-like flavors from the Impact Whey range include Salted Caramel, Chocolate Brownie, and Cookies & Cream. These provide a rich and satisfying sweet taste.