Skip to content

What is the difference between feed and concentrate?

5 min read

According to the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), concentrates made up about a quarter of all animal feed globally in the mid-1980s. While all concentrates are a type of feed, not all feeds are concentrates. Understanding the difference between feed and concentrate is crucial for balancing livestock diets for optimal health and productivity.

Quick Summary

An overview of animal nutrition, distinguishing between the broad category of "feed" and the specific, nutrient-dense subset known as "concentrate." It covers their distinct compositions, functions in animal diets, and common examples for various livestock.

Key Points

  • Definition: 'Feed' is a general term for all animal food, while 'concentrate' is a specific, nutrient-dense component used to supplement a base diet.

  • Nutrient Density: Concentrates are high in digestible nutrients (energy and/or protein) and low in fiber, unlike many roughage-based feeds.

  • Dietary Role: The primary function of a concentrate is to boost the nutrient intake of high-producing animals, complementing the bulk provided by roughage.

  • Examples: Cereal grains (corn, barley), oilseed meals (soybean meal), and molasses are examples of concentrates, while hay and pasture are roughage feeds.

  • Species Application: Concentrates are a crucial part of the diet for monogastric animals (poultry, pigs) and a supplement for ruminants (cows, sheep).

  • Digestive Health: For ruminants, a correct balance of roughage is necessary to maintain proper rumen function, which can be disrupted by all-concentrate diets.

In This Article

Feed: The General Term for Animal Nutrition

In simple terms, "feed" is a broad, overarching category that includes any and all materials an animal consumes for sustenance. It is the foundation of any livestock diet, providing the energy, protein, vitamins, and minerals necessary for survival, growth, and production. Feed can come in many forms, from simple grazing on pasture grasses to manufactured mixtures.

Examples of Feed

  • Roughage (Forage): This includes high-fiber plant materials like hay, silage, and pasture grass. Roughages are the staple diet for ruminants, which have evolved to digest fibrous plant matter efficiently. While low in digestible nutrients and energy, they are vital for maintaining proper rumen function.
  • Grains: Cereal grains such as corn, wheat, and oats serve as energy-rich feed sources.
  • By-products: Various by-products from human food production, including brewery grains, cottonseed hulls, and molasses, are also used as feed ingredients.

Concentrate: The Nutrient-Dense Supplement

Concentrates are a specific type of feed characterized by their high concentration of digestible nutrients and low fiber content. Their primary purpose is to supplement the base diet, often roughage, to boost an animal's intake of energy, protein, vitamins, or minerals. This is especially critical for animals with high production demands, such as high-yielding dairy cows or rapidly growing meat animals.

Types of Concentrates

  • Energy Concentrates: These are typically high in carbohydrates and fats. Common examples include cereal grains like maize and barley.
  • Protein Concentrates: Containing over 15% crude protein, these are used to increase protein intake. Examples include soybean meal, cottonseed meal, and fish meal.
  • Vitamin and Mineral Concentrates: These mixtures provide essential micronutrients that may be deficient in the basal diet.

The Importance of Concentrates

Concentrates are strategically used to maximize animal performance. For dairy cattle, they can increase milk production, while for beef cattle, they promote faster growth. For monogastric animals like pigs and poultry, which cannot efficiently digest high-fiber roughage, concentrates often form the majority of their diet. The precise formulation of concentrates ensures balanced nutrition, reduces waste, and improves feed efficiency.

The Difference in Practice: A Comparison

While feed is the general term for all animal food, concentrates are a specific, nutrient-dense subset used to enhance a base diet. The distinction is not merely semantic; it guides fundamental decisions in animal husbandry and nutrition.

Comparison Table: Feed (Roughage) vs. Concentrate

Feature Feed (Roughage) Concentrate
Fiber Content High (over 18% crude fiber) Low (less than 18% crude fiber)
Nutrient Density Low High
Energy Content Low High
Digestibility Varies, generally lower due to fiber High, providing easily accessible nutrients
Primary Role Provides bulk and maintains rumen function Supplements energy, protein, vitamins, and minerals
Examples Hay, pasture grass, silage, straw Cereal grains, soybean meal, molasses
Primary Use Staple diet for ruminants Supplement for high-production animals; primary diet for monogastrics
Cost Often more affordable, especially when locally sourced Higher per unit of weight due to processing

How to Select the Right Balance

Choosing the correct balance between roughage and concentrate depends on several factors, including the type of animal, its production goals, and the quality of available forage. For high-producing dairy cows, a significant portion of the diet may consist of concentrates to meet energy demands, while maintenance animals on good pasture may require little to no supplementation.

Key considerations for feed balancing:

  • Animal Type: Ruminants (cows, sheep) require more roughage, while monogastrics (pigs, poultry) depend heavily on concentrates.
  • Production Stage: A lactating cow has higher nutrient needs than a dry cow, necessitating more concentrates.
  • Forage Quality: If the quality of hay or pasture is poor, more concentrate will be needed to compensate for nutrient deficiencies.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: Finding the most cost-effective way to meet nutritional needs is key, balancing expensive concentrates with affordable roughage.

Conclusion

While the terms "feed" and "concentrate" are often used in the context of animal nutrition, they are not interchangeable. "Feed" is the general term for any edible material given to animals, whereas "concentrate" is a specific, nutrient-dense component used to enhance the overall diet. Concentrates are essential for modern high-yield animal production, providing a concentrated source of energy, protein, and micronutrients. A balanced feeding program that correctly incorporates both roughage and concentrates is fundamental to ensuring livestock health, optimizing productivity, and achieving economic efficiency in farming operations. By understanding this key difference, farmers can make more informed decisions about their animals' dietary needs, leading to improved performance and overall well-being.

Choosing a Horse Feed: complete feeds, balancers & supplements

For further reading and a deeper dive into the specific application for horses, consider exploring resources on balanced equine diets. The principles of balancing different feed components apply across species, though specific requirements vary.

Choosing a Horse Feed: complete feeds, balancers & supplements

Summary of Key Differences

  • Feed vs. Concentrate: Feed is the general term for any animal food, while concentrate is a specific feed type that is high in nutrients and low in fiber.
  • Roughage: A major component of feed, roughage is high in fiber and low in energy, crucial for ruminant digestion.
  • Nutrient Density: Concentrates are formulated to provide high levels of protein, energy, vitamins, and minerals.
  • Dietary Role: Concentrates supplement a base diet of roughage to meet specific production goals, such as milk yield or weight gain.
  • Animal Adaptation: Ruminants rely on roughage for rumen function, whereas monogastric animals depend more heavily on concentrates.
  • Strategic Feeding: The proportion of concentrate to roughage must be carefully managed based on the animal's needs and life stage.

FAQs

Q: Is forage the same as feed? A: Forage is a type of feed, but it is not the same as feed in general. Forage refers to high-fiber plant material like grass and hay, while feed is a broader term for anything an animal eats for nourishment.

Q: Can I feed my animals only concentrates? A: Feeding an all-concentrate diet is generally not recommended, especially for ruminants, as it can lead to digestive issues like rumen acidosis. A proper balance of roughage is necessary to maintain digestive health and function.

Q: What are some examples of concentrates? A: Common examples of concentrates include cereal grains like corn and barley, protein-rich supplements such as soybean meal, and various processed by-products like molasses.

Q: Why is fiber important for ruminant animals? A: Fiber is essential for ruminants because it promotes rumination (chewing cud), which stimulates saliva production. Saliva acts as a natural buffer that helps maintain a healthy pH in the rumen for optimal microbial digestion.

Q: Do monogastric animals, like pigs and poultry, require roughage? A: Unlike ruminants, monogastric animals have limited ability to digest high-fiber roughage. Therefore, their diets consist of a much higher proportion of nutrient-dense concentrates to meet their nutritional needs efficiently.

Q: How do I know the right feed-to-concentrate ratio for my animals? A: The ideal ratio depends on the animal species, age, weight, and production stage. It is best to consult with an animal nutritionist or follow manufacturer guidelines for specific feeding recommendations.

Q: Can concentrates reduce feed waste? A: Yes, well-formulated concentrates can minimize feed waste. Their compact and balanced nature ensures animals receive the exact nutrients they need, leading to better feed utilization and efficiency compared to lower-quality, less-dense feeds.

Frequently Asked Questions

The main difference is scope: "feed" is a broad term for any food an animal consumes, while "concentrate" refers to a specific, high-nutrient, low-fiber feed type that is often used to supplement a base diet.

Roughage, such as hay or grass, is high in fiber and low in digestible energy, which puts it in the general category of 'feed.' Concentrates, by definition, have the opposite characteristics—they are low in fiber and high in nutrients.

Concentrates are used to meet the high nutrient demands of specific animals, such as dairy cows during peak lactation, growing calves, or livestock being fattened for meat. They supplement the nutrients that a basal diet of roughage may lack.

You can mix concentrates yourself with raw ingredients like grains and meals, but commercial premixed concentrates are available for simpler and more accurate formulation, ensuring all necessary vitamins and minerals are included.

Feeding too much concentrate, especially to ruminants, can lead to serious digestive problems, including acidosis, which can impair rumen function and negatively affect animal health and productivity.

Yes, concentrates are typically more expensive per unit of weight than roughage due to their higher nutrient density and the processing involved. However, they are often more cost-effective when factoring in the efficiency gained in high-production scenarios.

Ruminants, like cattle, have a specialized digestive system that requires a high-fiber, roughage-based diet to function correctly. Monogastric animals, like poultry, have a single-chambered stomach and require a nutrient-dense, low-fiber diet, often composed mostly of concentrates.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.