Skip to content

What is the Healthiest Thing to Drink with Whiskey?

4 min read

Contrary to popular belief, a whiskey cocktail doesn't have to be a sugar bomb. The quest for the healthiest thing to drink with whiskey leads to simple, low-calorie mixers that enhance flavor without the extra sugar and calories found in many traditional mixers.

Quick Summary

This article explores the best low-sugar and low-calorie mixers for whiskey, focusing on water, club soda, and herbal infusions to create delicious, guilt-free cocktails. Includes a comparison of mixers.

Key Points

  • Purest Mixer: Water or ice is the simplest, zero-calorie way to enjoy whiskey, allowing its flavors to shine through with minimal additives.

  • Bubbly Alternative: Club soda or seltzer provides a refreshing fizz without the sugar or calories found in other carbonated drinks, making a perfect highball.

  • Flavor Infusions: Add flavor naturally with unsweetened tea, fresh herbs like mint or rosemary, or citrus peels, rather than relying on sugary syrups or juices.

  • Avoid Sugary Additions: Skip high-calorie mixers like cola, sweet and sour mix, and juice to drastically reduce the sugar and empty calories in your drink.

  • Prioritize Moderation: The healthiest approach is always responsible and moderate consumption, regardless of the mixer. Excessive drinking poses significant health risks.

In This Article

Why Your Mixer Choice Matters

When you're looking for the healthiest thing to drink with whiskey, the most crucial factor is avoiding sugary, high-calorie mixers. Traditional options like cola, sweet and sour mix, and creamy liqueurs can quickly turn a relatively low-calorie spirit into a dessert-like indulgence that is high in sugar and empty calories. Whiskey itself, when consumed in moderation, is a spirit with no carbohydrates and a moderate calorie count. The true health impact comes from what you add to it. By choosing a simple, low-sugar mixer, you can enjoy the complex flavors of your favorite whiskey while maintaining your health goals.

The Top Healthiest Whiskey Mixers

Water: The Purest Choice

For the purist, a simple addition of water or ice is the most straightforward and healthiest choice. This method, often referred to as 'on the rocks' or with a 'splash', adds zero calories and zero sugar. The addition of a few drops of water can actually enhance the whiskey's flavor profile by interacting with its esters, revealing more delicate aromas and softening its intensity. Adding ice also chills and dilutes the spirit, making it a smoother, more refreshing drink.

Club Soda or Seltzer: The Bubbly Solution

For those who prefer a little fizz, club soda or plain seltzer is an excellent, calorie-free alternative to sugary sodas. The bubbles lengthen the drink without overwhelming the whiskey's character, creating a crisp and refreshing highball. Adding a citrus twist, like a lemon or orange peel, provides extra aroma and flavor without a single calorie from sugar. This is a fantastic choice for a hot day or for those who want a lighter, longer-lasting drink.

Tea: The Warm and Soothing Option

For a comforting and flavorful mix, consider using tea. A hot toddy, made with whiskey, hot water, lemon, and a small amount of honey or ginger, is a classic for a reason. By controlling the amount of sweetener, you can create a warm, soothing drink that provides flavor without excessive sugar. Iced tea is another option, pairing surprisingly well with whiskey and offering a mellow, smooth base. Peach or ginger tea can add a pleasant flavor dimension.

Fresh Citrus and Spices: The Zesty Additions

For those who enjoy a more complex flavor, incorporating fresh ingredients is a great strategy. A squeeze of fresh lemon or lime juice adds a refreshing, tangy kick, as seen in a low-sugar whiskey sour. For an aromatic twist, muddle a few fresh mint leaves, or add a sprig of rosemary or a cinnamon stick. These additions provide significant flavor and aroma for minimal, if any, calories. A dash of bitters can also add complexity and depth without contributing to the sugar content.

Comparison Table: Healthy vs. Unhealthy Whiskey Mixers

Mixer Calories (approx. per serving) Sugar Content (approx. per serving) Health Impact
Water 0 0g Pure, simple, no additives. Enhances flavor.
Club Soda/Seltzer 0 0g Adds fizz without calories. Great for highballs.
Diet Soda 0 0g Sugar-free but contains artificial sweeteners.
Ginger Tea (unsweetened) <5 0g Soothing and flavorful. Adds warmth and spice.
Fresh Citrus Juice <10 Low Provides a tangy, fresh flavor boost.
Cola 140 39g High in sugar and calories, unhealthy choice.
Sweet & Sour Mix ~100 ~25g Often contains high-fructose corn syrup and artificial ingredients.
Ginger Ale (regular) 100+ 25g+ High in sugar, less healthy than a seltzer alternative.

Crafting Healthier Whiskey Cocktails

Making a healthier whiskey drink is easy and rewarding. Here are some simple recipes:

  • Whiskey Soda with a Twist: Fill a glass with ice. Add 2 oz whiskey and top with club soda. Squeeze in a lemon or lime wedge and drop it in. For extra aroma, use an orange peel.
  • Healthy Hot Toddy: In a mug, combine 1.5 oz whiskey with hot water, a teaspoon of raw honey, and a lemon wedge. A cinnamon stick adds a nice spiced aroma.
  • Herbal Whiskey Spritzer: Muddle a few mint or basil leaves at the bottom of a glass. Add ice, 2 oz whiskey, and top with chilled seltzer. Garnish with a fresh herb sprig.

The Importance of Moderation

While choosing a healthy mixer is a great step, it is important to remember that responsible consumption is the most critical factor for health. Excessive alcohol intake can lead to a number of health issues, regardless of the mixer used. Health organizations recommend limiting alcohol to no more than one drink per day for women and two drinks per day for men. By enjoying whiskey in moderation and with a smart mixer, you can minimize negative effects while still enjoying the experience.

Conclusion

When it comes to finding the healthiest thing to drink with whiskey, the answer is simple: use a calorie-free, sugar-free mixer. Water, club soda, or unsweetened tea allow the whiskey's natural flavors to shine through without adding unnecessary sugar and calories. By combining these smart mixer choices with responsible, moderate consumption, you can enjoy your favorite spirit in a health-conscious way. The best choice is often the simplest one, proving that you don't need a high-sugar cocktail to have a great drink.


Author's Note: For more information on the health implications of alcohol and moderation, please consult reputable sources such as WebMD.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, drinking whiskey neat is the healthiest in terms of mixer choice, as it adds no extra calories or sugar. However, moderation is key for overall health.

Seltzer is plain carbonated water. Club soda has added minerals, giving it a slightly saltier taste. Both are excellent, zero-calorie mixers, but their subtle flavor differences may affect your cocktail.

While diet soda eliminates sugar and calories, it relies on artificial sweeteners. For the healthiest option, natural, sugar-free mixers like club soda or tea are often preferred.

Try a simple whiskey highball (whiskey + club soda + lemon twist) or a healthy hot toddy (whiskey + hot water + lemon + a touch of honey or ginger).

For many drinkers, yes. Adding a few drops of water can "open up" the whiskey by releasing aromatic compounds, enhancing its complexity and revealing more subtle flavors.

A hot toddy with whiskey, hot water, lemon, and honey can provide temporary relief for cold symptoms by soothing a sore throat and acting as a mild decongestant. However, it is not a cure and should not replace professional medical advice.

Infuse your drink with fresh ingredients like mint, a sprig of rosemary, a citrus peel, or a slice of ginger. A dash of bitters is another zero-calorie way to add complexity.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.