Skip to content

What's the Difference Between Wheat Gluten and Vital Wheat Gluten?

6 min read

According to the Codex Standard, vital wheat gluten is a processed product derived from wheat flour, containing 80% or more protein. The primary difference between wheat gluten and vital wheat gluten lies in their concentration and form, as vital wheat gluten is a highly concentrated, powdered version of the natural protein found in wheat.

Quick Summary

Vital wheat gluten is a concentrated protein powder extracted from wheat flour, while "wheat gluten" often refers to the natural protein complex within wheat. The key distinction is that vital wheat gluten is an isolated ingredient, valued for its concentrated protein content, elasticity, and binding properties in baking and seitan production.

Key Points

  • Concentration is Key: Vital wheat gluten is a highly concentrated powder (approx. 75-80% protein), while wheat gluten is the natural protein complex found within all wheat flour.

  • Different Uses: Vital wheat gluten is an additive for strengthening dough or a base for seitan, whereas wheat gluten naturally forms the structure of baked goods made with wheat flour.

  • Processing Defines It: Vital wheat gluten is processed by washing away the starch from wheat flour, concentrating the protein, then drying and grinding it.

  • Not Interchangeable with Flour: Vital wheat gluten cannot replace regular flour in most recipes, as it contains almost no starch and would result in a dense, gummy texture.

  • Enhances Baking: Adding a small amount of vital wheat gluten can significantly improve the chewiness, elasticity, and volume of breads, especially those made with low-protein or whole-grain flours.

  • Vegan Meat Alternative: Vital wheat gluten is the primary ingredient for making seitan, a protein-rich meat substitute.

In This Article

What is Wheat Gluten?

Wheat gluten is the natural protein complex that forms when the proteins glutenin and gliadin, found in wheat flour, are hydrated and worked. It is not a singular substance but a network that develops and provides the dough with its unique viscoelastic properties—the ability to stretch and hold its shape. This process is what makes it possible to create light, airy breads and other baked goods. Essentially, all products made with wheat flour contain wheat gluten, formed naturally as the dough is kneaded.

The Role of Glutenin and Gliadin

The protein network of wheat gluten is primarily made of two proteins: glutenin and gliadin.

  • Gliadin: This protein provides the extensibility and viscosity of the dough, allowing it to stretch. It is a monomeric protein.
  • Glutenin: This protein contributes to the elasticity and strength of the dough. It is a polymeric protein, meaning it is made of larger chains of linked subunits.

This balance of gliadin and glutenin is crucial for the dough's final texture and rise. Different wheat varieties have different ratios of these proteins, which is why some flours are better for specific types of baking.

What is Vital Wheat Gluten?

Vital wheat gluten is the product of isolating and concentrating the gluten protein from wheat flour. The process involves washing a dough made from wheat flour and water, which removes the starch and leaves behind a protein mass. This wet mass is then dried and ground into a fine powder. This processing removes most of the carbohydrates, resulting in a product that is approximately 75-80% protein.

The Production of Vital Wheat Gluten

The industrial production of vital wheat gluten follows a wet extraction method, such as the Martin process.

  1. Dough Formation: Wheat flour is mixed with water to form a dough.
  2. Washing: The dough is repeatedly rinsed with water to wash away the water-soluble starch and other components.
  3. Gluten Separation: The insoluble gluten remains behind as a sticky, cohesive mass.
  4. Drying and Grinding: The wet gluten is carefully dried to preserve its vitality—its ability to regain viscoelastic properties when rehydrated—and then milled into a powder.

The Core Differences at a Glance

Here's a comparison table summarizing the key differences between wheat gluten and vital wheat gluten.

Feature Wheat Gluten Vital Wheat Gluten
Form A natural protein network that forms in hydrated wheat flour. A highly concentrated, processed, powdered protein product extracted from wheat flour.
Composition An integral component of wheat flour, mixed with starch, carbohydrates, lipids, and other elements. Approximately 75-80% pure gluten protein with minimal starch.
Concentration Protein content varies depending on the wheat flour type (e.g., all-purpose flour has less protein than bread flour). Highly concentrated protein, where a small amount has a significant impact on dough strength and elasticity.
Use Case Forms naturally during the baking process when using wheat flour. Added to flours with lower protein content to improve structure, or used as the base for meat substitutes like seitan.
Availability Present in all wheat-based products. Sold as a separate powder in the baking or health food aisle.

Practical Applications of Vital Wheat Gluten

Since vital wheat gluten is a concentrated form of protein, it offers specialized functionalities not present in regular flour.

  • Boosting Low-Protein Flours: A spoonful of vital wheat gluten can increase the protein content of all-purpose or whole-wheat flour, providing a stronger gluten network for higher, chewier bread. This is especially useful for dense whole-grain loaves that need help with rise.
  • Creating Seitan: For plant-based diets, vital wheat gluten is the primary ingredient for making seitan, or "wheat meat". When mixed with water and seasonings, it forms a dense, chewy dough that can be cooked to mimic the texture of meat.
  • Improving Texture in Baked Goods: When added to recipes, it can help add elasticity and chewiness to bagels, pizzas, and other baked goods.
  • Providing Binding Power: It can be used as a binder to hold ingredients together in vegan burgers, veggie dogs, and other plant-based creations.

Is One Healthier Than the Other?

For most people without gluten intolerance, vital wheat gluten is a safe and healthy ingredient. It serves as an excellent source of concentrated protein and minerals like selenium and iron, especially for those on plant-based diets. However, it is a processed food, and its health implications vary depending on dietary needs.

Naturally occurring wheat gluten in whole grains is part of a nutritious food, but modern processed foods often contain refined grains stripped of other nutrients. The choice between products is less about inherent health and more about function and dietary context.

Conclusion

In summary, the difference between wheat gluten and vital wheat gluten is one of concentration and form. Wheat gluten is the natural protein complex that develops within wheat-based doughs. In contrast, vital wheat gluten is a processed, highly concentrated powder of that very same protein. While the former is naturally present, the latter is a functional ingredient used to enhance dough structure or create plant-based meat alternatives. Knowing this distinction allows home bakers and cooks to make informed decisions about their ingredients, achieving specific textures and dietary goals in their recipes.

Wheat Gluten and Vital Wheat Gluten Comparison

Wheat Gluten

  • Natural occurrence: It exists naturally within wheat flour as a combination of gliadin and glutenin proteins.
  • Ingredient dependent: The amount and quality of wheat gluten depend on the specific wheat flour used in a recipe.
  • Functionality: Provides dough with elasticity and extensibility when hydrated and mixed.
  • Form: Not a standalone product but a complex network within wheat dough.
  • Usage: Not used as an additive, but its formation is critical to the structure of all wheat-based baked goods.

Vital Wheat Gluten

  • Concentrated product: A processed powder consisting of 75-80% concentrated gluten protein.
  • Additive or base: Used as an additive to boost the protein content of lower-protein flours or as the primary ingredient for seitan.
  • Controlled results: Provides a predictable and powerful increase in dough elasticity and rise, allowing for more control over the final product.
  • Form: Sold as a separate, light beige powder.
  • Usage: Critical for recipes needing high chewiness or structure, and for making meat alternatives.

Understanding Flour and Gluten Types

It's also important to understand that there are different classifications of flours and gluten products beyond just the vital vs. natural distinction.

High-Gluten Flour

High-gluten flour is a specific type of wheat flour milled to have a higher-than-average protein content, usually around 14%. It is distinct from vital wheat gluten powder, as it is still a complete flour containing starch, bran, and other components. It's used for applications like bagels and artisan breads that require a strong, chewy texture.

Non-Vital Wheat Gluten

In industrial settings, there's also a product called "non-vital" wheat gluten. This refers to gluten that has been damaged by excessive heat during the drying process, causing the protein to denature. It can still be used for protein enrichment in foods but has lost its valuable viscoelastic properties.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

For the home cook, the distinction is straightforward. If a recipe calls for "wheat gluten," it is most likely referring to vital wheat gluten powder. The term "wheat gluten" on its own is a more generic term for the protein complex, but in a product or recipe context, it signifies the concentrated additive.

Understanding the concentration and function of vital wheat gluten allows you to use it effectively. A small amount can significantly improve the texture of your baked goods, particularly when using whole grains or low-protein flours. For those creating plant-based meals, vital wheat gluten is an indispensable ingredient for making delicious and satisfying seitan. By respecting the power of this concentrated protein, you can achieve better baking results and expand your culinary repertoire.

One can explore the full range of applications for this ingredient by consulting reputable sources like The Kitchn's guide to using vital wheat gluten: Vital Wheat Gluten: What Is It and When Should It Be Used?.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, you cannot. Vital wheat gluten is a concentrated protein powder and lacks the starch found in regular flour. Using it as a direct substitute for flour would result in a dense, unpalatable texture.

No, vital wheat gluten is a processed product. While the protein itself comes from wheat, it has been separated from the other components like starch and fiber.

For most bread recipes, you can add one heaping tablespoon of vital wheat gluten for every two cups of flour. Whisk it with the dry ingredients to ensure even distribution before mixing.

Vital wheat gluten has a relatively neutral flavor. It is primarily used to affect the texture, chewiness, and rise of baked goods, not the flavor.

Seitan, also known as "wheat meat," is a vegetarian meat alternative made by hydrating and cooking vital wheat gluten mixed with seasonings. Vital wheat gluten is the main ingredient.

No. People with Celiac disease, gluten sensitivities, or wheat allergies must avoid vital wheat gluten, as it is a highly concentrated source of the protein that triggers adverse reactions.

Vital wheat gluten helps counteract the bran in whole-wheat flour, which can inhibit gluten development. By adding it, you get a softer, higher-rising, and less dense loaf of bread.

Vital wheat gluten can be found in the baking aisle of many well-stocked grocery stores, health food stores, and online retailers.

Vital wheat gluten has a long shelf life. It can last for several years unopened. Once opened, it should be stored in a cool, dry place in an airtight container for up to six months to maintain freshness and vitality.

Yes, it is possible to make it at home by washing the starch out of a wheat flour dough. However, it is a laborious process, and the resulting product is often less concentrated than the commercially available version.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.