The Original Vegetarian Mandate in Genesis
In Genesis 1:29, God provides a diet of plants and fruits for Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden. This established a plant-based diet for humanity at creation.
The Shift to a Carnivorous Diet After the Flood
After the flood and the survival of Noah and his family, God made a new covenant. In Genesis 9:3, God permits humans to eat meat, stating, 'Every moving thing that liveth shall be meat for you; even as the green herb have I given you all things'. This change occurred in a world significantly altered by the flood.
Possible reasons for this shift include:
- Ecological changes in the post-flood world may have necessitated new food sources.
- Some interpretations view it as a concession to human nature after the Fall.
- It may have been a provision to ensure human survival and repopulation.
The Mosaic Laws: Clean and Unclean Animals
Following the covenant with Noah, God later gave the Israelites specific dietary laws through Moses, found in Leviticus 11 and Deuteronomy 14. These laws differentiated between 'clean' and 'unclean' animals, including criteria for land animals (must have a divided hoof and chew cud), sea creatures, and birds.
Comparison of Biblical Dietary Guidelines
| Covenant/Period | Source | Dietary Allowance | Key Restrictions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-Flood (Adam) | Genesis 1:29 | All seed-bearing plants and fruit trees | Strictly vegetarian; no meat permitted. |
| Post-Flood (Noah) | Genesis 9:3 | All moving creatures and green plants | Must not eat meat with its lifeblood still in it. |
| Mosaic Law (Israelites) | Leviticus 11 | Specific clean animals with fins & scales (fish), divided hooves & chew cud (mammals), and certain birds/insects | Prohibits unclean animals (e.g., pork, shellfish, scavenger birds); must not eat blood. |
| New Testament (Christians) | Acts 10, Romans 14 | All foods are considered clean | Freedom to eat, but avoid causing a brother to stumble; abstain from blood and strangled animals. |
The New Testament Perspective on Dietary Laws
The New Testament brought changes to the interpretation of Old Testament laws. In Mark 7, Jesus indicates that internal purity is more important than external food rules. The Apostle Peter's vision in Acts 10, while involving unclean animals, was primarily understood as a message about not considering people 'common or unclean,' leading to the inclusion of Gentiles. The Jerusalem Council in Acts 15 advised Gentile believers to abstain from meat offered to idols, blood, and strangled animals. The Apostle Paul in Romans 14 emphasized not judging others based on food choices and prioritizing love and conscience. For further reading, The Gospel Coalition offers insights into this topic: The Gospel Coalition.
Conclusion: Evolving Guidelines
The biblical record shows a progression in God's instructions regarding meat consumption. The initial creation mandate was vegetarian. After the flood, Noah was given permission to eat meat, with a restriction against consuming blood. The Mosaic Law provided specific 'clean' and 'unclean' categories for the Israelites. The New Testament shifted the focus to inner purity and freedom in Christ, while still upholding some restrictions like abstaining from blood. These changes reflect different biblical covenants and historical contexts.