Skip to content

Which tomatoes are highest in lycopene?

4 min read

According to the USDA, Americans consume an average of 22 pounds of tomatoes per year, with over half being processed products like sauces and ketchup. If you're seeking to maximize the antioxidant benefits, knowing which tomatoes are highest in lycopene and how to prepare them is key. This powerful antioxidant, a type of carotenoid, can help protect your cells from damage caused by free radicals.

Quick Summary

Different tomato varieties offer varying levels of the powerful antioxidant lycopene. Tomato varieties like Roma, San Marzano, and specific orange and cherry types are known for high lycopene content. Cooking and processing tomatoes, especially with a little oil, can significantly increase the bioavailability of this nutrient, making it easier for your body to absorb.

Key Points

  • Highest Lycopene Sources: Tomato paste and concentrated sauces contain the highest levels of bioavailable lycopene due to processing and reduced water content.

  • Top Fresh Varieties: For eating raw, dense and intensely colored tomatoes like cherry, Roma, and San Marzano typically offer higher lycopene content than standard round varieties.

  • Enhance Absorption: Cooking tomatoes and combining them with a healthy fat like olive oil dramatically increases the body's ability to absorb lycopene.

  • Don't Overlook Orange Tomatoes: Some orange varieties contain a form of lycopene that is more readily absorbed by the body, offering a potentially more bioavailable raw option.

  • Ripeness and Conditions Matter: Fully vine-ripened tomatoes and those grown under certain conditions (like partial shade) can have higher lycopene concentrations.

  • Processing Benefits: Canned and cooked tomato products, including tomato juice and ketchup, provide a significant and easily absorbed source of lycopene.

In This Article

Understanding Lycopene and its Benefits

Lycopene is a naturally occurring plant pigment, or carotenoid, found in red and pink fruits and vegetables. It's a powerful antioxidant that combats free radicals, unstable molecules that can damage cells and contribute to chronic illnesses like heart disease and cancer. The human body cannot produce its own lycopene, so it must be obtained through diet.

The Surprising Role of Cooking in Lycopene Absorption

While eating raw tomatoes provides lycopene, cooking them can dramatically increase its bioavailability—the amount your body can actually absorb and use. Heat breaks down the thick cell walls of the tomato, releasing the lycopene. Moreover, lycopene is a fat-soluble nutrient, meaning it is absorbed more efficiently when consumed with a source of healthy fat, like olive oil. This is why processed tomato products like sauces and paste, which are cooked and often contain oil, are excellent sources of bioavailable lycopene. Research has also shown that during processing, the heat can convert the less-bioavailable all-trans-lycopene isomer into the more easily absorbed cis-lycopene form.

The Top Raw and Processed Sources

Scientific studies have evaluated the lycopene content of various raw and processed tomato products, yielding some fascinating results. On a dry weight basis, concentrated products like tomato paste contain far more lycopene than fresh tomatoes, due to the reduced water content. For fresh eating, certain varieties are clear winners, with specific research showing variations even within the same color family.

Best raw and processed tomato sources:

  • Tomato Paste: This is arguably the most concentrated source of lycopene, with levels significantly higher than fresh tomatoes.
  • Cherry Tomatoes: High skin-to-flesh ratio and intense color mean these tiny tomatoes often pack more lycopene per gram than larger varieties.
  • Orange Tomatoes: Certain orange varieties like 'Sungold' and specific heirlooms contain a different, more bioavailable form of lycopene (cis-lycopene) than standard red tomatoes.
  • Roma Tomatoes: A study found these plum-shaped tomatoes to be among the highest in lycopene concentration when evaluated on a dry weight basis.
  • San Marzano: Known for their deep red color and meaty texture, these tomatoes are a high-lycopene choice, especially for sauces.
  • Tomato Sauce and Ketchup: Due to processing and concentration, these common products are strong lycopene sources.

Lycopene Content Comparison Table

Tomato Product (100g) Lycopene Content (mg) Bioavailability Best Use Case
Tomato Paste High (e.g., 45.9) Very High Sauces, stews, concentrated flavor
Raw Cherry Tomatoes Medium (e.g., 4.89-11.67*) Low (without oil) Salads, snacks, fresh eating
Cooked Roma Tomatoes High (e.g., 7.88*) High (with oil) Sauces, roasting, paste
Raw Red Tomato Low (e.g., 5.6) Low (without oil) Salads, sandwiches
Cooked Orange Tomato Medium (variable) Higher (cis-lycopene) Sauces, soups, fresh eating
Ketchup Medium (e.g., 16.6) High Condiment, sauces
Tomato Juice Low (e.g., 9) Medium Beverages

*Note: Lycopene content can vary based on ripeness, growing conditions, and specific cultivar.

Factors Influencing Lycopene Levels

Several factors affect the final lycopene content in your tomatoes. Beyond the variety, the maturity and growing conditions play a significant role. Tomatoes harvested when fully vine-ripened have higher lycopene levels than those picked green and ripened off the vine. The specific growing conditions, such as light exposure and even shade, can also influence the lycopene content. For instance, one study found that shaded tomato plants produced fruit with higher lycopene levels.

For optimal absorption, remember that lycopene is fat-soluble. Always pair your cooked tomato products with a healthy fat like olive oil or avocado. This simple step significantly enhances your body's ability to utilize this powerful nutrient. Consider simmering your homemade tomato sauce with a generous glug of olive oil to get the most out of your tomatoes. You can also add some healthy fat to raw preparations by tossing fresh cherry tomatoes into a salad with an oil-based dressing.

Conclusion

While many varieties contain lycopene, processing types like Roma and specific heirlooms like San Marzano tend to have higher concentrations. For fresh applications, smaller, intensely colored cherry tomatoes are a great choice. However, the best way to increase your body's absorption of this potent antioxidant is by heating the tomatoes and consuming them with a healthy fat. This process makes the nutrient more bioavailable. Whether from a homemade sauce using ripe Roma tomatoes or a ready-made paste enriched with olive oil, prioritizing cooked tomato products is the most effective strategy for maximizing your lycopene intake. The ultimate recipe for success is to incorporate a variety of tomato types and preparations into your diet to ensure a consistent supply of this beneficial antioxidant.

One can find more information about the health benefits of lycopene and its protective effects against various diseases on reputable health websites like WebMD.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, cooking tomatoes actually increases the bioavailability of lycopene. Heat breaks down the plant's cell walls, making the lycopene easier for your body to absorb. In fact, studies show cooked and processed tomato products are excellent sources of usable lycopene.

Adding a healthy fat like olive oil when cooking tomatoes enhances lycopene absorption. As a fat-soluble nutrient, lycopene needs fat to be effectively absorbed by the body. This is a primary reason why processed tomato products cooked with oil are so potent.

Yes, some orange-colored varieties are notably high in lycopene. Research indicates they contain a form called cis-lycopene, which is more easily absorbed by the body than the all-trans-lycopene found in most red varieties.

While not a perfect science, the intensity of a tomato's red or orange color is a good indicator of its lycopene content. Fully ripe, deeply colored tomatoes are a better choice for maximizing this antioxidant.

Yes, on average, canned tomatoes and tomato paste contain more lycopene than their raw counterparts. This is because the cooking and concentration process increases lycopene levels and enhances its bioavailability.

Per gram, cherry tomatoes often have a higher lycopene content. This is attributed to their greater ratio of skin (where lycopene is concentrated) to flesh compared to larger, round tomatoes.

For maximum lycopene benefits, consume tomatoes that have been cooked and processed, such as in paste or sauce. Always include a healthy fat in the preparation to further increase absorption. For fresh consumption, choose ripe, deeply colored cherry, Roma, or San Marzano varieties.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.