Which uncrustable is better? A definitive comparison

With annual sales of Uncrustables closing in on a billion dollars, it's clear these frozen, crustless sandwiches are a massive hit. But for many, the ultimate question remains: which uncrustable is better? The answer is more complex than a simple preference between grape and strawberry, involving factors like sweetness, flavor profile, and even texture preferences.

Quick Summary

A detailed comparison of Uncrustables flavors, including Grape, Strawberry, Raspberry, and Hazelnut, to determine the best choice. Evaluates taste, texture, and nutritional profiles.

Key Points

• Grape vs. Strawberry: The original debate pits the classic sweet grape jelly against the fruitier, slightly tarter strawberry jam, with many preferring the iconic grape flavor.

• Raspberry is a Top Contender: The Raspberry spread flavor often surprises taste testers and is ranked highly for its vibrant, tart profile and refreshing taste.

• Nutritional Variety: Beyond the classics, Uncrustables offers higher-protein versions like Up & Apple™ and Bright-Eyed Berry™, providing more balanced nutrition.

• Alternative Flavors: For dessert lovers, the Chocolate Flavored Hazelnut spread offers a rich, sweet alternative, while the Honey spread is often rated lower due to its artificial taste.

• Homemade vs. Store-bought: Some argue homemade versions are superior, but Uncrustables are prized for their convenience, mess-free design, and impossibly soft, sealed bread.

• Thawing is Key: For the best flavor and texture, proper thawing for 30–60 minutes is recommended; refrigerating can dry out the bread.

The Classic Contenders: Grape vs. Strawberry

When the Uncrustables brand launched into grocery stores in 2000, it featured two classic flavors: Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly and Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam. For most fans, the debate starts and ends here. But which one is truly superior?

The Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly Uncrustable is the iconic, time-honored classic. Many consider it the default best flavor, and its legendary reliability has made it a favorite for decades. Its sweet, concord grape flavor offers a comforting and familiar taste that perfectly complements the salty peanut butter. The texture is consistently soft, with a decent spread-to-peanut butter ratio, though some have noted inconsistent jelly distribution.

On the other hand, the Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam Uncrustable presents a fruitier, slightly more complex flavor profile. The strawberry jam tends to be more tart and bright than the grape jelly, which can cut through the richness of the peanut butter more effectively for some palates. While it's a solid, fan-favorite choice, some taste tests have found it to be a slightly less balanced experience compared to its grape counterpart.

Beyond the Basics: Raspberry, Hazelnut, and More

While grape and strawberry dominate the market, Smucker's has expanded its lineup to include several other inventive flavors. These options cater to those looking for a different taste or a specific nutritional profile.

• Raspberry Spread: Many taste testers surprisingly rank the Raspberry spread as a top contender, with its vibrant and tart flavor offering a refreshing twist on the classic PB&J.
• Chocolate Flavored Hazelnut Spread: A dessert-like option that replaces the fruit spread entirely, this Uncrustable is a favorite for those with a serious sweet tooth. It is important to note that this is a very sweet snack and stretches the definition of a traditional sandwich.
• Peanut Butter & Honey Spread: This option, while appealing in theory, has received mixed reviews. Some find the honey spread to have an artificial or medicinal taste and can be overly sweet, leading it to be ranked lower than the fruit jelly versions.
• Up & Apple™ and Bright-Eyed Berry™: These are newer options from Uncrustables that boast a higher protein content (12g per serving). They provide a more balanced nutritional profile for those seeking a healthier choice, though the taste may differ from the classic versions.

Uncrustable Comparison Table

To help you decide which uncrustable is better for your personal preferences, here is a quick comparison of some of the most popular flavors.

Flavor	Main Flavor Profile	Sweetness Level	Texture Notes	Best For	Typical Calories (2 oz)	Protein (g)
Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly	Sweet, classic grape	High	Consistent, smooth filling	Traditionalists and kids	~210	6
Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam	Fruity, slightly tart	High	Smooth, bright jam	Fans of a fruitier flavor	~210	6
Peanut Butter & Raspberry Spread	Punchy, tart raspberry	High	Intense, zesty jam	Adventurous snackers	Varies	Varies
Choc. Hazelnut Spread	Rich, nutty, and sweet	Very High	Creamy, chocolatey	Dessert lovers	Varies	Varies
Peanut Butter & Honey	Sweet, processed honey	High	Sometimes cloying honey	Only for honey enthusiasts	Varies	Varies

The Verdict: How to Choose Your Champion

So, which uncrustable is better? The truth is, there is no single right answer, as it ultimately comes down to individual taste and what you want from your snack. If you're a purist who craves a classic, nostalgic experience, the Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly is likely your best bet. If you prefer a sharper, fruitier flavor, the Strawberry Jam is a solid choice. For those with a more adventurous palate, the Raspberry or Chocolate Hazelnut spreads offer a break from the norm. Those seeking a higher-protein, more nutritious option can explore the Up & Apple™ or Bright-Eyed Berry™ varieties.

The convenience of a pre-made, frozen sandwich is what makes the Uncrustable so appealing in the first place, allowing for a delicious, mess-free meal or snack on the go. To make the most informed decision, consider your personal flavor preferences and desired nutritional content. Perhaps the best approach is to try a variety pack and hold your own taste test! Visit Uncrustables' official website for more info.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Do I need to thaw my Uncrustable before eating it? A: Yes, it is recommended to thaw Uncrustables for 30–60 minutes at room temperature before eating for the best texture and flavor.

Q: What is the nutritional value of an Uncrustable? A: A classic 2 oz Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly Uncrustable has about 210 calories, 6 grams of protein, and 9 grams of added sugar.

Q: Are there any nut-free Uncrustable options? A: While Smucker's Uncrustables are all made with peanut butter, some alternative brands, like SunButter, offer nut-free, crustless sandwiches.

Q: Can I put my Uncrustable in the microwave? A: Microwaving is not recommended, as it can make the bread soggy and affect the texture. Thawing is the best way to enjoy your sandwich.

Q: Can I refrigerate my Uncrustable? A: Uncrustables can be refrigerated for up to 24 hours after thawing, but for the best flavor experience, eating them within 8–10 hours is best.

Q: Why do NFL players eat so many Uncrustables? A: NFL teams reportedly consume thousands of Uncrustables weekly due to their convenience, high calorie density, and balanced energy provided by the combination of peanut butter and jelly, making them an ideal on-the-go snack for athletes.

Q: Do Uncrustables really have no crust? A: Yes, the sandwiches are made by trimming the crust and crimping the edges to seal the filling inside, preventing mess and removing the unwanted crust.

Conclusion

Ultimately, deciding which uncrustable is better is a personal journey of taste and preference. The classic Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly remains the crowd-pleaser for its nostalgic flavor and reliability, while the Strawberry Jam offers a delightful, fruitier alternative. For those seeking something new, options like the tart Raspberry or decadent Hazelnut spread can satisfy different cravings. With a variety of options now available, including higher-protein choices, the Uncrustable lineup offers something for everyone, whether you're a kid at lunch or a professional athlete on the go. The best way to know for sure is to try them all yourself and pick your favorite.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you properly thaw an Uncrustable?

To properly thaw an Uncrustable, simply remove it from the freezer and let it sit at room temperature for 30 to 60 minutes. For the best flavor experience, consume it within 8 to 10 hours of thawing.

Can I eat an Uncrustable frozen?

While it's not recommended for the ideal experience, you can eat an Uncrustable when it's still partially frozen. This gives it a unique, ice cream sandwich-like texture, but eating it completely frozen will negatively affect the bread's texture.

Are there any gluten-free Uncrustables?

Currently, Smucker's does not offer a gluten-free version of Uncrustables. The bread used in their sandwiches contains wheat ingredients.

Is there a difference between the club store and grocery store Uncrustables?

Yes, the Uncrustables sold at club stores (like Costco) are often larger in size than those in regular grocery stores, so their calorie count and nutritional information will differ.

How long do Uncrustables last in the freezer?

As long as the Uncrustable package is sealed and it remains frozen, the product has a long shelf life. The best-by date on the box indicates how long it will maintain optimal quality.

What is the key to an Uncrustable's leak-proof design?

The key feature is the crimped and sealed edge of the soft bread, which keeps the filling contained and prevents it from leaking out, ensuring a mess-free snack.

Are there any non-peanut butter Uncrustables?

Yes, Smucker's offers a Peanut Butter & Chocolate Flavored Hazelnut Spread sandwich, which replaces the jelly with a chocolatey, nutty spread for a sweeter experience.