Skip to content

Why are 5 Guys burgers so high in calories?

4 min read

According to nutritional data, a standard Five Guys Bacon Cheeseburger contains over 900 calories, significantly higher than many competitors. So, why are 5 Guys burgers so high in calories? The answer lies in a combination of high-fat ingredients, generous portion sizes, and the multitude of high-calorie toppings available.

Quick Summary

Five Guys' burgers are calorically dense due to high-fat ground beef, multiple patties, generous cheese and bacon portions, and calorie-heavy customizable toppings like mayonnaise. The large, frequent cooking in peanut oil also adds to the overall calorie count.

Key Points

  • High-Fat Beef: Five Guys uses fresh, high-fat (80/20) ground beef, a core contributor to the high calorie count.

  • Double Patties: Standard Five Guys burgers come with two patties, doubling the meat, fat, and calories compared to most single-patty fast-food options.

  • Calorie-Dense Toppings: Free toppings like mayonnaise (100+ calories), cheese, and bacon significantly increase the final calorie and fat content.

  • Large Fries Portions: The famously generous serving of fries, cooked in peanut oil, adds a substantial amount of calories to the meal.

  • Allergen Info: The Five Guys website provides nutritional and allergen information for all menu items for those with dietary restrictions or concerns.

  • Peanut Oil Cooking: All items are cooked in 100% peanut oil, which, despite its quality, adds to the fat and calorie density.

  • Healthier Alternatives: The 'Little Hamburger' and veggie-heavy toppings are recommended to significantly reduce the calorie count.

In This Article

The Core Components of a High-Calorie Five Guys Burger

High-Fat Beef and Multiple Patties

At the heart of the matter is the beef itself. Five Guys uses fresh, high-fat ground beef, specifically an 80/20 mix (80% lean, 20% fat), which provides the distinctive flavor and juiciness. While a single patty might not be overly extreme, a standard Five Guys burger comes with two patties. This doubles the meat and, consequently, doubles the fat and calorie content compared to a single-patty equivalent from another chain. For example, the Bacon Cheeseburger, a popular choice, includes two patties, two slices of cheese, and bacon, pushing its calorie count well over 900. A Little Hamburger, by contrast, has only one patty, resulting in a much lower calorie count of 480.

The Impact of Cheese and Bacon

The toppings at Five Guys are a major contributor to the final calorie count. The addition of two slices of American cheese adds a significant amount of fat and calories to the burger. Similarly, the crispy strips of applewood-smoked bacon, while delicious, contribute a substantial amount of calories and sodium. Customers can add these premium toppings at no extra cost, making it easy to build a high-calorie burger without even realizing it. The bacon cheeseburger, a popular item, shows a dramatic calorie increase simply due to the bacon and cheese.

Unlimited, High-Calorie Toppings

Five Guys prides itself on its customizable burgers with a wide array of free toppings. While options like lettuce, onions, and tomatoes add minimal calories, many other popular choices are calorically dense. Mayonnaise is a significant offender, adding 100-110 calories per serving. Other sauces like BBQ sauce and A1 sauce, as well as grilled mushrooms, also add up quickly. A customer freely adding multiple sauces and fatty toppings can easily boost their burger's calorie count by several hundred calories.

Here is a list of some high-calorie toppings to be mindful of:

  • Mayonnaise: Approximately 100-110 calories per serving.
  • Bacon: Roughly 210 calories per two strips.
  • Cheese: One slice adds about 70 calories.
  • BBQ Sauce: Around 50 calories per serving.
  • Peanut Butter: For shakes, adds around 250 calories.
  • Grilled Mushrooms: Add a small but notable calorie bump.

The Role of Cooking Oil

Five Guys cooks all its burgers and fries in 100% peanut oil. While peanut oil is not inherently unhealthy, it is a fat and contributes significantly to the overall calories. The grilling process on the flat top, where burgers are smashed down, allows the fat to render and adds to the flavor, but also means the burger is absorbing some of this fat, increasing its calorie density.

The Caloric Impact of the Entire Meal

It's important to remember that the burger is often only one part of the Five Guys meal. The fries are particularly high in calories, with a regular-sized order containing over 900 calories due to the huge portion size and the fact that they are cooked in peanut oil. Adding a milkshake can push a single meal's calorie count well over the average daily recommended intake for many individuals.

Comparison with Competitors

To understand the caloric density of Five Guys burgers, comparing them to other fast-food options is useful. The difference often lies in portion size, beef fat content, and available toppings.

Feature Five Guys McDonald's In-N-Out Shake Shack
Standard Burger Two patties, high-fat beef Single or double patty Single or double patty Single or double patty
Calories (Cheeseburger) 840 (standard) 300 (regular) 480 550
Fries Portion Overflowing into bag Standard serving size Standard serving size Standard serving size
Fries Calories (Small) 526 ~320 395 420
Toppings Free, unlimited Standard menu toppings Customization available Customization available
Protein Content High Standard High High

Conclusion

The high calorie content of Five Guys burgers stems from a combination of fresh, high-fat beef served in generous portions (two patties standard), multiple slices of cheese and bacon, and the customer's ability to load up on calorically dense free toppings like mayonnaise. When paired with their notoriously large servings of fries cooked in peanut oil, a single meal can quickly become a significant portion of a person's daily recommended calories. For those looking to manage their intake, opting for a 'Little' burger with vegetable toppings and skipping the fries and sugary drinks are the most effective strategies. Ultimately, the high-calorie nature is a direct result of Five Guys' quality-focused, generously portioned approach to its classic menu.

Making Healthier Choices

For customers concerned about calories, mindful ordering is key. Choosing a 'Little Hamburger' with just one patty is the most significant step. From there, being selective with toppings by focusing on vegetables like lettuce, tomatoes, and onions instead of mayo, bacon, and cheese can drastically reduce the final calorie count. Ordering a burger without a bun and wrapped in lettuce is another popular and effective strategy for minimizing calories and carbs. By making these simple adjustments, you can still enjoy the fresh, high-quality taste of a Five Guys burger without the overwhelming calorie intake.

For more information on making healthier choices when dining out, consult resources on conscious eating. Conscious Eating: How to Make Healthier Fast Food Choices

Frequently Asked Questions

The lowest calorie burger is the 'Little Hamburger.' It contains a single patty and has significantly fewer calories than the standard two-patty options, especially if you opt for vegetable toppings and skip the high-calorie sauces and cheese.

Yes, opting for a lettuce wrap instead of a bun can save a considerable number of calories and carbohydrates, as the bun itself contributes significantly to the overall calorie count.

Yes, many toppings are free and can drastically increase the calorie count. While vegetables like lettuce and onions are low-calorie, sauces like mayonnaise and BBQ sauce add significant calories.

Five Guys fries are notably higher in calories due to their large portion sizes and cooking method in peanut oil. A 'regular' size can have over 900 calories, far exceeding the standard servings at many competitors.

Five Guys uses high-quality, fresh ground beef with an 80/20 lean-to-fat ratio. This high fat content is a key reason for the burgers' juicy flavor and high calorie count.

The bacon cheeseburger is one of the highest-calorie options because it includes two high-fat beef patties, two slices of cheese, and bacon, all of which are calorically dense.

Achieving a low-sodium meal is challenging at Five Guys, as many components, including the beef, cheese, bacon, and sauces, contain high levels of sodium. Your best bet is to order a 'Little' option without added salt or high-sodium toppings.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.