Skip to content

Why can Mormons drink hot chocolate but not hot coffee?

3 min read

The Word of Wisdom, a health code for members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, was first received in 1833 and advises against certain substances. This revelatory counsel offers the key answer to the common question: Why can Mormons drink hot chocolate but not hot coffee?

Quick Summary

The prohibition on coffee stems from prophetic interpretations of the Word of Wisdom, not caffeine or temperature. Hot chocolate is not included in this specific counsel, allowing its consumption by Latter-day Saints.

Key Points

  • Specific Interpretation: The prohibition on "hot drinks" refers specifically to coffee and tea, based on prophetic clarification, not temperature or caffeine.

  • Hot Chocolate Exemption: Hot chocolate is not included in the specific list of prohibited "hot drinks" and is therefore permissible.

  • Caffeine Misconception: The Word of Wisdom does not explicitly ban all caffeine; its focus is on the specific substances of coffee and tea, not the chemical compound.

  • Evolving Guidance: While the foundational revelation is from 1833, its application has been clarified over time by modern prophets to include substances like illegal drugs and vaping.

  • Spiritual Focus: The primary purpose of the Word of Wisdom is spiritual, helping members become more receptive to divine guidance, with physical health benefits being a secondary result.

  • Sign of Discipleship: Keeping the Word of Wisdom is an outward sign of a member's commitment to their covenant with God and their willingness to obey prophetic counsel.

In This Article

The Word of Wisdom: Origins and Interpretation

The Word of Wisdom is a revelation received by Joseph Smith in 1833, outlined in Doctrine and Covenants 89. It is the basis for the health practices of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Initially given as counsel, it became a requirement for temple attendance in the early 20th century. It recommends avoiding tobacco, alcohol, and "hot drinks".

Prophetic Clarification of "Hot Drinks"

Since Joseph Smith's time, Church leaders have clarified that "hot drinks" specifically refers to coffee and tea. This interpretation, based on prophetic guidance, is the reason members abstain from these beverages. The prohibition isn't against all hot beverages, but specifically coffee and tea, including black and green tea regardless of temperature, and iced coffee. Other hot drinks, like herbal teas or warm milk, are not prohibited.

The Hot Chocolate Exception

Hot chocolate is not among the prohibited "hot drinks". Although it can be served hot and contains some caffeine, the prohibition is not based solely on temperature or caffeine content. The distinction comes from specific prophetic guidance which has never included cocoa or chocolate products. Thus, hot chocolate is permitted and commonly enjoyed by Latter-day Saints.

More than Caffeine

A common misunderstanding is that the Word of Wisdom prohibits all caffeine. The Church clarifies that while harmful or habit-forming substances should be avoided, caffeine itself is not the specific reason for the coffee and tea ban. Caffeinated soft drinks are considered a matter of personal choice, not a violation. The prohibition is tied to obedience to revelation and avoiding substances identified as problematic in earlier contexts. Abstaining from coffee and tea is seen as a commitment to covenants and prophetic counsel.

Understanding the Spiritual Principle

The Word of Wisdom is viewed primarily as a spiritual principle that leads to physical benefits. President Boyd K. Packer taught that it helps members be more receptive to spiritual promptings. By avoiding substances that can hinder spiritual sensitivity, members aim to feel the influence of the Holy Ghost more clearly. Observing the Word of Wisdom is part of discipleship, promising blessings of health, wisdom, and knowledge.

A Shifting Standard Over Time

The application of the Word of Wisdom has evolved. Starting as counsel, it became a commandment. Modern prophets have also expanded the counsel to include avoiding illegal drugs, misuse of prescription drugs, and vaping. This demonstrates that the Word of Wisdom is a living law guided by ongoing revelation.

Conclusion: Obedience and Covenant

Latter-day Saints drink hot chocolate but not coffee because of the specific, prophetically interpreted application of the Word of Wisdom. The prohibition is on coffee and tea, not all hot beverages or caffeine. This obedience is a significant aspect of their commitment to God and their covenants, leading to promised spiritual and physical blessings.

Word of Wisdom: Prohibited vs. Allowed Substances

Substance Classification Word of Wisdom Status
Coffee "Hot Drink" Prohibited
Tea (Black, Green) "Hot Drink" Prohibited
Alcohol "Strong Drink" Prohibited
Tobacco "Not for the body" Prohibited
Illegal Drugs Harmful/Habit-Forming Prohibited (Modern Counsel)
Hot Chocolate Not included in prohibition Allowed
Herbal Tea "Wholesome Herb" Allowed
Grains, Fruits, Vegetables "Staff of Life" / Good for man Encouraged
Caffeinated Sodas Not specifically prohibited Discretionary (Not a violation)
Meat "For the use of man" Used sparingly

The Purpose of Keeping the Word of Wisdom

  • Spiritual Insight: Keeping the Word of Wisdom is believed to enhance the ability to receive and understand spiritual promptings.
  • Health and Vigor: Obedience is associated with promises of physical health, strength, and resistance to disease.
  • Personal Sanctification: Abstaining from certain substances is seen as honoring the body as a sacred temple.
  • Covenant Symbol: Adhering to this law signifies commitment and faith in God's revelations.
  • Blessings and Protection: Obedience is linked to blessings, wisdom, knowledge, and divine protection.

Learn more about the Word of Wisdom and other Gospel topics on The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints' official website. https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/manual/gospel-topics/word-of-wisdom?lang=eng

Frequently Asked Questions

No, the prohibition is not based on caffeine. While coffee and tea contain caffeine, the Word of Wisdom does not explicitly mention or ban caffeine. The official stance clarifies that the ban applies specifically to coffee and tea, and that caffeinated soft drinks are not prohibited, although some members exercise personal discretion.

No, the term "hot drinks" has been specifically interpreted by Church leaders to mean coffee and tea. Therefore, other hot beverages like herbal tea, hot chocolate, and warm milk are not prohibited under the Word of Wisdom.

Hot chocolate is allowed because it was never included in the specific prophetic clarification that defined "hot drinks" as coffee and tea. The ban is about obedience to specific counsel, not the caffeine content of all beverages.

The Word of Wisdom was received in 1833 as counsel, or "not by commandment or constraint". Observance became a requirement for temple attendance and other privileges in the early 20th century under President Heber J. Grant, establishing it as a strict commandment for modern members.

All forms of coffee and tea are prohibited, regardless of temperature or whether they are caffeinated. Prophetic clarification states that drinks with words like 'café,' 'latte,' or 'mocha' are also considered coffee.

No, caffeinated sodas are not officially prohibited. The Church has advised against harmful and habit-forming substances, but has left the consumption of products like soda to individual judgment. Some members choose to abstain based on the 'spirit of the law,' but this is not a Church-wide rule.

While promoting physical health is a benefit, the primary purpose is spiritual. It is seen as a way to increase spiritual wisdom, knowledge, and receptivity to divine revelation by keeping one's mind and body clean from harmful substances.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.