Skip to content
Ntro

Why Shouldn't We Eat Eel? The Health and Environmental Risks

•
8 min read

The population of European eels has experienced a catastrophic decline of over 95% in the last 25 years, earning them a classification as a critically endangered species. This dramatic collapse is one of several compelling reasons why consumers should reconsider adding this ancient fish to their plate.

Quick Summary

Examines the severe threats associated with eel consumption, including the endangerment of multiple species and significant food safety hazards like heat-stable ciguatoxins, dangerous parasites, and heavy metal contamination.

Key Points

  • Endangered Species: All major species of edible eel, including European, American, and Japanese, are endangered or critically endangered due to overfishing.

  • Illegal Trade: The high demand for eels, particularly young glass eels for farming, fuels a major illegal wildlife trade.

  • Blood is Toxic: The blood of eels contains a neurotoxin that requires thorough cooking to be neutralized and can be fatal if consumed raw.

  • High in Contaminants: As bottom-dwelling predators, eels accumulate dangerous levels of heavy metals and pollutants from their environment.

  • Parasite Risk: Consuming raw or improperly cooked eel can expose you to harmful parasites, like Gnathostoma spinigerum.

  • Ecosystem Harm: The decline of eel populations disrupts important aquatic food webs and ecosystem functions, such as water filtration.

  • Farmed Eel is Unsustainable: Because eels cannot be bred in captivity, eel farms stock their operations with wild-caught juveniles, contributing to the depletion of wild stock.

In This Article

Why Eating Eel is a Serious Environmental Concern

Beyond individual health, the biggest argument against eating eel is its devastating ecological impact. All three major species consumed globally—the European, American, and Japanese eels—are listed as endangered or critically endangered by the IUCN. A primary driver of their decline is overfishing, often to supply aquaculture farms. The eel's life cycle is so complex that breeding them successfully in captivity has proven impossible, meaning farms rely entirely on capturing wild juveniles, or 'glass eels'. This practice removes young eels from their natural population before they can mature and reproduce, perpetuating the cycle of decline.

The Unsustainable Eel Trade

In addition to the collection of wild juveniles for farming, the international trade in eels faces a significant problem with illegal trafficking. The Sustainable Eel Group has described the eel trade as the “greatest wildlife crime on the planet”. Illegal poaching and smuggling further deplete the already vulnerable wild populations, often bypassing existing regulations meant to protect the species. This illegal and unsustainable trade not only impacts the eels themselves but also the wider aquatic ecosystems in which they play a crucial role, such as distributing mussel populations that act as natural water filters.

Significant Health Risks Associated with Eel Consumption

Improperly prepared eel can pose serious health dangers due to naturally occurring toxins and pollutants concentrated in the meat.

Poisonous Eel Blood and Improper Cooking

Eel blood is inherently toxic to humans and other mammals, containing a protein that causes severe muscle cramps, including the heart. Fortunately, this heat-labile toxin is neutralized during the cooking process. However, the risk remains for those who handle raw eel or consume it improperly prepared. The presence of this natural toxin highlights the need for careful handling and preparation, though most eels are always served cooked to eliminate this danger.

Dangerous Parasites

Like many aquatic organisms, eels are known to carry parasites. The Asian swamp eel, for example, can transmit a parasitic infection called gnathostomiasis if consumed raw or undercooked. This infection, caused by parasitic worms, can lead to serious health issues, including blindness and even death in severe cases. While cooking typically kills parasites, relying on proper preparation is always a risk, particularly with market-sourced eels that may not be handled with extreme care.

Heavy Metal and Contaminant Bioaccumulation

As bottom-dwelling fish, eels are particularly susceptible to accumulating high levels of heavy metals and other environmental pollutants. Research has shown European eels can contain dangerously high levels of mercury, cadmium, and lead, often exceeding legally established limits for human consumption. These contaminants are not destroyed by cooking and can accumulate in human tissue over time, causing serious health problems. This issue is particularly concerning for eels from polluted rivers or waterways, making the sourcing of wild-caught eels a major health gamble.

Comparison: Eel vs. Sustainable Fish Options

Feature Wild-Caught Eel (e.g., European Eel) Sustainable Alternatives (e.g., U.S. Wild-Caught Alaskan Salmon)
Conservation Status Critically Endangered/Endangered species. Healthy and well-managed populations.
Sourcing for Farms Depends entirely on harvesting wild juveniles. Does not rely on depleting wild stocks for aquaculture.
Toxin in Blood Contains a neurotoxin neutralized only by proper cooking. No such inherent toxin requiring special handling.
Heavy Metal Accumulation High risk, especially in polluted waterways. Lower risk due to life cycle and cleaner habitats.
Parasite Risk Can carry parasites like Gnathostoma spinigerum if undercooked. Proper handling and cooking still required, but generally lower risk profile.
Taste Profile Rich, oily, and delicate texture. Varies greatly; offers numerous flavorful and textured choices.

Conclusion

The compelling arguments against eating eel are multi-faceted and significant. From a sustainability perspective, consuming eel directly contributes to the severe decline of critically endangered species across the globe, a problem exacerbated by illegal trafficking and farming practices that rely on wild stock. Ecologically, eels play a vital role in their aquatic environments, and their disappearance has broader consequences for river ecosystems. From a health and food safety standpoint, the risks are substantial. The presence of a blood toxin, the potential for parasites, and the proven accumulation of heavy metals like mercury and cadmium make eel a high-risk food, even when cooked. Choosing more sustainable and safer seafood alternatives helps protect these vulnerable species and ensures a healthier outcome for yourself and the planet.

How to Make Sustainable Choices

If you appreciate the rich flavor of eel, there are many sustainable alternatives that provide a satisfying seafood experience without the ethical and health concerns. The Monterey Bay Aquarium's Seafood Watch provides excellent guides to help consumers make informed decisions. Avoiding eel and encouraging responsible sourcing from restaurants and markets are powerful steps toward protecting these struggling species and promoting global marine health.

Key Takeaways

  • Eel is Highly Endangered: Major eel species like the European, American, and Japanese eel are critically endangered due to overfishing and habitat loss.
  • Farming Is Not a Solution: Eel farms depend on catching wild juveniles, which depletes natural populations and further harms species recovery.
  • Eel Blood is Toxic: Raw eel blood contains a toxin that is dangerous to humans and requires thorough cooking to be neutralized.
  • High in Heavy Metals: As bottom dwellers, eels readily bioaccumulate toxic heavy metals and pollutants, posing a significant health risk to consumers.
  • Risk of Parasites: Under or improperly cooked eel can transmit parasitic infections, with potentially serious consequences.
  • Sustainable Alternatives Exist: Healthier and more sustainable seafood options are available that do not carry the same environmental and health burdens as eel.

FAQs

Question: Why is eel still on menus if it's endangered? Answer: Despite their endangered status, eels remain a traditional delicacy in many parts of the world. Enforcement of fishing regulations can be difficult, and consumer demand, particularly in Asia, continues to drive the market.

Question: Isn't farm-raised eel a sustainable option? Answer: No, it is not. Because eel breeding cannot be replicated in captivity, all eel farms source their juveniles (glass eels) from the wild. This practice removes young eels from the natural population before they can mature and reproduce, which is a major contributor to their endangered status.

Question: Is the toxin in eel blood dangerous after cooking? Answer: The proteinaceous toxin in eel blood is heat-labile, meaning it is destroyed when cooked. However, handling raw eel carries a risk, and the dependence on proper cooking highlights a significant food safety concern not present in other common fish.

Question: What is ciguatera food poisoning related to moray eels? Answer: Moray eels, a species of marine eel, can accumulate high levels of ciguatoxins from their diet of reef fish. Unlike the toxin in eel blood, ciguatoxins are not destroyed by cooking and can cause severe, long-lasting illness.

Question: Do all eels accumulate high levels of heavy metals? Answer: As bottom dwellers, many species of eels are prone to bioaccumulating contaminants from polluted waterways. Studies have shown eels in specific locations to have heavy metal levels exceeding safe limits for human consumption.

Question: What are some good alternatives to eel? Answer: For sustainable options that are rich in flavor and texture, consider wild-caught Alaskan salmon, Pacific halibut, or farmed striped bass. These choices do not carry the same environmental and health risks.

Question: Does eating unagi contribute to illegal wildlife crime? Answer: Yes. The global demand for unagi (Japanese freshwater eel) fuels a massive illegal trade in glass eels, which are smuggled to supply aquaculture farms. This trafficking is one of the biggest threats to eel populations worldwide.

Question: Why are eels so important to the ecosystem? Answer: Eels play an important role as a food source for other species and in maintaining ecosystem health. For example, American eels help spread mussel populations that act as natural water filters. Their decline impacts the wider aquatic food web.

Citations

Frequently Asked Questions

Despite their endangered status, eels remain a traditional delicacy in many parts of the world. Enforcement of fishing regulations can be difficult, and consumer demand, particularly in Asia, continues to drive the market.

No, it is not. Because eel breeding cannot be replicated in captivity, all eel farms source their juveniles (glass eels) from the wild. This practice removes young eels from the natural population before they can mature and reproduce, which is a major contributor to their endangered status.

The proteinaceous toxin in eel blood is heat-labile, meaning it is destroyed when cooked. However, handling raw eel carries a risk, and the dependence on proper cooking highlights a significant food safety concern not present in other common fish.

Moray eels, a species of marine eel, can accumulate high levels of ciguatoxins from their diet of reef fish. Unlike the toxin in eel blood, ciguatoxins are not destroyed by cooking and can cause severe, long-lasting illness.

As bottom dwellers, many species of eels are prone to bioaccumulating contaminants from polluted waterways. Studies have shown eels in specific locations to have heavy metal levels exceeding safe limits for human consumption.

For sustainable options that are rich in flavor and texture, consider wild-caught Alaskan salmon, Pacific halibut, or farmed striped bass. These choices do not carry the same environmental and health risks.

Yes. The global demand for unagi (Japanese freshwater eel) fuels a massive illegal trade in glass eels, which are smuggled to supply aquaculture farms. This trafficking is one of the biggest threats to eel populations worldwide.

Eels play an important role as a food source for other species and in maintaining ecosystem health. For example, American eels help spread mussel populations that act as natural water filters. Their decline impacts the wider aquatic food web.

References

  1. 1
    European eel - Rewilding Britain
  2. 2
    Eels have fascinated us for ages - now we need to stop eating them
  3. 3
    Heavy Metals Uptake by Asian Swamp Eel, Monopterus albus...
  4. 4
    Parasite in Live Asian Swamp Eels May Cause Human Illness
  5. 5
    Eel blood is poisonous to humans. - Interesting Facts

Related Topics:

#sustainable seafood #heavy metals #Parasites #ciguatera #endangered species #unagi #Eel #eel blood toxin

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.