How Bragg Liquid Aminos are Made
Understanding the manufacturing process of Bragg Liquid Aminos is key to determining its histamine potential. Unlike traditional soy sauce, which is a fermented product, Bragg's is made from non-GMO soybeans and purified water, and is created through a process called acid hydrolysis. In this process, hydrochloric acid is used to break down the vegetable protein in the soybeans into its constituent amino acids. The process does not involve fermentation, which is a primary driver of high histamine levels in many foods.
The Role of Histidine and Hydrolysis
The breakdown of soy protein during hydrolysis releases free amino acids, including histidine. Histamine is derived from the decarboxylation of the amino acid histidine, and certain bacteria are known to possess the enzyme that converts histidine to histamine. While Bragg's production method avoids the fermentation that typically allows these bacteria to flourish, the presence of histidine is still a key factor to consider.
Hydrolyzed vegetable protein itself is not inherently high in histamine, and in the case of Bragg Liquid Aminos, the histamine levels are typically very low. However, some individuals with histamine intolerance might still experience symptoms, not necessarily from histamine in the product, but because soy products can sometimes act as "histamine liberators," triggering the body to release its own stored histamine.
Comparison of Bragg Aminos vs. High-Histamine Foods
To put the histamine content of Bragg Liquid Aminos into perspective, it's helpful to compare it with other foods commonly known for their high histamine levels.
| Food Item | Production Process | Key Histamine Factor | Potential for High Histamine | Relevance to Histamine Intolerance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bragg Liquid Aminos | Acid hydrolysis, not fermented. | Contains histidine, but manufacturing avoids fermentation. | Low; manufacturing process reduces risk, but can act as a liberator for some. | Individual reactions vary; trial and error recommended. |
| Traditional Soy Sauce | Fermented with mold cultures and wheat. | Fermentation by bacteria can convert histidine into histamine. | High; a well-known trigger for histamine intolerance. | Generally avoided on a low-histamine diet. |
| Aged Cheese | Aged and fermented dairy. | Bacterial action during aging significantly increases histamine and other biogenic amines. | Very High; a major dietary source of histamine. | A prime food to avoid with histamine intolerance. |
| Sauerkraut | Fermented cabbage. | Lactic acid fermentation can produce histamine. | Can be high; histamine levels vary based on fermentation time and method. | Should be approached with caution; homemade may have lower histamine. |
| Cured Meats | Fermented, cured, or smoked. | Bacterial processes during curing significantly elevate histamine and tyramine. | High; common trigger for histamine symptoms. | Best to avoid for those sensitive to histamine. |
The Variability of Histamine Intolerance
Histamine intolerance, or HIT, is a complex condition where the body has difficulty breaking down histamine, often due to a deficiency in the enzyme diamine oxidase (DAO). Because tolerance levels are highly individual, one person might react to a food that another person tolerates well. This makes it challenging to give a definitive yes or no answer about any food. Factors such as gut health, overall histamine load from other foods, and the individual's DAO enzyme activity all play a role.
Managing Your Reaction to Soy
If you have histamine intolerance and are concerned about Bragg Liquid Aminos, the best approach is to test your individual tolerance carefully. When reintroducing a food, start with a very small amount and monitor your symptoms. A food diary can be a very useful tool for tracking your body's unique response to different foods.
For those who find that Bragg's is a trigger, there are several low-histamine alternatives for adding a savory, umami flavor to meals. Coconut aminos are a popular choice, and tests have shown some brands have very low or undetectable histamine levels. Short-fermented, low-histamine soy sauces or miso made with specific, non-histamine-producing strains of bacteria also exist, but require careful sourcing. Always read labels and, if possible, research the manufacturer's fermentation process to be certain.
What This Means for Your Diet
Overall, while Bragg Liquid Aminos are made from soy and contain histidine, their acid hydrolysis process means they are not a fermented, high-histamine food in the same category as aged cheese or traditional soy sauce. The potential issue for those with histamine intolerance lies in soy's potential as a 'histamine liberator' rather than a direct histamine source. For some, this effect will be negligible, while for others, it may cause symptoms. This highlights the importance of personalized dietary management for histamine intolerance, rather than relying on blanket statements about food groups.
Conclusion
While Bragg Liquid Aminos are not inherently high in histamine due to their production process, they can be a potential issue for some individuals with histamine intolerance because soy can act as a histamine liberator. The variability of individual reactions, combined with external factors like gut health, makes it crucial to approach this food with caution and test your own tolerance carefully. For a savory flavor without the potential histamine concerns, alternatives like certain brands of coconut aminos may be a safer choice.
Alternative Low-Histamine Seasoning Options
If you find that Bragg Liquid Aminos trigger your symptoms, consider these alternatives for adding a similar flavor profile to your cooking:
- Coconut Aminos: Sourced from coconut blossom nectar, many brands have been tested to be very low in histamine. They offer a slightly sweeter, salty flavor profile.
- Homemade Broth: Making your own broth with fresh, low-histamine vegetables can provide a savory depth to your dishes without the risk of biogenic amines.
- Salt & Spices: Utilizing high-quality sea salt and a variety of fresh or dried herbs and spices can create complex flavors without relying on soy-based products. Ensure your spice blends don't contain fillers or high-histamine ingredients.
- White Wine Vinegar: While some vinegars are problematic, distilled white wine vinegar is often better tolerated in small amounts by those with histamine issues.
- Fresh Lemon Juice: The acidity of lemon juice can brighten flavors and cut through richness, serving as a substitute for the tanginess in Bragg's.
Remember, the best approach for managing histamine intolerance is a personalized one. By understanding the factors at play and carefully testing your individual triggers, you can navigate your diet effectively and enjoy a variety of flavorful meals.
What is the difference between histamine content and histamine-releasing properties?
Histamine Content: The direct amount of histamine present in a food item. Fermented, aged, or poorly stored foods tend to have high levels of direct histamine. Histamine-Releasing Properties: A substance that triggers the body's mast cells to release its own stored histamine, even if the food itself contains little to no histamine. Soy is an example of a potential histamine liberator. It's the difference between ingesting histamine directly versus prompting your body to create more of it internally.
How can you test for histamine intolerance reactions to Bragg's?
Elimination and Reintroduction: The most reliable method is to eliminate Bragg Liquid Aminos from your diet for a period of time, then reintroduce a small amount and monitor your symptoms carefully in a food diary. Work with a healthcare professional for a structured approach.
Outbound Link
For more information on the complexities of histamine in food, you can consult research articles on the National Institutes of Health website, such as this study on biogenic amines in fermented foods.
