Are Lima Beans and Edamame the Same?

While they are both green legumes, edamame and lima beans are entirely different plants, with edamame being an immature soybean and lima beans belonging to a separate genus. Their distinct origins, appearances, and nutritional compositions mean they offer different culinary experiences and health benefits.

Quick Summary

Though both are green legumes, edamame and lima beans are distinct, hailing from different plant families with unique origins, textures, and nutrient profiles. This article details their key differences and how they compare.

Key Points

• Botanical Difference: Edamame is an immature soybean (Glycine max), while lima beans (Phaseolus lunatus) are a different legume species.

• Origin: Edamame originated in Asia, and lima beans are native to South and Central America.

• Appearance and Texture: Edamame are small, plump, and firm with a nutty flavor, whereas lima beans are larger, flatter, and have a creamy, starchy texture.

• Nutritional Highlights: Edamame is a complete protein and higher in fat, while lima beans are higher in carbs and fiber.

• Culinary Uses: Edamame is often served as a steamed appetizer or in salads, while lima beans are common in soups, stews, and side dishes.

The question, "Are lima beans and edamame the same?", is a common one, given their similar appearance. However, beyond being green legumes, they are quite distinct from one another. Edamame is a young, immature soybean, whereas lima beans are an entirely different type of bean, botanically known as Phaseolus lunatus. This fundamental botanical difference leads to variations in their flavor, texture, and nutritional makeup.

Botanical and Geographic Origins

Edamame and lima beans originate from vastly different parts of the world. The journey of edamame begins in Asia, with evidence of its cultivation tracing back thousands of years in China and its popularization in Japanese cuisine. Edamame, which is the young, green harvest of the soybean (Glycine max), is picked before the beans fully ripen and harden.

In stark contrast, lima beans trace their roots back to South and Central America, with two distinct domestication events occurring thousands of years ago. The bean is named after the city of Lima, Peru, where it has a long history of cultivation. They are also known as "butter beans" in various parts of the world due to their creamy texture when cooked.

Appearance, Flavor, and Texture

While a superficial glance might make them appear similar, a closer look reveals significant differences in their physical attributes and how they are cooked and eaten.

• Edamame: The beans are small, plump, and a vibrant green color. They are typically served in the pod, steamed or boiled and sprinkled with salt, as a popular snack or appetizer. When cooked, they have a firm, slightly crunchy texture and a mild, sweet, and nutty flavor.
• Lima Beans: Lima beans are larger and flatter than edamame, with a paler green hue. They can have a creamy, buttery texture when cooked thoroughly, which is why they are often called butter beans. Their flavor is milder and more starchy compared to edamame.

The pods also differ. Edamame pods are edible, though usually discarded after the beans are eaten, while lima bean pods are not edible and must be discarded.

Nutritional Comparison

Both legumes are healthy additions to a diet, but their nutritional profiles are not identical. Here is a comparison of 100g servings of cooked, boiled edamame and large, mature cooked lima beans:

Nutrient	Edamame (100g cooked)	Lima Beans (100g cooked)
Calories	~140 kcal	~103 kcal
Protein	~11.5 g	~6.05 g
Carbohydrates	~8.63 g	~19.3 g
Fat	~7.57 g	~0.34 g
Fiber	~5 g	~5.3 g

Some notable nutritional differences include:

• Protein Quality: Edamame is a complete protein, containing all nine essential amino acids, making it a valuable protein source for vegetarian and vegan diets.
• Vitamins and Minerals: Edamame is richer in folate, vitamin K, calcium, and manganese, while lima beans provide slightly more fiber and potassium.
• Carbohydrates and Fat: Edamame is lower in carbohydrates and higher in fat, whereas lima beans have higher carbs and are nearly fat-free.

Culinary Uses and Preparation

Because of their differing textures and flavors, the beans are typically used in different culinary applications, though some overlap exists.

Edamame is most commonly used in:

• Appetizers: Steamed and salted in the pod.
• Salads and Stir-fries: Shelled edamame adds a pop of color, sweetness, and a pleasant chewiness.
• Snacks: Roasted and seasoned for a crunchy, healthy snack.

Lima beans are most commonly used in:

• Soups and Stews: Their creamy texture holds up well and adds a hearty element.
• Succotash: A classic dish combining lima beans, corn, and other vegetables.
• Side Dishes: Often served simply boiled or buttered.

Despite their differences, they can be substituted for one another in certain recipes, especially in dishes like bean salads or some soups, as long as you account for the textural and flavor differences. However, edamame's slightly firmer texture and nutty flavor are not a perfect match for the creaminess of lima beans.

Conclusion

In conclusion, despite their superficial similarities, lima beans and edamame are distinct legumes with different botanical origins, physical characteristics, and nutritional compositions. Edamame, the young soybean from Asia, offers a firmer, nuttier, and protein-rich option, often served as an appetizer. Lima beans, or butter beans, from the Americas, provide a creamier, starchier profile, ideal for stews and side dishes. While both are excellent plant-based foods, understanding their unique attributes can help you choose the right one for your culinary needs.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can I substitute edamame for lima beans in a recipe?

Yes, you can substitute edamame for lima beans in many recipes like salads or soups, but be aware of the differences in texture and flavor. Edamame is firmer and nuttier, while lima beans are creamier and starchier.

Is edamame healthier than lima beans?

Neither is definitively healthier; they have different nutritional strengths. Edamame is a complete protein and higher in certain vitamins like K and folate, while lima beans are lower in fat and higher in certain minerals like potassium.

Do lima beans have more fiber than edamame?

Yes, mature lima beans typically contain slightly more dietary fiber per serving than edamame. A 100g serving of lima beans has about 7g of fiber, while edamame has about 5.2g.

Where do edamame and lima beans come from?

Edamame is native to Asia, with a long history in countries like China and Japan, while lima beans are native to South and Central America.

What are the main flavor differences?

Edamame has a sweeter, nuttier, and more earthy taste, while lima beans have a mild, starchy flavor, often described as buttery.

Can you eat edamame and lima bean pods?

You can typically eat the pod of edamame, especially if they are young, but the pods of lima beans are not edible and should always be discarded.

What are other names for lima beans?

Lima beans are also commonly known as butter beans, particularly in the Southern United States and the United Kingdom.

What is a complete protein?

A complete protein contains all nine essential amino acids necessary for the body. Edamame is considered a complete plant-based protein, which is rare.

Are edamame and lima beans part of the same plant family?

Yes, both edamame (a soybean) and lima beans are part of the legume family, Fabaceae, but they belong to different genera: Glycine for edamame and Phaseolus for lima beans.

Which bean is higher in fat?

Edamame contains significantly more fat than lima beans. A 100g serving of edamame has approximately 5.2g of fat, while lima beans have only about 0.38g.

Is one more common in Japanese cuisine?

Yes, edamame is a staple in Japanese cuisine, often served steamed with salt as an appetizer. Lima beans are not typically found in Japanese dishes.

Does cooking change their nutritional value?

Cooking methods like boiling, steaming, or roasting can alter the calorie and nutrient density of both beans. For example, salting edamame increases its sodium content. However, their core nutritional profiles remain distinct.

Citations

• Bob's Red Mill. (2025, February 6). Edamame vs. Lima Beans. https://www.bobsredmill.com/articles/edamame-vs-lima-beans
• A-Z Animals. (2023, August 3). Edamame vs. Lima Beans: What's the Difference?. https://a-z-animals.com/blog/edamame-vs-lima-beans/
• Food Struct. (2023, December 25). Lima beans vs. Edamame — Health Impact and Nutrition .... https://foodstruct.com/compare/limabeans-large-matureseeds-cooked-boiled-withoutsalt-vs-edamame
• Yahoo. (2024, May 16). No, Edamame Isn't Made With Lima Beans. https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/no-edamame-isnt-made-lima-151507924.html
• Foodie. (2024, April 22). What Really Separates Lima Beans From Edamame. https://www.foodie.com/1566237/difference-between-lima-beans-edamame/
• Medical News Today. (2023, November 29). Edamame: Nutrition, recipes, benefits, how to eat, and more. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/280285
• InstaCare. (2025, April 14). Lima Beans - Health Benefits, Nutrition Facts, and More. https://instacare.pk/blog/lima-beans-health-benefits
• Yahoo. (2024, May 9). Lima Beans Vs Edamame: They're Not As Similar As They Appear. https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/lima-beans-vs-edamame-theyre-161517810.html
• Food Struct. (2023, December 25). Lima beans vs. Edamame — Health Impact and Nutrition .... https://foodstruct.com/compare/limabeans-large-matureseeds-cooked-boiled-withoutsalt-vs-edamame
• Bob's Red Mill. (2025, February 6). Edamame vs. Lima Beans. https://www.bobsredmill.com/articles/edamame-vs-lima-beans

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use lima beans in place of edamame?

Yes, you can substitute them in many recipes, such as soups or bean salads, but the texture and flavor will be different. Edamame is firmer and nuttier, while lima beans are creamier and starchier.

Is one bean nutritionally superior to the other?

No, each has its own nutritional benefits. Edamame is a complete protein and higher in some vitamins, but lima beans are lower in fat and higher in carbs and fiber.

What is the key difference between the two legumes?

The most significant difference is their botanical classification and origin; edamame is a young soybean from Asia, and the lima bean is a distinct bean species from the Americas.

Can you eat the pods of edamame and lima beans?

No, you should only eat the beans inside. While edamame is often served in the pod, you discard it before eating the beans, and lima bean pods are not edible at all.

Why is edamame sometimes considered a 'superfood'?

Edamame is rich in protein, fiber, and essential nutrients like vitamin C, calcium, magnesium, and iron, contributing to various health benefits, which is why it's often called a superfood.

Are edamame and lima beans part of the same plant family?

They are both in the Fabaceae (legume) family but belong to different genera: Glycine for edamame and Phaseolus for lima beans.

What is a complete protein, and why does it matter?

A complete protein contains all nine essential amino acids. Edamame is a complete plant-based protein, which is important for vegetarians and vegans who may need alternative protein sources.

What is the flavor profile of lima beans?

Lima beans have a mild, starchy flavor, and when cooked, they have a creamy, buttery texture, which is why they are sometimes called 'butter beans'.

Why do edamame and lima beans appear so similar?

Their similar green color is mainly a coincidence. Edamame is green because it's an immature soybean, while lima beans are naturally green in their immature state.

How are edamame and lima beans typically cooked?

Edamame is usually steamed or boiled and seasoned, often served in the pod as a snack. Lima beans are cooked until soft and creamy, often used in soups, stews, or casseroles.