Skip to content

Are My Home Grown Potatoes Safe to Eat? A Guide to Identifying Toxic Potatoes

4 min read

According to the National Capital Poison Center, green potatoes are not safe to eat due to a toxic compound called solanine. This raises a critical question for many home gardeners: are my home grown potatoes safe to eat? The answer depends on their appearance and how they have been stored.

Quick Summary

This guide explains the signs of toxic home grown potatoes, focusing on the dangers of green skin and sprouts which indicate high levels of solanine. Learn safe handling, storage, and preparation methods to enjoy your harvest without risk.

Key Points

  • Solanine is toxic: The compounds solanine and chaconine, natural toxins in potatoes, increase when exposed to light or damage, and can cause poisoning in large doses.

  • Green is a warning sign: Green skin, caused by chlorophyll, indicates increased solanine levels; completely peel or discard green potatoes.

  • Extensive sprouts are a risk: While small sprouts can be removed, extensive sprouting and soft texture indicate high toxin levels and spoilage.

  • Taste test is crucial: If a potato tastes bitter or causes a burning sensation, it contains high solanine and should be discarded, regardless of appearance.

  • Proper storage is preventative: Store potatoes in a cool, dark, dry, and well-ventilated space, away from sunlight and other produce like onions, to prevent greening and sprouting.

  • Cooking does not eliminate solanine: High temperatures from boiling or frying do not effectively remove solanine, so trimming or discarding affected potatoes is essential.

  • Err on the side of caution: The golden rule is 'when in doubt, throw it out,' especially when dealing with potatoes showing significant signs of spoilage or toxicity.

In This Article

Understanding the Threat: Solanine and Glycoalkaloids

Potatoes naturally produce compounds called glycoalkaloids, including solanine and chaconine, as a defense mechanism against pests and diseases. In small amounts, these compounds are harmless. However, their concentration increases significantly when a potato is exposed to light or physical damage. High levels of solanine are toxic to humans and can cause a range of unpleasant symptoms, from digestive upset to more severe health issues in rare cases.

Signs Your Potatoes Might Be Unsafe

For home gardeners, spotting potentially unsafe potatoes is crucial. While a perfect harvest is the goal, some potatoes might show signs that they're no longer fit for consumption. Here's what to look for:

  • Green skin: The most common and visible sign of elevated solanine is a green tint on the potato's skin or flesh. The green color itself comes from chlorophyll, which is harmless, but its presence is a clear indicator that solanine levels are also high.
  • Sprouts or 'eyes': As potatoes age, they begin to sprout, or grow 'eyes'. The highest concentration of solanine is found in the sprouts and the surrounding area. While small, firm sprouts can sometimes be removed, extensive sprouting suggests the potato is past its prime and has higher toxin levels.
  • Soft or shriveled texture: A firm potato is a fresh potato. If your home-grown potatoes become soft, mushy, or shriveled, it's a definitive sign of spoilage. This is a clear signal to discard the tuber.
  • Bitter taste: Solanine has a distinctly bitter flavor. If a cooked potato tastes bitter or causes a burning sensation in your mouth or throat, spit it out and discard the rest immediately.
  • Mold or pungent odor: Visible mold is an obvious indicator that a potato should not be eaten. A foul or musty smell is also a strong warning sign of rot, even if no mold is visible.

Safe Handling and Preparation

To minimize your risk, proper handling is key from the moment of harvest. By following these simple steps, you can safely enjoy your harvest.

  • Cut out green spots and sprouts: For potatoes with minor greening or small sprouts, you can often salvage them. Use a knife or peeler to completely remove the skin and any green-tinged areas. Dig out the 'eyes' and cut away any surrounding green flesh. Peeling and trimming can reduce solanine levels significantly.
  • When in doubt, throw it out: This is a gardener's golden rule. If a potato is very green, soft, or tastes bitter, the safest course of action is to discard it. The risk of illness, however mild, is not worth it, especially for children who are more susceptible to solanine poisoning due to their lower body weight.
  • Cooking doesn't destroy solanine: It is a common misconception that cooking methods like boiling, baking, or frying eliminate solanine. While some toxins may be reduced, these compounds are heat-stable and are not completely destroyed by typical cooking temperatures.
  • Never reuse potato cooking water: If you boiled potatoes with green sections or sprouts, do not reuse the water for other cooking, as some of the toxic compounds may have leached into it.

Safe Storage for Home-Grown Potatoes

Preventing toxicity in the first place is the best strategy. Proper storage is essential for extending the life of your potatoes and keeping them safe.

  • Cure before storing: After harvesting, allow your potatoes to cure for 7-10 days in a dark, well-ventilated space with moderate temperatures (around 60-65°F). This process hardens their skins and heals minor wounds, preparing them for long-term storage.
  • Store in a cool, dark, dry place: The ideal long-term storage location is a dark, cool, and dry space, like a basement, cellar, or pantry. Temperatures between 40-50°F and high humidity are optimal. Use a breathable container, such as a paper bag, mesh sack, or basket, to allow for good air circulation.
  • Avoid sunlight: Light exposure is the primary trigger for solanine production. Keep stored potatoes completely in the dark to prevent greening.
  • Keep away from other produce: Storing potatoes near fruits and other vegetables, especially onions, can cause them to sprout faster. Onions release ethylene gas, which accelerates ripening and sprouting in potatoes.
  • Don't wash before storing: The soil on freshly harvested potatoes helps protect them. Only wash them right before you are ready to use them. Excess moisture encourages mold and decay.

Comparison Table: Safe vs. Unsafe Potatoes

Feature Safe Potato Unsafe Potato
Appearance Firm to the touch, tight skin, uniform color Soft, mushy, wrinkled skin, visible mold
Color Evenly colored, typical for the variety Prominent green areas on the skin or flesh
Sprouts/Eyes Few, small, non-existent, or easily removed Long, extensive sprouts indicating high toxin levels
Smell Earthy, starchy, and fresh Musty, rotten, or foul odor
Taste Mild, typical potato flavor Distinctly bitter or causes a burning sensation
Storage Stored in cool, dark, dry, breathable conditions Exposed to sunlight, heat, or improper ventilation

Conclusion

Home-grown potatoes can be a safe and delicious addition to your meals, provided you take a few simple precautions. By understanding the risk of solanine and knowing how to identify potentially toxic potatoes, you can protect yourself and your family. Proper storage is your first line of defense, preventing the conditions that cause greening and sprouting. Always inspect your harvest for softness, green spots, and extensive sprouts before cooking. When a potato shows clear signs of being unsafe, don't hesitate to toss it out. Following these guidelines ensures your hard work in the garden results in a harvest you can confidently and safely enjoy. For more information on identifying solanine poisoning symptoms, consult resources like the UF Health article, 'Potato plant poisoning'.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, for a potato with only a small, localized green spot, you can cut away the green section and peel the potato completely. However, if the potato is largely green or tastes bitter, it is safer to discard the entire thing, as the toxin can permeate the flesh.

If the potato is still firm and has only small, minimal sprouts, it is generally safe to eat after thoroughly removing the sprouts and any surrounding 'eyes'. Extensive sprouting, however, indicates higher toxin levels and nutrient depletion, making it best to throw the potato away.

Consuming a potato with high levels of solanine can cause gastrointestinal distress, including nausea, vomiting, stomach pain, and diarrhea. Severe poisoning is rare but can include more serious neurological symptoms.

The best practice is to first cure the potatoes for 7-10 days and then store them in a cool (40-50°F), dark, dry, and well-ventilated place like a basement or cellar. Use a paper bag or mesh sack, and keep them away from other ripening produce.

No, you should not wash potatoes before storing them. The excess moisture can encourage mold and spoilage. Brush off any large clumps of dirt, but only wash the potatoes right before you plan to cook them.

Peeling can significantly reduce the solanine content, as it is most concentrated in the skin and the green layers just beneath it. For a potato with mild greening, peeling and trimming is effective. For severely green or bitter potatoes, peeling may not be enough to make it safe.

New potatoes can be safe to eat right after harvest, especially if they are not exposed to sunlight. However, care should be taken to ensure they have not been exposed to light during or after harvest, which would increase solanine levels just as it does in mature potatoes.

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.