What is the origin of proteins in wine?
Proteins in wine originate from two primary sources: the grapes themselves and the yeast used during fermentation.
-
Grape-Derived Proteins: Grape berries naturally contain soluble proteins. These include pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins, such as thaumatin-like proteins (TLPs) and chitinases, which act as a defense mechanism against pathogens like fungi. The concentration of these proteins varies by grape variety, vineyard practices, and ripeness. For example, the stress from fungal infections can increase their presence. Grape skin contact during fermentation, which is more common in red wines, can also affect protein levels.
-
Yeast-Derived Proteins: During fermentation, yeast plays a crucial role. As yeast cells break down and die (autolysis), they release their own proteins into the wine. While these yeast-derived proteins can contribute to the wine's final composition, they are not typically the primary cause of protein instability.
The critical role of proteins in wine stability
While nutritionally insignificant, the presence of proteins is a major concern for winemakers, particularly for white and rosé wines. The main issue they cause is 'protein haze,' which is a cloudiness that can form in bottled wine, especially when it is exposed to temperature fluctuations.
- Unfolding and Aggregation: Proteins in the finished wine are initially soluble. However, under conditions like heat or certain pH levels, they can denature, or 'unfold,' exposing hydrophobic parts of the molecule. This allows the proteins to aggregate with each other, forming visible particles that create a haze.
- Heat Stability Tests: Winemakers perform heat stability tests to predict this haze formation. They take a sample of the finished wine and heat it to simulate potential bottle-aging conditions. If a haze forms, they know the wine needs further treatment before bottling.
- Impact on White vs. Red Wines: Protein haze is a more significant problem for white and rosé wines because consumers expect them to be perfectly clear. In contrast, most proteins in red wine are naturally removed during fermentation. The higher levels of tannins in red wines bind with and precipitate the proteins, which settle out with the sediment.
Protein removal techniques: A deeper look
To prevent protein haze and ensure a clear, stable product, winemakers use fining agents, which are substances added to the wine to remove unwanted particles. The choice of fining agent can also impact whether a wine is considered vegan.
Comparison of Common Fining Agents
| Fining Agent | Source | Purpose | Vegan Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bentonite Clay | Volcanic ash | Removes proteins to prevent haze | Vegan | Most common commercial agent; effective but can remove desirable aromas. |
| Egg Whites (Albumen) | Eggs | Softens harsh tannins and clarifies red wines. | Not Vegan | Often used for high-tannin reds; trace amounts may remain. |
| Casein | Milk Protein | Clarifies wine and prevents oxidation. | Not Vegan | Mostly used on white wines; traces can cause issues for those with milk allergies. |
| Isinglass | Fish Bladders | Clarifies white wine. | Not Vegan | Historically common, less so now; fish allergens may be present. |
| Vegan Alternatives | Plant-based, mineral-based | Various clarifying purposes, often targeting specific compounds. | Vegan | Includes vegetable gelatine, pea protein, carbon, and active yeast polysaccharides (mannoproteins). |
Health implications: Allergies and intolerance
While the minute protein levels in wine pose no nutritional benefit, they can be an issue for individuals with specific allergies.
- Grape Allergens: Some people are allergic to specific proteins found in grapes, such as lipid transfer proteins (LTPs), though this is relatively rare. A reaction to wine containing grape allergens is possible, though the winemaking process may inactivate or remove these proteins.
- Allergens from Fining Agents: A more significant concern is the residue from animal-derived fining agents. Although winemakers aim to remove these agents, trace amounts of allergens like casein (milk protein), egg whites, or isinglass (fish protein) can remain, potentially causing reactions in highly sensitive individuals.
Conclusion
In summary, proteins are naturally present in wine, originating from grapes and yeast, but their quantity is nutritionally insignificant. Their importance lies in their potential to cause aesthetic problems like protein haze, particularly in white and rosé wines, necessitating their removal. Winemakers use fining agents like bentonite clay, and sometimes animal-derived products, to achieve clarity. For consumers, the minimal protein content is a non-issue unless they have allergies to specific grape proteins or, more commonly, to animal-based fining agents. This makes the winemaking process and fining practices a crucial consideration for vegans and those with sensitivities to milk, egg, or fish products.
Note: For individuals with severe allergies to milk, egg, or fish, it is essential to seek out wines specifically labeled as vegan or to contact the manufacturer to ensure no cross-contamination occurred during the fining process. The wine industry is increasingly moving toward vegan-friendly and alternative fining methods.
