Understanding the 'No' to Besan During Fasting
For many devotees observing a religious fast, particularly during festivals like Navratri or the bi-monthly Ekadashi, the dietary rules are guided by ancient traditions and scriptural interpretations. The primary reason besan is disallowed is because it is derived from chickpeas or chana dal, which are legumes and pulses. The fast's purpose is to purify the body and mind by consuming only 'satvik' foods, which are considered pure, light, and easy to digest, while avoiding 'tamasic' foods like grains, pulses, and onion or garlic.
The prohibition extends to all forms of legumes and lentils, not just besan. This includes moong dal, kidney beans, and all flours derived from pulses. The belief is that these foods can produce a 'heaviness' that is counter-productive to the spiritual clarity and focus sought during a fast.
The Importance of Satvik Foods
During a fast, the focus is on consuming foods that are sattvic in nature. The Bhagavad Gita and other Vedic texts categorize foods into three types: Sattvic, Rajasic, and Tamasic. Sattvic foods are thought to increase purity, strength, health, and peace of mind. They are generally fresh, seasonal, and easy to digest. Rajasic foods, which are overly spicy, salty, or bitter, are believed to increase passion and restlessness. Tamasic foods are those that are heavy and dulling, which includes most grains, legumes, and even garlic and onion.
By avoiding besan and other legume-based flours, fasters adhere to this philosophical principle, choosing lighter alternatives that support the spiritual intention of the fast.
Safe and Delicious Alternatives to Besan
Just because besan is off the menu doesn't mean you can't enjoy a variety of delicious and satisfying foods while fasting. Several flours and food items are widely considered acceptable for vrat or upvas meals.
- Kuttu ka Atta (Buckwheat Flour): This is a popular alternative for making pooris and rotis during Navratri. Despite its name, buckwheat is not a cereal grain but a pseudo-cereal, making it compliant with fasting rules.
- Singhare ka Atta (Water Chestnut Flour): Another common vrat-friendly flour, it is often used for making fried items like pakoras and tikkis.
- Rajgira ka Atta (Amaranth Flour): Amaranth is a powerhouse pseudo-cereal rich in protein and is used to make rotis and other baked goods suitable for fasting.
- Samak ke Chawal (Barnyard Millet): This is a millet that serves as an excellent substitute for rice and can be used to make khichdi or pulao.
- Sabudana (Tapioca Pearls): A staple during many fasts, sabudana is used for making khichdi, vadas, and kheer.
- Dairy Products: Milk, yogurt, paneer, and ghee are all permitted and are a great source of protein and energy.
- Vegetables: Potatoes, sweet potatoes, pumpkin, and bottle gourd are widely accepted.
- Fruits and Nuts: All fresh and dried fruits are allowed, along with nuts like almonds, cashews, and peanuts.
Besan vs. Vrat-Friendly Flours: A Comparison
| Feature | Besan (Gram Flour) | Kuttu ka Atta (Buckwheat Flour) | Singhare ka Atta (Water Chestnut Flour) | 
|---|---|---|---|
| Source | Chickpeas (legume/pulse) | Buckwheat (pseudo-cereal) | Water Chestnut (fruit) | 
| Fasting Status | Not Permitted | Permitted | Permitted | 
| Taste Profile | Nutty, earthy flavor | Earthy and slightly bitter | Mild, neutral flavor | 
| Texture | Very fine powder | Slightly grainy | Smooth and fine | 
| Common Uses | Pakoras, kadhi, dhokla | Rotis, pooris, parathas | Pakoras, tikkis, halwa | 
| Nutritional Profile | High in protein and fiber | Good source of fiber and magnesium | Rich in carbohydrates and minerals | 
| Preparation | Needs thorough cooking to remove raw taste | Relatively easy to cook | Versatile for various preparations | 
Conclusion
In summary, the answer to "can we eat besan in fast?" is a clear no for the vast majority of Hindu fasting traditions, including Navratri and Ekadashi. The prohibition stems from besan's origin as a legume, which is considered a non-satvik food. Adherence to these dietary rules is a way of purifying the body and mind in line with the spiritual goals of the fast. Thankfully, plenty of delicious and nutritious alternatives exist, such as kuttu, singhara, and rajgira flours, ensuring that one can observe their religious duties without compromising on taste or nourishment. For further reading on this topic, consult the relevant religious texts or sources cited like Medanta for detailed dietary guidance during fasting periods.