The Rise and Fall of a Strict Carnivore Diet
Dr. Paul Saladino, known as "Carnivore MD," gained prominence advocating for a strict carnivore diet consisting exclusively of meat, fish, eggs, and some dairy, arguing against plant consumption. After years on this restrictive diet, focused on nose-to-tail animal consumption, he began experiencing health issues.
Health Problems on the Strict Carnivore Diet
Saladino reported several adverse effects:
- Low testosterone
- Sleep disturbances
- Heart palpitations
- Muscle cramps
- Feeling cold
- Chronically low insulin
He publicly acknowledged these struggles, stating that long-term ketosis might not be beneficial for him or most humans.
The Transition to an "Animal-Based" Diet
Saladino evolved his diet to an "animal-based" approach to retain benefits while mitigating negative effects by reintroducing select plant foods. This was a notable shift for his followers, given his previous stance on vegetables.
The Components of Saladino's New Diet
His current diet includes:
- Meat and Organs
- Fruit (considered "least toxic" plant foods)
- Honey (for carbohydrates and electrolyte balance)
- Raw Dairy (cheese, butter, milk)
The addition of fruit and honey provided carbohydrates, which he found necessary for electrolyte retention and resolving sleep and hormone issues. More information about Saladino can be found on his Wikipedia page.
Comparing Saladino's Diet Phases
| Feature | Strict Carnivore (c. 2018–2022) | Animal-Based (c. 2022–Present) | 
|---|---|---|
| Core Foods | Meat, fish, eggs, some dairy | Meat, organs, fruit, honey, raw dairy | 
| Carbohydrate Sources | None (ketogenic) | Fruit, honey | 
| Plant Foods | Excluded all plant foods | Includes fruit (avoids most vegetables, grains, seeds) | 
| Primary Rationale | Avoid plant toxins; ancestral eating | Avoid plant toxins; ancestral eating with carbohydrates for hormonal and metabolic health | 
| Reported Effects | Low testosterone, sleep issues, muscle cramps, heart palpitations | Resolution of previous symptoms for Saladino (e.g., improved sleep, hormones) | 
Expert Opinions on the Change
Experts and critics note that despite the changes, his diet still involves high animal product intake and raw dairy, which may pose health risks like increased LDL cholesterol. The continued exclusion of most plant foods is also questioned. Many in the health community emphasize the importance of a varied diet.
Key Lessons from Paul Saladino's Journey
- Listen to persistent negative health symptoms.
- Be cautious of rigid dietary rules; individual needs vary.
- Nutrient diversity, including carbohydrates, can be important.
- Ancestral dietary patterns may not directly translate to optimal modern health.
Conclusion
Paul Saladino did change his diet from strict carnivore to an "animal-based" approach including fruit, honey, and raw dairy. This shift was prompted by negative health effects from long-term ketosis. While his new diet has both supporters and critics, his experience highlights the importance of individual responses to diet and the complexity of finding an optimal eating pattern.