Skip to content

Do humans eat anything that wasn't alive? Unpacking a curious dietary question

3 min read

Over 60% of the human body is made up of water, a fundamental substance that was never alive. This fact points to a larger truth: while most dietary energy comes from once-living sources, humans do in fact eat anything that wasn't alive, like minerals and chemical compounds, to sustain life.

Quick Summary

Humans consume a variety of non-living substances, including essential minerals and water, alongside foods from living organisms. Additives, salt, and even processed items fall into this category, proving that our diets extend beyond the realm of the once-living.

Key Points

  • Inorganic Essentials: The human diet includes crucial non-living inorganic nutrients like water and essential minerals such as sodium, calcium, and iron.

  • Minerals are Non-Living: Table salt (sodium chloride) is a prime example of a non-living mineral we consume, which is harvested from natural sources like seawater or rock deposits.

  • Synthetic and Processed Items: Many modern foods contain non-living chemical compounds like artificial sweeteners, colors, and preservatives created in a lab.

  • Fermentation Nuances: While fermenting agents like yeast and bacteria are living, they may be killed during cooking, as is the case with yeast in most baked bread.

  • Complex Refined Foods: Heavily processed items like white sugar and purified oils, though derived from once-living sources, are essentially non-living molecular structures in their final form.

  • No Energy from Minerals: Unlike organic foods that provide caloric energy, inorganic minerals offer no calories but are vital for metabolic processes and fluid balance.

  • The Circle of Consumption: The need for non-living inputs like soil minerals demonstrates that human sustenance depends on a complex web of both living and non-living components.

  • Water is Fundamental: Water, which makes up a significant portion of our bodies, is a non-living inorganic compound that is essential for life.

In This Article

The Foundation: Water and Minerals

At its core, human survival depends on more than just the organic macronutrients from plants and animals. We require inorganic substances, specifically water and minerals, to function properly. These are the most straightforward examples of non-living things we ingest daily.

Water (H₂O) is a simple inorganic compound critical for every bodily process, from cellular function to temperature regulation. It was never, and will never be, a living organism. Similarly, dietary minerals like sodium, calcium, and iron are non-living inorganic substances. These are absorbed by plants from the soil and passed up the food chain, or consumed directly by humans as supplements or ingredients. Table salt, for instance, is a mineral (sodium chloride) harvested from ancient sea deposits or through the evaporation of seawater.

Beyond the Natural: Processed and Synthetic Items

As our food production and technology have evolved, so too have the non-living ingredients we consume. Many modern food products contain synthetic or heavily processed components that were never part of a living thing.

  • Food Additives: Artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives are often synthesized in a lab and have no direct biological origin. While derived from organic compounds in some cases, the final chemical is significantly altered. A prime example is sucralose, an artificial sweetener chemically modified from sugar, but no longer resembling a natural product.
  • Leavening and Carbonation: The bubbles in bread and soda offer another interesting case. While yeast is a living fungus, it is killed during baking, making the final bread a non-living product. Similarly, the carbon dioxide used to carbonate drinks is an inorganic compound, not a living entity.
  • Refined Oils and Sugars: While their source material (e.g., plants) was once alive, the final product is often so heavily processed and refined that it is a collection of non-living molecules. While this is a grey area, the resulting white sugar or pure vegetable oil lacks the cellular structure and enzymes that classify a living food.

Comparison: Living vs. Non-Living Food Sources

To better understand the distinction, consider the differences in how we acquire and process these items. The contrast is clear when comparing the journey of a steak versus a pinch of salt.

Feature Living-Derived Food (e.g., steak) Non-Living Food (e.g., salt)
Source Animal, plant, or fungus kingdom Mineral deposits, seawater
Energy Provides caloric energy (proteins, carbs, fats) Provides no calories; essential for metabolic function
Production Growth, reproduction, photosynthesis Geological processes, evaporation, mining
Processing Butchering, harvesting, cooking Grinding, refining, purification
Biological State Was alive at harvest, cells die during cooking Was never alive; a simple mineral compound

A Deeper Dive into the Microbial World

Some food products present more nuanced examples. Fermented foods, for instance, utilize microorganisms like bacteria and yeast, which are certainly living organisms. However, in many cases, these microbes are either killed during processing or exist in a dormant state in the final product. For example, the yeast in most baked bread is killed by the high heat of the oven. In contrast, the active cultures in some yogurts and fermented vegetables are still alive and provide probiotics.

The Importance of Inorganic Nutrients

It is impossible to rely solely on organic food for sustenance. We need inorganic compounds like minerals for critical functions, including nerve transmission, muscle contraction, and fluid balance. Iron, a mineral, is required to carry oxygen in red blood cells, while calcium is essential for bone health. These are simple elements from the periodic table that cannot be biologically created from scratch within the human body. We must consume them from external sources, most of which were never alive themselves, reinforcing the breadth of things humans ingest to survive.

Conclusion: The Surprising Truth of Our Diet

While the bulk of our diet comes from things that were once living—plants, animals, and fungi—the human body relies on a host of substances that never possessed life. From the obvious examples of water and minerals to the synthetic additives and heavily processed components in modern food, our consumption extends beyond the purely organic realm. This reality underscores the complex interplay of biological and geological processes that sustain human life, and serves as a reminder that what we consider 'food' encompasses a surprisingly wide array of materials, both living and non-living.

Morton Salt's website offers a detailed look at how one of the most common non-living food items is produced, showcasing the industrial processes that bring this essential mineral to our tables.

Frequently Asked Questions

Water is not a living thing, but it is considered an essential nutrient for all life. While not a source of caloric energy, it is critical for bodily functions and is an inorganic compound.

Vitamins are organic nutrients, meaning they contain carbon as part of their structure, and can be produced by living organisms. Minerals, conversely, are inorganic and non-living.

Yes, a fruit is the product of a living plant. While the cells in the fruit are no longer performing all life processes after being picked, they were part of a once-living organism.

An unfertilized egg is a reproductive cell from a living animal but is not considered a living organism itself, as it cannot develop into a new life form without fertilization.

Honey is a natural food produced by bees, which are living creatures, from flower nectar. It is not a living organism itself but is a product derived from living sources.

Yes, vegetarians and vegans consume many non-living things, including water, minerals like salt, and any processed or synthetic ingredients that do not originate from an animal.

The key difference is whether the substance provides caloric energy. Living or once-living things like plants and animals provide the macronutrients (carbs, proteins, fats) for energy, while non-living items like minerals provide essential elements but no calories.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.