Not All Bean Pastes are Sweet
For those accustomed to Asian sweets, the idea of bean paste is often synonymous with dessert. However, this is only part of the story. The broad category of 'bean paste' includes a variety of products, some of which are distinctly sweet, while others are intensely savory, spicy, or fermented. The critical distinction lies in the ingredients and preparation method, which are tailored to the paste's final culinary use.
Sweet Bean Pastes: Anko and Shiro-an
In Japanese and Chinese cuisine, sweet bean pastes are essential for confections. Anko, or sweet red bean paste, and shiro-an, or sweet white bean paste, are two of the most common varieties.
- Anko (Sweet Red Bean Paste): Made from adzuki beans, water, and a substantial amount of sugar, anko is a staple sweet filling. It comes in two primary textures:
- Tsubuan: A chunky paste where the beans are mashed but still mostly intact.
- Koshian: A smooth, velvety paste made by sieving the mashed beans to remove the skins.
- Shiro-an (Sweet White Bean Paste): This paste is made from white beans, such as lima, navy, or cannellini beans, which are hulled and mashed with sugar. It has a milder flavor than anko and is prized for its pale color, making it easy to dye for use in beautiful wagashi (Japanese confections).
Savory and Fermented Bean Pastes
Beyond the world of desserts, many bean pastes are integral to savory cooking, particularly in Chinese and Korean food. These are often fermented and contain little to no added sugar.
Popular savory bean pastes
- Doenjang (Korean Soybean Paste): This paste is a staple in Korean cuisine, made from fermented soybeans. It is salty and earthy, used in soups, stews, and as a condiment.
- Doubanjiang (Chinese Spicy Chili Bean Paste): A key ingredient in Sichuan cooking, this paste is made from fermented broad beans and chili peppers. Its flavor profile is spicy and savory, with only a very small amount of sugar to balance the heat.
- Tianmianjiang (Chinese Sweet Bean Sauce): A thick, dark sauce made from fermented wheat flour and soybean paste. While its name includes "sweet," it is not sugary like a dessert paste but rather has a deep, savory-sweet flavor from its fermentation and is used in savory dishes like Peking duck.
- Miso (Japanese Soybean Paste): Miso is a fermented paste with a deep umami flavor. While some milder versions may have a slight sweetness, it is primarily savory and used in soups, marinades, and glazes.
The Role of Sugar in Different Bean Pastes
Sugar is not a default ingredient in all bean pastes; its inclusion is a deliberate choice tied to the paste's function. The amount of sugar can also vary widely, even within the same type of paste.
For sweet bean pastes like anko, sugar is added during the cooking process to provide sweetness, act as a preservative, and help achieve the desired texture. In contrast, savory and fermented pastes derive their flavor from the fermentation process. For example, doubanjiang gets its complexity from fermented beans and chili, not from sweetness, and any sugar present is minimal. Homemade versions of any bean paste offer the greatest control over the amount of sugar used, allowing for lower-sugar alternatives.
Sweet vs. Savory Bean Paste Comparison
| Feature | Sweet Bean Paste (e.g., Anko) | Savory Bean Paste (e.g., Doenjang) |
|---|---|---|
| Flavor Profile | Sweet, nutty, earthy | Salty, earthy, savory, often spicy |
| Primary Use | Desserts, pastries, confections | Soups, stews, sauces, marinades |
| Sugar Content | High added sugar for sweetness | Very low or no added sugar; flavor from fermentation |
| Key Ingredient | Adzuki beans (red), lima/navy beans (white) | Soybeans, broad beans, chili peppers |
| Texture | Smooth (koshian) or chunky (tsubuan) | Often chunky and rough |
| Appearance | Red, white, or greenish | Varies, from light brown to deep reddish-brown |
Conclusion: The Final Word on Sugar Content
The question of whether bean paste has sugar is entirely dependent on which kind you are referring to. Sweet varieties like red bean paste (anko) are prepared with a significant amount of added sugar for use in desserts and pastries. Conversely, savory, fermented bean pastes like Korean doenjang or Sichuan doubanjiang are primarily salty and savory, with minimal or no added sugar. When purchasing, always check the label for ingredients to determine the paste's flavor profile. Or, for complete control over the sugar content, consider making your own at home. You can find excellent, reliable recipes for both sweet and savory versions online, including this useful guide from Just One Cookbook: https://www.justonecookbook.com/white-bean-paste-shiroan/.
How to Choose the Right Bean Paste
If you're unsure which type of bean paste to use for a recipe, think about the dish's intended flavor. If it's a dessert, reach for a sweet bean paste like anko. If you're making a rich, savory stew or a spicy stir-fry, a fermented, savory variety is what you need. A quick check of the ingredient list will also give you the definitive answer regarding its sugar content.