King Arthur's Unbromated Promise
King Arthur Baking Company explicitly states that its flour has never contained bromate. The company's products are labeled as "Never Bleached, Never Bromated®". Potassium bromate is an oxidizing agent traditionally used in commercial baking to strengthen dough and improve rise. However, health concerns led to its classification as a potential human carcinogen under California's Proposition 65 in 1991. Many countries, including the UK and Canada, have banned bromate, although it remains legal in most of the U.S..
King Arthur avoids this additive by naturally aging its flour, a process that allows for natural oxidation and whitening. This aligns with their focus on high-quality, transparent ingredients and health.
The Science Behind Bromated vs. Unbromated Flour
Potassium bromate enhances dough strength and elasticity, leading to better gas retention and a lighter crumb. While baking should convert bromate to potassium bromide, tests have found residual levels in finished goods.
King Arthur's unbromated flours, such as their bread flour, achieve dough strength through higher protein content. Bakers using unbromated flour might adjust mixing times or use preferments to develop gluten.
Why Bakers Choose King Arthur's Approach
- Health and Safety: King Arthur offers an option free from a potentially carcinogenic additive.
- Ingredient Purity: The company uses American-grown wheat and no artificial preservatives.
- Consistent Results: King Arthur ensures reliable baking results through quality standards and test-baking.
Comparison: King Arthur Flour vs. Bromated Flour
| Feature | King Arthur Flour (Unbromated) | Bromated Flour (Found in some brands) |
|---|---|---|
| Bromate Content | No. Explicitly unbromated. | Contains potassium bromate (KBrO3). |
| Aging Process | Naturally aged over 2-4 weeks. | Chemical aging process is accelerated by bromate. |
| Dough Strength | Achieved naturally through high protein content and aging. | Achieved via a powerful oxidizing agent, potassium bromate. |
| Health Concerns | No associated health risks from this additive. | Linked to potential carcinogenic risks in animal studies. |
| Legality | Legal and widely accepted in the U.S. and worldwide. | Legal in most of the U.S. but banned in many other countries and specific U.S. states. |
| Baking Performance | Consistent, high-quality results from superior wheat and milling. | Can produce very high-volume loaves, especially in commercial baking. |
Health Risks of Bromated Flour
Potassium bromate has been linked to potential health risks:
- The IARC classifies potassium bromate as "possibly carcinogenic to humans" (Group 2B).
- Studies have associated it with kidney, thyroid, and other tumors in animals.
- Residual bromate can remain in baked goods.
- The EWG advocates for a U.S. ban, citing bans in other countries.
Conclusion: Your Flour Choice Matters
King Arthur flour does not contain bromine (potassium bromate), reflecting the company's commitment to unbromated and unbleached products. This makes King Arthur a reliable choice for bakers who prioritize clean ingredients and wish to avoid potentially harmful additives. While potassium bromate can enhance commercial baking, its health concerns and international bans make it a controversial additive many consumers avoid. King Arthur achieves its baking performance through high-quality ingredients, not chemical additives.
King Arthur Baking Company's commitment to unbromated flour is a cornerstone of its brand identity.