Skip to content

Does White Kidney Bean Really Work? Unpacking the Science of Carb Blockers

4 min read

According to a 2020 study, subjects taking white kidney bean extract over 35 days showed a significant reduction in body weight compared to a placebo group. This natural compound is most notably sold as a "starch blocker" and has garnered significant attention for its potential weight management benefits, but does white kidney bean really work as claimed?

Quick Summary

White kidney bean extract functions as a starch blocker by inhibiting the alpha-amylase enzyme, reducing carbohydrate absorption. While some studies show modest weight loss, results are mixed and evidence is moderate, suggesting it's an adjunct, not a sole solution for weight management.

Key Points

  • Alpha-Amylase Inhibitor: White kidney bean extract (WKBE) contains phaseolamin, a protein that blocks the starch-digesting enzyme alpha-amylase.

  • Reduced Carb Absorption: This inhibition leads to fewer starchy carbohydrates being broken down and absorbed, potentially lowering calorie intake.

  • Modest Weight Loss Potential: Some studies indicate that WKBE can assist with modest weight and fat loss, particularly when combined with a healthy diet and exercise.

  • Mixed Research Findings: While some trials show positive effects, others report inconsistent results, suggesting that WKBE is not a guaranteed solution for weight loss.

  • Glycemic Control: By slowing carb absorption, WKBE can help blunt blood sugar spikes after meals, which can aid in better glycemic control.

  • Mild Side Effects: The most common side effects are mild gastrointestinal issues like gas and bloating, which tend to subside with continued use.

  • Not a Replacement for Lifestyle Changes: For effective and sustainable weight management, WKBE should supplement, not replace, a balanced diet and regular physical activity.

In This Article

The Science Behind White Kidney Bean Extract

White kidney bean extract (WKBE), or Phaseolus vulgaris extract, is a dietary supplement derived from white kidney beans. Its primary mechanism of action centers on a protein known as phaseolamin, which acts as an alpha-amylase inhibitor.

How the "Starch Blocker" Effect Works

Alpha-amylase is a digestive enzyme secreted by your pancreas that breaks down complex carbohydrates, or starches, into simple sugars that your body can easily absorb. Phaseolamin works by blocking the function of this enzyme. By inhibiting alpha-amylase, WKBE prevents the complete digestion of some starchy carbohydrates. The result is that some of these carbs pass through the digestive system undigested, leading to a potential reduction in overall calorie absorption from starchy foods.

Research on Efficacy: Does it Deliver?

Research into the effectiveness of white kidney bean extract has yielded a mix of promising results and inconsistencies, emphasizing the need for more large-scale, long-term studies.

Evidence for Weight Management

Several studies have investigated the impact of WKBE on weight loss, often with modest results. For example, a 2020 study on obese subjects found that the extract group lost an average of 2.24 kg over 35 days, significantly more than the placebo group. Other clinical trials have similarly shown potential for modest reductions in weight and body fat when combined with a controlled diet and exercise. However, some trials have found no significant difference compared to a placebo, suggesting that the effects can be inconsistent depending on the study parameters and type of extract used.

Effects on Blood Sugar Levels

Beyond weight loss, WKBE's effect on carbohydrate absorption can help manage blood sugar levels, particularly after a starchy meal. The slower digestion and absorption of carbs can blunt the postprandial (after-meal) blood glucose spike, which is beneficial for individuals focusing on glycemic control. This effect could be particularly relevant for those with insulin resistance or pre-diabetes, though WKBE is not a replacement for prescribed medical treatment.

Key Benefits and Considerations

Benefits of White Kidney Bean Extract

  • Support for Weight Management: By acting as a starch blocker, it may help reduce calorie intake from complex carbs, supporting weight loss efforts.
  • Blood Sugar Modulation: The inhibition of alpha-amylase can help moderate blood sugar spikes after carb-heavy meals.
  • Increased Satiety: High fiber content from the whole bean can promote feelings of fullness, potentially reducing overall food intake.
  • Digestive Health: Fiber also aids in promoting regular bowel movements and gut health.

Considerations and Drawbacks

  • Digestive Side Effects: The most common side effects are mild and gastrointestinal, including gas, bloating, and soft stools, which typically lessen over time.
  • Inconsistent Results: Not all clinical trials have shown significant effects on weight loss, indicating that individual results can vary.
  • Not a Miracle Cure: It works best when combined with a balanced diet and regular exercise, and should not be relied upon as a sole solution for weight loss.

Comparing White Kidney Bean Extract to Other Weight Loss Supplements

Feature White Kidney Bean Extract Green Coffee Bean Extract Orlistat (Pharmaceutical)
Primary Mechanism Alpha-amylase inhibitor (Starch Blocker) Chlorogenic acid slows glucose release; some thermogenic effects Pancreatic lipase inhibitor (Fat Blocker)
Target Nutrient Carbohydrates Glucose metabolism Fats
Key Benefit Reduces absorption of starchy carbs Supports weight loss and increases metabolism Reduces absorption of dietary fats
Key Limitation Efficacy can be inconsistent; primarily targets starch, not all carbs Evidence is also mixed and some studies have bias Can have more severe gastrointestinal side effects
Stimulant No Yes (contains caffeine, unless decaffeinated) No

Using White Kidney Bean Extract for Best Results

To maximize the potential benefits of white kidney bean extract, it is generally recommended to take the supplement shortly before a meal, particularly one high in carbohydrates. This timing allows the phaseolamin to be present in the digestive system and inhibit alpha-amylase as the food is being consumed. Dosages vary between products, but typical recommendations range from 500 to 1500 mg per day. Always follow the specific instructions on the product label and consult a healthcare provider, especially if you have pre-existing health conditions like diabetes or are taking other medications.

Conclusion

So, does white kidney bean really work? The evidence suggests that for some, it can, but its effectiveness is not guaranteed. As a starch blocker, it offers a plausible mechanism for reducing the caloric impact of carbohydrate-rich meals by inhibiting alpha-amylase. While some studies show encouraging results for modest weight loss and better blood sugar control, findings are inconsistent across the board. Therefore, WKBE is best viewed as a potential aid to be used in conjunction with a healthy diet and regular exercise, not a standalone solution. For optimal and long-term weight management, the fundamentals of a balanced lifestyle remain the most effective approach.

For more information on the research, consult this review on the effects of white kidney bean extract: It's No Has Bean: A Review of the Effects of White Kidney Bean Extract on Body Composition and Metabolic Health.

Frequently Asked Questions

White kidney bean extract contains phaseolamin, an alpha-amylase inhibitor that blocks the enzyme responsible for digesting starches. This reduces the number of calories absorbed from complex carbohydrates, which can lead to modest weight and fat loss when combined with a healthy lifestyle.

Yes, some individuals may experience mild gastrointestinal side effects such as gas, bloating, and diarrhea, especially when first starting supplementation. These symptoms often decrease over time.

For maximum effect, it is generally recommended to take the supplement about 30 minutes before a carbohydrate-rich meal. This timing ensures the alpha-amylase inhibitor is active in your digestive system when the carbs are consumed.

While generally considered safe for healthy individuals for short-term use, it is best to consult a healthcare professional before taking WKBE. This is especially important for those with conditions like diabetes, hypoglycemia, or kidney/liver disease.

WKBE primarily works as a 'starch blocker' by inhibiting carb digestion, unlike supplements that boost metabolism (like green coffee bean extract) or block fat absorption (like Orlistat). Its effect is specifically on carbohydrates, making it different from other types of weight management aids.

The extract is a concentrated form of the active compound (phaseolamin). While eating cooked white kidney beans is healthy due to their fiber and nutrients, the heat from cooking deactivates the alpha-amylase inhibitor, so they do not have the same "starch blocking" effect.

By slowing the digestion and absorption of carbohydrates, WKBE may help reduce post-meal blood sugar spikes. This can be a supportive measure for glycemic control, but it is not a cure for diabetes and should only be used under a doctor's supervision.

No, the research is not conclusive. While some randomized controlled trials show a significant difference in weight loss compared to a placebo, results can be inconsistent, and larger, independent studies are still needed to confirm its long-term efficacy and safety.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.