Why Wine Can Make You Feel So Sick
While the primary cause of any alcohol-related sickness is the ethanol itself, specific components in wine can exacerbate unpleasant effects, leading to a more intense hangover or immediate adverse reactions. It's not just the amount of alcohol consumed but the cocktail of compounds unique to wine that can trigger nausea, headaches, and other digestive issues. This section explores the key culprits behind wine-induced sickness.
The Role of Congeners
Congeners are complex chemical byproducts of the fermentation process that give alcoholic beverages their distinctive flavor and aroma. While present in all fermented drinks, they are found in higher concentrations in darker beverages like red wine, whiskey, and brandy. Experts believe that the body's effort to break down these extra substances alongside the alcohol may contribute to more severe hangovers and a heightened sense of malaise. If you find yourself feeling sicker after red wine than, say, white wine or clear spirits, congeners are a very likely suspect.
Histamines and Sulfites: Triggers for Intolerance
For some individuals, sensitivity to histamines and sulfites is the primary reason wine makes them sick.
- Histamines: A naturally occurring compound found in high levels in red wine, histamine can cause allergy-like reactions in sensitive people. Symptoms include headaches, flushing, itching, and digestive issues. Some people lack sufficient levels of the enzyme diamine oxidase (DAO), which breaks down histamine, leading to its accumulation and these adverse effects.
- Sulfites: Used as a preservative in winemaking, sulfites can trigger asthma-like symptoms, wheezing, and coughing in those with a sensitivity. While often blamed for headaches, this is a misconception for most, with respiratory issues being the more common reaction.
Dehydration and Acetaldehyde Accumulation
Regardless of the type, alcohol acts as a diuretic, causing the body to lose fluids and leading to dehydration. Dehydration is a major contributor to classic hangover symptoms such as thirst, headache, and fatigue. Additionally, when the liver metabolizes ethanol, it produces acetaldehyde, a toxic substance. For some, a genetic variant (especially common in people of Asian descent) means they produce less of the enzyme needed to break down acetaldehyde, leading to a rapid buildup of this toxin and subsequent nausea, flushing, and rapid heartbeat.
The Difference Between Wine Intolerance and Allergy
It's important to understand the distinction between a true wine allergy and a more common intolerance.
- Wine Intolerance: A non-immune system reaction where your digestive system simply struggles to process certain compounds in wine, like sulfites or histamines. Symptoms are generally digestive, like nausea, gas, and abdominal pain, but can also include flushing and headaches.
- Wine Allergy: A much rarer immune system response to a specific ingredient, such as grape proteins, yeast, or clearing agents used in the winemaking process. True allergies can trigger severe symptoms, including hives, swelling, and in rare cases, anaphylaxis.
Comparison of Potential Sickness Factors: Red vs. White Wine
| Factor | Red Wine | White Wine | Potential for Sickness | 
|---|---|---|---|
| Congeners | Higher concentration due to fermentation with grape skins. | Lower concentration, as skins are removed during fermentation. | Higher potential for more intense hangovers. | 
| Histamines | Higher levels naturally present, a key trigger for headaches and other intolerance symptoms. | Lower levels compared to red wine. | Higher risk of histamine-related symptoms like flushing and headaches. | 
| Sulfites | Usually added in lower concentrations than white wines, though still present. | Often has higher sulfite levels to preserve freshness and prevent browning. | White wine may be a greater trigger for sulfite-sensitive individuals. | 
| Tannins | Derived from grape skins, seeds, and stems; can trigger headaches in some. | Found in much lower concentrations, if at all. | A specific trigger for certain individuals sensitive to tannins. | 
| Acetaldehyde | The body's metabolism of ethanol produces this toxic compound in all alcohol. | Same metabolic process applies, though lower congener load may feel less taxing. | Equal potential, but other factors in red wine may amplify the effect. | 
Prevention and Mitigation Strategies
For those who experience sickness from wine, several strategies can help minimize adverse effects:
- Moderation: The most effective way to avoid all alcohol-related sickness is to drink less.
- Hydrate Effectively: Alternate each glass of wine with a full glass of water to combat dehydration.
- Eat Food: Consuming food, especially before and during drinking, slows down alcohol absorption and can lessen stomach irritation.
- Choose Wisely: If red wine is a consistent trigger, consider switching to white wine or clear spirits, which generally contain fewer congeners and histamines.
- Pace Yourself: Limiting consumption to one drink per hour allows your liver more time to process the alcohol and other compounds.
Conclusion
In short, the sensation of feeling sick from wine is not just a myth but a complex reaction influenced by several key compounds. While the ethanol is the core intoxicant, specific compounds like congeners, histamines, and sulfites—particularly in red wine—can trigger more intense hangovers or intolerance symptoms. Factors such as dehydration and genetic variations in alcohol metabolism also play significant roles. The key to mitigating wine-induced sickness lies in understanding your personal sensitivities and practicing moderation and mindful drinking habits. For those with severe or consistent reactions, avoiding wine or consulting a healthcare provider may be the best course of action.
For more information on the causes and symptoms of hangovers, you can visit the Mayo Clinic website.