Is Better Than Bouillon Truly Natural? A Deep Dive
Many consumers turn to Better Than Bouillon for its rich flavor and convenience, often assuming it's a more 'natural' alternative to traditional bouillon cubes. However, a closer look at the ingredient list reveals a more complex picture. While some versions, particularly the organic line, use more recognizable food items, the conventional products incorporate a number of processed elements.
The Breakdown: Conventional vs. Organic
To understand if Better Than Bouillon is all natural, you must differentiate between its product lines. The brand offers standard bases, reduced-sodium versions, and certified organic options. The organic line is the closest one gets to a truly 'natural' product from the brand, but even these contain processed ingredients.
The Conventional Ingredients
Looking at the Roasted Chicken Base, for example, several components immediately stand out:
- Corn Syrup Solids: A form of processed sugar. While derived from corn, it is not a whole food ingredient.
- Hydrolyzed Soy Protein: This is created by breaking down soy protein with chemicals. It serves as a flavor enhancer and contains free glutamates, which are similar to MSG.
- Disodium Inosinate and Disodium Guanylate: These are flavor enhancers often added alongside hydrolyzed soy protein to boost umami flavor. They are not considered 'all-natural' in the context of whole food ingredients.
- Flavoring: A vague term that can refer to any number of processed and manufactured flavor compounds. While not always artificial, it's not a transparent ingredient.
The Organic Ingredients
In contrast, the organic line offers a cleaner label, though still not perfectly 'all natural'. For instance, the Organic Roasted Chicken Base lists the following:
- Organic Chicken Meat and Natural Juices: This is the primary flavor component.
- Salt and Organic Cane Sugar: Standard seasonings.
- Organic Maltodextrin: This is a processed carbohydrate, often used as a thickener or stabilizer. While derived from an organic source, it is still a processed ingredient.
- Natural Flavor: As with the conventional line, this is not a whole food ingredient and is made in a lab from natural sources.
- Organic Spices: This is a more transparent ingredient, indicating recognizable herbs and spices.
Comparison Table: Better Than Bouillon Ingredients
| Ingredient Category | Conventional Roasted Chicken Base | Organic Roasted Chicken Base | Implications for 'Natural' Status | 
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Flavor | Roasted Chicken, Natural Juices | Organic Roasted Chicken, Natural Juices | Organic version guarantees certified organic chicken. | 
| Enhancers | Hydrolyzed Soy Protein, Disodium Inosinate, Disodium Guanylate | Yeast Extract, Natural Flavor | Conventional contains processed chemical enhancers. Organic uses yeast extract and 'natural flavors.' | 
| Sweeteners | Sugar, Corn Syrup Solids | Organic Cane Sugar | Organic uses a more minimally processed sugar source. | 
| Starches/Thickeners | Food Starch | Organic Maltodextrin, Organic Food Starch | Both use processed starches, though the organic version guarantees their organic origin. | 
| Artificial Colors | None specified | None specified | The brand generally does not use artificial colors. | 
The Takeaway for Health-Conscious Cooks
For those seeking an 'all natural' product, Better Than Bouillon is a mixed bag. The presence of processed components like corn syrup solids, hydrolyzed soy protein, and maltodextrin means the conventional versions do not fit a strict definition of 'all natural.' The organic line is a superior choice, as it avoids some of the more overtly processed additives found in the conventional products. However, even the organic options contain ingredients like 'natural flavor' and 'organic maltodextrin,' which are not whole foods. The brand’s claim of '95% certified organic ingredients' for its organic line highlights this distinction.
If your goal is to use only whole, unprocessed foods in your cooking, making your own stock from scratch is the only way to ensure 100% control over the ingredients. However, for a convenient and flavorful substitute, the organic line of Better Than Bouillon is a much better alternative than its conventional counterpart or many other packaged broths. You'll need to carefully read the labels and decide which ingredients you are comfortable with.
Conclusion
Is Better Than Bouillon all natural? No, not by a strict definition of the term, especially the conventional product lines. While the organic versions are significantly cleaner, they still contain some processed components. The brand provides a convenient, flavorful option for those who can't make stock from scratch, but a discerning eye toward the ingredient label is necessary for any cook prioritizing an 'all natural' approach. For the purest results, nothing truly replaces homemade stock.