Is Cayman Jack Margarita Zero Sugar? The Answer You Need

November 21, 2025 •

3 min read

According to official product information, Cayman Jack indeed offers a line of zero sugar margaritas that achieve an authentic flavor without the added sweetening. These beverages are crafted using a combination of zesty lime juice and sweet agave nectar, alongside a special plant-sourced sweetener recipe, to deliver a low-calorie experience. The 'Zero Sugar Margarita' variant provides the classic taste with zero sugar and only 100 calories per 12 oz serving.

Quick Summary

Cayman Jack produces a Zero Sugar Margarita that contains no sugar and 100 calories per 12 oz serving, distinct from its original higher-sugar beverage. It is formulated with agave nectar, lime juice, and a plant-based sweetener to deliver a classic margarita taste without compromising flavor.

Key Points

Zero Sugar Option Exists: Cayman Jack offers a specific 'Zero Sugar Margarita' product line which contains zero grams of sugar.
Not All Margaritas Are Sugar-Free: The company's original margarita contains a significant amount of cane sugar and is not a zero-sugar product.
Uses Plant-Based Sweeteners: The sugar-free version is sweetened with a proprietary plant-based recipe and agave nectar for a natural taste.
Lower Calorie Count: With only 100 calories per 12 oz serving, the zero-sugar option is a low-calorie alternative.
Authentic Flavor Profile: The drink is formulated to provide an authentic margarita taste using lime juice and agave nectar, despite having zero sugar.
Compare Labels Carefully: Consumers must check the product packaging specifically for 'Zero Sugar' to ensure they are buying the low-calorie version.

Is Cayman Jack Margarita Zero Sugar? A Detailed Breakdown

For many health-conscious consumers, knowing the nutritional profile of their favorite drinks is crucial. The question of whether Cayman Jack margarita contains zero sugar is one that arises frequently. The definitive answer is that while the company's flagship original margarita is not zero sugar, Cayman Jack offers a specific product line known as the Zero Sugar Margarita that is, in fact, completely sugar-free.

Understanding Cayman Jack's Different Margarita Products

Cayman Jack's product portfolio includes several ready-to-drink margarita options, and it is important to distinguish between them to understand the sugar content. The original Cayman Jack Margarita, for example, is made with real cane sugar and 100% blue agave nectar. This results in a much higher calorie and sugar count. The Zero Sugar line, however, was specifically developed to cater to consumers seeking a lower-calorie, no-sugar alternative without sacrificing the classic margarita flavor.

The Zero Sugar Formulation: How It's Made

The secret to the Zero Sugar Margarita lies in its innovative recipe. Instead of relying on cane sugar for sweetness, Cayman Jack utilizes a proprietary, plant-based sweetener blend. This is combined with the natural sweetness of 100% blue agave nectar and the tartness of real lime juice to create a well-balanced, authentic-tasting beverage. This careful formulation ensures the drink retains the signature flavor profile that fans love, but with the added benefit of zero sugar.

What to Know About the Ingredients

Here is a list of key ingredients and characteristics of the Cayman Jack Zero Sugar Margarita:

100% Blue Agave Nectar: Contributes a depth of flavor that is characteristic of premium margaritas.
Real Lime Juice: Provides the zesty, tart profile essential for an authentic margarita taste.
Plant-Based Sweetener: The source of the zero-sugar sweetness, avoiding artificial sweetener aftertaste.
Gluten-Removed: The beverage is crafted to remove gluten, making it a viable option for those with gluten sensitivities.
Premium Malt Beverage Base: The alcoholic base is a premium malt beverage, rather than a tequila base.

Nutritional Comparison: Zero Sugar vs. Original

To highlight the significant difference, let's compare the nutritional facts of the Cayman Jack Zero Sugar Margarita with the original version based on a standard 12 oz serving:


Feature	Cayman Jack Zero Sugar Margarita	Cayman Jack Original Margarita
Sugar	0 grams	31-35 grams
Calories	100	~240
Carbohydrates	11 grams	36-38 grams
ABV (Alcohol by Volume)	4.8%	5.8%
Sweetener	Plant-based, plus agave nectar	Real cane sugar, plus agave nectar

Flavor Profile and Consumer Perception

While the goal is to replicate the authentic margarita taste, the flavor profile of the zero sugar version can be perceived differently by consumers. The use of a plant-based sweetener avoids the harsh, chemical aftertaste often associated with artificial sweeteners. However, some reviewers note a slightly different sweetness compared to the sugar-filled original, though many appreciate the lighter, less cloying finish. The overall consensus is that it is a refreshing and flavorful alternative for those seeking a lower-calorie option.

Conclusion: The Verdict on Cayman Jack's Zero Sugar Offering

In conclusion, if you are looking for a Cayman Jack margarita with zero sugar, the specific "Zero Sugar Margarita" and its variety packs are the correct products to choose. It is crucial to read the product label carefully to ensure you are selecting the right variant, as the classic Cayman Jack margarita is not sugar-free. The zero-sugar version provides an authentic-tasting, lower-calorie alternative that successfully replicates the zesty lime and agave flavor without any added sugar, utilizing natural flavors and plant-based sweeteners. For those who enjoy a ready-to-drink cocktail but are mindful of their sugar intake, this product is an excellent option.

For more information on the brand's offerings, you can visit the official Cayman Jack website.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, Cayman Jack offers a product called "Zero Sugar Margarita" which contains zero grams of sugar and is sweetened with a proprietary plant-based recipe and agave nectar.

The main difference is the sugar content; the original Cayman Jack Margarita is made with real cane sugar and agave nectar, while the Zero Sugar version is sweetened using plant-based ingredients for zero grams of sugar and fewer calories.

No, only the specific line of products labeled "Zero Sugar Margarita" or found in the "Zero Sugar Variety Pack" are sugar-free. Other flavors and the original margarita contain sugar.

A 12 oz serving of the Cayman Jack Zero Sugar Margarita contains 100 calories. In contrast, a 12 oz original Cayman Jack can have up to 240 calories.

The zero sugar version is designed to taste authentic with zesty lime and agave notes. Many find the flavor profile to be very similar, although some note it is slightly less sweet than the original, with a clean finish.

The Zero Sugar Margarita has a lower carbohydrate count (11g per 12 oz) compared to the original, making it more suitable for low-carb diets. However, it is not carb-free, so it is important to factor it into your daily intake.

While Cayman Jack's Zero Sugar Margarita is a malt beverage crafted to remove gluten, the company notes that the gluten content cannot be verified and it may still contain trace amounts.