Skip to content

Is Cravendale milk better for you than normal milk? A nutritional diet comparison

4 min read

According to Cravendale's manufacturer, Arla, the company's milk is filtered for purity and stays fresher for longer because more of the bacteria that turn milk sour are removed. This raises a key question for consumers: Is Cravendale milk better for you than normal milk? While the extended shelf life is a major selling point, the core nutritional value remains the central point of comparison for those focused on a balanced diet.

Quick Summary

This article compares Cravendale's filtered milk with standard pasteurised milk, analysing their nutritional content, processing methods, taste, and shelf life. The findings indicate that while Cravendale's filtration offers extended freshness, its basic nutritional profile is virtually identical to that of normal milk, with the primary difference being processing and longevity.

Key Points

  • Nutritionally Similar: Cravendale and normal milk (of the same fat content) provide the same essential vitamins, minerals, and protein.

  • Extended Shelf Life: Cravendale is microfiltered to remove spoilage-causing bacteria, allowing it to last significantly longer than normal pasteurised milk.

  • Different Processing: Cravendale uses an extra ceramic filtration step before pasteurisation, while normal milk relies only on pasteurisation to ensure safety.

  • Taste Preference: The filtration process can create a purer, creamier taste in Cravendale, which some people prefer, while others prefer the taste of standard milk.

  • Cost vs. Convenience: Cravendale is typically more expensive due to its advanced processing, so the choice depends on whether the extended freshness is worth the extra cost to you.

  • Not UHT Milk: Unlike UHT (long-life) milk, Cravendale undergoes less intensive heat treatment, preserving a fresher taste.

  • Informed Choice: To decide which is "better," consider personal budget, taste preference, and the value of longer shelf life, rather than expecting a major nutritional difference.

In This Article

What Exactly is Cravendale Milk?

Cravendale is a brand of fresh milk that undergoes a special microfiltration process before pasteurisation. This unique step uses ceramic filters with extremely small pores to remove naturally occurring impurities and, crucially, a significant portion of the bacteria that cause milk to spoil. The result is milk that stays fresher in your fridge for a longer period compared to standard fresh milk, typically lasting up to three weeks unopened and seven days once opened. The key point is that it is still fresh, pasteurised milk, not ultra-heat-treated (UHT) milk, which is heated to a much higher temperature and has a distinct flavour.

The Cravendale Process Explained

The unique processing of Cravendale milk can be broken down into a few key steps:

  • Source Milk Selection: Cravendale is made from 100% British milk sourced from Arla's farmer-owners who adhere to specific animal welfare standards.
  • Fine Filtration: Before the milk is pasteurised, it is finely filtered through ceramic filters to remove the bacteria that lead to spoilage.
  • Pasteurisation: The filtered milk is then pasteurised, a heat treatment designed to kill any remaining harmful pathogens, just like normal milk.
  • Homogenisation: The milk is homogenised to break down and disperse fat particles evenly, preventing the cream from separating and rising to the top.
  • Bottling and Storage: The finished product is bottled and refrigerated, ready for distribution with its signature extended shelf life.

Nutritional Breakdown: Cravendale vs. Normal Milk

From a nutritional standpoint, the most critical finding is that there is no significant nutritional advantage to be gained from choosing Cravendale over regular pasteurised milk. Both types of milk, assuming they are the same fat content (e.g., whole, semi-skimmed, or skimmed), contain the same essential nutrients.

Key nutrients found in both Cravendale and normal milk include:

  • Calcium: Essential for building and maintaining strong bones and teeth.
  • Protein: Important for muscle repair and growth.
  • Vitamins: Both contain B vitamins, such as B12 and riboflavin (B2), which are important for energy metabolism and nerve function.
  • Minerals: Both provide potassium and iodine, essential for a healthy body.

Some newer, more advanced "ultra-filtered" milk products (different from Cravendale's process) might claim higher protein and calcium content by using a more intensive filtration process. However, Cravendale's process focuses specifically on bacterial removal for longevity, not on concentrating nutrients.

A Closer Look: Cravendale vs. Normal Milk

Feature Cravendale Milk Normal Pasteurised Milk
Processing Microfiltered through ceramic filters before pasteurisation to remove more bacteria. Standard pasteurisation (heating to 71.7°C for 15-20 seconds).
Nutritional Content No significant nutritional difference. Contains the same calcium, protein, and vitamins as normal milk. Offers the same essential nutrients as filtered milk.
Shelf Life (Unopened) Significantly longer; typically up to 3 weeks. Standard shelf life; typically around 5-7 days.
Taste & Purity Described by many as having a purer, fresher, and sometimes creamier taste due to the removal of impurities. Taste is dependent on the cow and farm, and some may find it less 'pure' or slightly 'milky' in flavour.
Cost Often more expensive due to the additional filtration step. Generally more affordable and widely available.
Suitability Ideal for those who use milk intermittently or want to minimise food waste due to its extended shelf life. Perfect for regular, everyday use and those who prioritise cost-effectiveness.

Taste and Texture: The Subjective Difference

While nutritionally similar, many consumers report a subjective difference in taste and texture. Cravendale's filtration process is said to result in a purer, cleaner taste profile, as some of the components that cause off-flavours are removed. This can make it a preferred choice for people who enjoy a milder, creamier-tasting milk, even in lower-fat versions. The opaque bottle also helps to protect the milk from light degradation, which can further preserve its flavour.

Practical Considerations: Shelf Life and Cost

The main practical benefit of Cravendale is its extended shelf life. For small households, individuals, or those who use milk infrequently, the longer-lasting nature of Cravendale can be a major advantage, reducing food waste and saving money in the long run by avoiding having to throw away spoiled milk. However, this convenience comes at a higher price point than most standard supermarket milks.

Making the Right Choice for Your Nutritional Needs

Ultimately, the decision between Cravendale and normal milk comes down to personal priorities. If your primary goal is to maximise nutritional value, either milk is an equally valid choice. For those focused on convenience, longevity, and a specific taste preference, Cravendale's extra cost might be justifiable. If budget is a key concern, normal pasteurised milk offers all the same nutritional benefits at a lower price point. Consider your consumption habits, dietary goals, and budget when deciding which carton to pick up on your next shopping trip. You can learn more about the Cravendale process and their farming initiatives on the Arla UK website.

Conclusion

In summary, from a purely nutritional perspective, Cravendale is not "better for you" than normal milk. Both are excellent sources of essential vitamins and minerals like calcium, potassium, and B vitamins. The key difference lies in the processing: Cravendale's additional ceramic filtration removes more bacteria, giving it a longer shelf life and, according to some, a purer taste. Your personal preference for taste, your budget, and the importance of extended freshness are the main factors to consider when deciding which milk is the right choice for your diet.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, Cravendale is not fortified with extra vitamins beyond what is naturally present. The filtration process primarily removes bacteria, and no additional nutrients are added.

No, Cravendale's protein content is comparable to normal milk of the same fat percentage. The filtering process doesn't concentrate the protein in the milk.

Cravendale lasts longer because it is finely filtered through ceramic filters to remove more of the naturally occurring bacteria that cause milk to turn sour. This process is distinct from UHT treatment and extends the shelf life.

No, Cravendale is not lactose-free. It is made from fresh cow's milk and contains lactose. Arla offers a separate Lactofree product for those with a sensitive stomach.

Cravendale is also pasteurised, but it undergoes an additional microfiltration step before pasteurisation. Normal milk is only pasteurised.

Yes, Cravendale milk can be used for cooking, baking, and in tea or coffee in the same way as normal milk. It offers the same functionality and nutritional properties.

Cravendale is generally more expensive due to its advanced filtration process, not because it offers superior nutritional health benefits. The cost reflects the additional technology and the benefit of extended freshness.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.