Is Great Value Peanut Butter Recalled? Clearing the Confusion

In 2007, a massive Salmonella outbreak traced to ConAgra’s Sylvester, Georgia plant prompted a widespread recall of specific batches of Great Value peanut butter and its sister brand, Peter Pan. Though this event is nearly two decades old, outdated information and rumors still lead consumers to ask: is Great Value peanut butter recalled today?

Quick Summary

There is no current recall for Great Value peanut butter. Past recalls, like the 2007 event, cause confusion, but all recent issues have affected other brands.

Key Points

• No Current Recall: There is no active recall for Great Value brand peanut butter as of 2025.

• Historical Event: The last major recall for Great Value peanut butter was in 2007, caused by a Salmonella outbreak traced to a ConAgra facility.

• Affected Product Code: The 2007 recall specifically impacted jars with product codes beginning with "2111".

• Misinformation Source: Rumors often stem from outdated information or confusion with other, more recent peanut butter recalls involving different brands like Jif.

• Reliable Sources: To verify recall information, always check official sources like the FDA's website or Walmart's corporate recall page.

The 2007 Salmonella Scare: The Historical Great Value Recall

The most significant and often-referenced recall involving Great Value peanut butter occurred in early 2007. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) investigated a Salmonella outbreak affecting hundreds of people across dozens of states. The source was traced back to a specific manufacturing facility operated by ConAgra Foods in Sylvester, Georgia, which produced both Peter Pan and Great Value branded peanut butter.

Which Products Were Affected?

The recall applied to all jars of Peter Pan and Great Value peanut butter with a product code beginning with "2111" on the lid. Consumers were advised to discard any of these products, regardless of their expiration date, with the recall expanding to cover products made as far back as October 2004. The FDA later confirmed that the outbreak strain of Salmonella was present in samples of the recalled peanut butter. This was a serious and well-documented event, which is why the misinformation persists to this day.

No Active Recall for Great Value Peanut Butter in 2025

Despite the historical event, it's important to clarify that there is no current or active recall for Great Value peanut butter. The rumors that circulate online, often shared on social media or in forums like Reddit, are based on outdated information. As of October 2025, there are no alerts from the FDA or Walmart concerning a peanut butter recall under the Great Value brand.

It's easy to get confused, especially when other product recalls are in the news. For instance, recent recalls under the Great Value brand have involved items like chicken broth due to packaging issues (January 2025) and certain bakery items due to potential plastic contamination (November 2024), but not peanut butter.

How to Verify a Product Recall

To avoid misinformation and ensure the safety of your food, always check reliable sources. Here’s a simple checklist:

• Check the FDA Website: The U.S. Food and Drug Administration maintains a searchable database of all food recalls, market withdrawals, and safety alerts. This is the most authoritative source for information regarding recalls in the U.S..
• Visit the Company's Recall Page: Large retailers like Walmart often have a dedicated recall section on their corporate website. For Great Value products, this is a direct way to check for up-to-date alerts.
• Look for Official News Releases: Official announcements from regulatory bodies or the company itself will be carried by reputable news outlets like Reuters or USA Today. Be wary of unverified posts on social media or in online forums.
• Check the Product Itself: Recalls are often specific to certain lot codes or "best by" dates. Always inspect the packaging of your product to see if it matches any identifying information in a recall notice.

Recent Recalls for Other Peanut Butter Brands

To put the Great Value rumors into context, it is helpful to look at other, more recent peanut butter recalls involving different brands. These are distinct events and should not be confused with the 2007 Great Value incident.

• Jif Peanut Butter (May 2022): The J.M. Smucker Co. voluntarily recalled certain Jif brand peanut butter products due to a multi-state Salmonella outbreak linked to its Lexington, Kentucky, facility.
• Skippy Peanut Butter (April 2022): Hormel Foods issued a recall for select Skippy products due to a potential contamination with small metal fragments.
• Coles Peanut Butter (June 2025): In Australia, Coles Supermarkets recalled its house brand peanut butter due to higher-than-regulated levels of aflatoxin.

Comparison: Great Value 2007 vs. Jif 2022 Recalls

Feature	Great Value (2007)	Jif (2022)
Manufacturer	ConAgra Foods	J.M. Smucker Co.
Contaminant	Salmonella	Salmonella
Product Scope	Specific batches beginning with code '2111'	Specific lot codes and 'best by' dates
Affected Location	Nationwide U.S.	Nationwide U.S. and Canada
Plant Location	Sylvester, Georgia	Lexington, Kentucky
Brand	Great Value and Peter Pan	Jif
Source Confirmation	Confirmed by FDA testing	Confirmed by FDA/CDC investigation

Conclusion: Keeping Up with Food Safety

In conclusion, while the query "is Great Value peanut butter recalled" is a legitimate concern rooted in a real, historical event, the answer today is no. The 2007 recall was a significant food safety event, but it was specific to certain batches manufactured almost two decades ago. For current information, it is always best to consult reliable sources such as the official FDA website or Walmart's own recall page. Staying informed is the best way to ensure the safety of the food in your pantry.

To check the most current FDA recalls, visit their official database here.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Great Value peanut butter being recalled right now?

No, there is no current recall for Great Value peanut butter. All recent product safety issues associated with this brand have involved different food items, not peanut butter.

When was Great Value peanut butter last recalled?

Great Value peanut butter was last recalled in 2007 due to a Salmonella outbreak. The recall affected specific jars produced by ConAgra Foods that had a product code beginning with "2111".

What caused the Great Value peanut butter recall in 2007?

The 2007 recall was prompted by a Salmonella outbreak that was epidemiologically linked to peanut butter produced at a ConAgra facility in Sylvester, Georgia.

How can I check for active food recalls?

You can check for active food recalls by visiting the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) website, which maintains a database of recalls and safety alerts.

Was the 2022 Jif recall related to Great Value peanut butter?

No, the 2022 Jif peanut butter recall was a completely separate event involving products manufactured by the J.M. Smucker Company. It was not related to any Great Value products.

Is Walmart currently warning about Great Value peanut butter?

No, Walmart is not currently warning about Great Value peanut butter. You can check Walmart's official product recall page for the latest information on any recalls affecting its products.

What is the difference between a market withdrawal and a recall?

A recall is initiated to remove a product from the market due to a health or safety issue. A market withdrawal is a minor stock issue that is not a health risk, such as a product not meeting company quality standards.