Skip to content

Is Shake Smart good? An honest review of their shakes, bowls, and value

4 min read

Shake Smart, a company started by two college students in 2011, aimed to provide healthy, on-the-go food options for a busy lifestyle. With an average customer rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars on Yelp, most patrons are generally satisfied with their offerings. However, whether it's truly a "good" option for you depends on a variety of factors, including your dietary goals, budget, and personal taste.

Quick Summary

An in-depth analysis of Shake Smart, evaluating the nutritional value, ingredient quality, customization options, and customer reviews to determine if it lives up to its health-focused vision. Includes a comparison to competitors to assess its overall market position and value proposition.

Key Points

  • High in Protein: Most shakes offer over 25 grams of protein, using high-quality whey isolates for muscle recovery and satisfaction.

  • Nutrient-Dense Ingredients: Shake Smart uses real fruits, vegetables, and organic agave, avoiding artificial sugars and purees in its signature items.

  • Customizable Options: You can adjust the sweetness level by choosing half or no agave, catering to specific calorie or sugar intake goals.

  • Vegan and Gluten-Free Choices: The menu includes vegan, lactose-free, and gluten-free options, such as plant protein and modified toppings.

  • Varying Customer Experience: Customer service and product consistency can differ by location, though overall customer satisfaction is generally high.

  • On-the-Go Convenience: With locations primarily on college campuses, it provides a quick, healthy option for busy individuals.

In This Article

Shake Smart's Core Promise: Healthy Convenience

Since its inception, Shake Smart has built its brand on the promise of healthy convenience, particularly for the college-student demographic. The company has expanded beyond its campus roots and now offers a variety of shakes, bowls, and other nutritious grab-and-go items. A key differentiator is their focus on high-protein, nutritionally dense menu items that can serve as a meal replacement or post-workout refuel. Their shakes feature high-quality whey protein isolates and real fruits, while also offering vegan, gluten-free, and lactose-free options to cater to a broader audience.

Diving into the Menu: Shakes, Bowls, and More

Shake Smart's menu goes beyond simple protein shakes to include a wider array of items designed for a health-conscious clientele.

  • Signature Shakes: These are a cornerstone of the brand, offering over 25 grams of protein in flavors like "A Perfect 10" and "Cookies N' Cream." They use natural sweetness from organic agave nectar, with the option to customize the sweetness level.
  • Acai Bowls: Another popular item, these are made with an acai base and topped with various fresh fruits, granola, and peanut butter. Customer reviews are somewhat mixed on consistency, but the quality of ingredients is generally praised.
  • Toasts and Oats: The menu has expanded to include items like avocado toast, overnight oats, and chia seed pudding at some locations, providing more substantial, savory, and fiber-rich options.
  • Cold Brew Coffee: For those needing a caffeine kick, Shake Smart offers shakes infused with cold brew coffee, blending protein and energy.

An Honest Look at the Nutrition and Ingredients

Shake Smart takes pride in its ingredient sourcing and nutritional profile. They emphasize using real fruits and vegetables, high-quality whey isolates, and organic agave nectar for sweetness. This contrasts with many fast-food alternatives that rely on artificial flavors and processed sugars. For example, a "Perfect 10 with Agave" shake offers 32 grams of protein and 45 grams of carbohydrates in a 360-calorie serving, making it a viable option for muscle repair and energy. However, the amount of sugar can still be significant in some flavored shakes, so customizing the agave level is a good strategy for those monitoring sugar intake. The protein powder itself contains whey protein isolates, concentrates, and hydrolysates, along with additives like lecithin and xanthan gum. While they offer customization, it's worth noting that they do not guarantee an allergen-free environment due to shared equipment.

Shake Smart vs. The Competition: A Comparative Table

Feature Shake Smart Jamba Juice Smoothie King Fast-Food Shakes
Primary Focus Protein-heavy, post-workout/meal replacement Fruit-focused, juice and smoothie-centric Customizable, varied blends with supplements High-sugar, dessert-style shakes
Nutritional Value Emphasizes high protein, real fruit, and customization Varies widely; some high-sugar options exist Can be very high-calorie, depends heavily on ingredients Often lacks fiber and protein, high in sugar
Customization Offers adjustments for protein, sweetness (agave), and additions Provides options for boosts and substitutions High degree of customization for blends and supplements Typically minimal to no customization
Typical Ingredients Whey isolates, real fruit, organic agave, whole ingredients Fruits, vegetables, yogurt, juices, sorbet Fruits, juices, various supplements, some sorbet Ice cream, syrups, artificial flavors, whipped cream
Target Audience Health-conscious, students, fitness enthusiasts Casual consumers, families, juice fans Fitness enthusiasts, general public General public, dessert consumers

The Overall Value Proposition

When considering if Shake Smart is "good," it's essential to weigh its strengths and weaknesses. On the plus side, it fills a specific niche by providing convenient, protein-packed options that are generally healthier than most on-campus or fast-food alternatives. The ability to customize sweetness and ingredients is a major benefit for those with specific dietary needs or preferences. The company's expansion into new institutional settings like hospitals and airports also speaks to a recognized value proposition. However, there are some downsides. Prices can be a bit high for a typical student's budget, though some locations accept meal plans. Consistency and customer service can vary by location, as indicated by some online reviews. The acai bowl consistency has also been a point of critique for some customers.

Conclusion: So, is Shake Smart good?

Ultimately, judging whether Shake Smart is "good" depends on your individual needs and expectations. For those seeking a high-protein, nutrient-dense, and customizable meal or snack option, it's a solid choice, especially as an alternative to less healthy fast-food offerings. The convenience factor is undeniable, particularly in its common campus settings. However, budget-conscious consumers and those sensitive to potential ingredient inconsistencies may want to compare it with other options or manage their expectations. By understanding the balance between its high-quality ingredients and potential drawbacks like price and service variability, you can make an informed decision on whether Shake Smart is the right fit for your lifestyle. For more information, you can visit their official website at shakesmart.com.

Frequently Asked Questions

Shake Smart offers many healthy options, including protein-packed shakes made with real fruits and high-quality protein. However, the healthiness depends on your specific order, as some larger or sweeter items can be higher in calories and sugar. Customization options help you manage your intake.

Yes, Shake Smart provides vegan options. They offer plant-based proteins and alternative ingredients to accommodate various dietary needs. They also offer substitutions for granola to ensure gluten-free treats.

Compared to other fast-food alternatives, Shake Smart's pricing can be considered higher, particularly for students on a budget. However, the price often reflects the quality of ingredients and nutritional value. Some locations also accept campus meal plans or loyalty apps.

Yes, customization is a key feature of Shake Smart. You can often adjust the amount of agave (sweetener) and other ingredients to your liking. This is particularly useful for controlling calorie and sugar content.

Customer opinions on the acai bowls are mixed. Some appreciate the high-quality ingredients, while others have noted inconsistencies in the acai base's texture. The quality often depends on the specific location.

This depends on your goal. For a high-protein option, a signature shake like "A Perfect 10" is a popular choice. For something more substantial, the overnight oats or an acai bowl can be a good option, depending on your location's menu.

Shake Smart is generally more focused on high-protein, meal-replacement options with high-quality whey isolates and natural sweeteners. Smoothie King and Jamba Juice offer broader, more customizable menus that can include higher-sugar, fruit-focused blends and various supplements. Shake Smart tends to be targeted more toward the fitness-focused, on-campus crowd.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.