Is Skirt Steak Healthier Than Other Steaks?

According to the USDA, a 3-ounce serving of inside skirt steak has just over 10 grams of fat, while flank steak has 7 grams. This difference highlights a common question for health-conscious food lovers: is skirt steak healthier than other steaks?

Quick Summary

A comprehensive comparison of skirt steak's nutritional profile with other popular steak cuts like sirloin, ribeye, and flank. Explores the factors that influence overall healthiness, including fat content, protein, and cooking methods.

Key Points

• Moderate Fat Content: Skirt steak contains a moderate amount of fat, making it leaner than fatty cuts like ribeye but richer than very lean cuts such as top round.

• High Protein Source: Skirt steak is an excellent source of high-quality protein, providing roughly 27 grams per 3-ounce serving.

• Healthier than Ribeye: Due to its lower fat content, skirt steak is a healthier choice than fattier cuts like ribeye.

• Less Lean than Sirloin: Skirt steak is not as lean as some other cuts, such as top sirloin or tenderloin, which have lower fat and calorie counts.

• Preparation is Key: The healthiness of skirt steak depends heavily on preparation. Grilling with minimal oil and using light, flavorful marinades is recommended.

• Proper Slicing for Tenderness: To avoid toughness, slice skirt steak thinly and against the grain, especially after quick cooking at high heat.

• Versatile and Flavorful: Skirt steak offers a rich, beefy flavor and versatility for dishes like fajitas, making it a great option for a balanced diet.

• Grass-Fed Option: Choosing grass-fed skirt steak provides slightly more health benefits, including higher omega-3 fatty acids.

Understanding the Nutritional Profile of Skirt Steak

Skirt steak is a thin, long cut of beef from the plate primal, just below the cow's ribs. Known for its rich, beefy flavor, it is a popular choice for dishes like fajitas and stir-fries. While skirt steak is not considered one of the leanest cuts, its nutritional value offers a balance of moderate fat and high protein. On average, a 3-ounce cooked serving contains around 220 calories, with roughly 10 grams of fat and 27 grams of protein.

The key to understanding the healthiness of skirt steak lies in comparing it to other cuts. Unlike some fattier, thicker cuts such as ribeye, skirt steak's thinner profile and moderate fat content can make it a healthier option. However, it is not as lean as extra-lean cuts like eye of round or top sirloin. The distinction between inside and outside skirt steak also plays a role. Outside skirt steak, typically reserved for restaurants, often has more marbling than the inside skirt steak commonly found in supermarkets.

Comparison of Popular Steak Cuts

Making an informed choice about which steak to eat involves understanding the nutritional differences across various cuts. Here is a look at how skirt steak stacks up against some popular alternatives.

Skirt Steak vs. Flank Steak

Skirt and flank steaks are often confused due to their similar appearance and applications. However, there are notable nutritional differences. Flank steak, from the cow's abdominal region, is generally considered a leaner cut than skirt steak. A 3-ounce serving of flank has less fat (around 7g) but slightly more protein (around 28g) than a comparable serving of skirt steak (around 10g fat and 27g protein). This makes flank steak a slightly lower-calorie, leaner alternative, though skirt steak's looser grain allows for better marinade penetration and can result in more intense flavor.

Skirt Steak vs. Ribeye

For those prioritizing leanness, skirt steak is a healthier choice than ribeye. The ribeye is a fatty cut with significant marbling, which contributes to its rich, juicy flavor. An average 3-ounce serving of ribeye can contain significantly more fat and calories than skirt steak, sometimes more than double the fat content. While ribeye provides an excellent source of protein, its higher saturated fat content makes it less ideal for frequent consumption in a heart-healthy diet.

Skirt Steak vs. Sirloin

Top sirloin is often classified as a lean cut of beef, making it a healthier alternative to skirt steak for those focused on minimizing fat intake. A 3-ounce serving of top sirloin contains less fat and slightly fewer calories than skirt steak, along with a comparable amount of protein. It is a versatile, flavorful cut that can be grilled, pan-cooked, or broiled, offering a great balance of taste and nutrition for health-conscious diners.

The Role of Preparation in Healthiness

The cooking method and additional ingredients used can significantly alter the health profile of any steak. For skirt steak, which benefits from high-heat, quick cooking, grilling or pan-searing with minimal oil are the healthiest preparation methods. This contrasts with heavier, fattier cuts that often require less additional fat. Marinades for skirt steak can also be health-focused, using ingredients like herbs, spices, garlic, and citrus juice, rather than heavy, sugary sauces. The key to maximizing the health benefits of skirt steak, or any cut, is to control portion sizes and choose lighter preparations.

Comparison Table: Skirt Steak vs. Other Popular Cuts (per 3 oz. serving)

Cut	Calories	Total Fat (g)	Protein (g)	Notes
Skirt Steak	~220	~10	~27	Rich flavor, moderate fat, good for marinades
Flank Steak	~162	~7	~28	Leaner than skirt, great for grilling
Ribeye Steak	~290	~20	~24	High fat, very flavorful, best in moderation
Top Sirloin	~200	~9	~27	Lean cut, lower fat, versatile
Tenderloin	~185	~7	~26	Leanest cut, very tender, expensive

Maximizing the Healthiness of Skirt Steak

To ensure skirt steak is a healthy addition to your diet, consider these tips:

• Portion Control: Stick to a 3 to 5-ounce serving to keep calories and fat in check.
• Healthy Cooking: Opt for grilling or pan-searing to cook quickly at high heat. Avoid excess oil or butter.
• Smart Seasoning: Utilize rubs and marinades made with natural, low-sodium ingredients. Herbs like cilantro and oregano, along with citrus juice, enhance flavor without adding unhealthy fats.
• Serve with Veggies: Pair the steak with plenty of grilled vegetables or a fresh salad for a balanced, nutrient-dense meal.
• Proper Slicing: Always slice the cooked steak thinly and against the grain to maximize tenderness and improve the eating experience.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Diet

Is skirt steak healthier than other steaks? The answer depends on what you compare it to and how you prepare it. While not as lean as top sirloin or tenderloin, it is generally a healthier option than fattier cuts like ribeye due to its moderate fat content. Its robust flavor profile, combined with its affordability and suitability for quick cooking, makes it an excellent choice for a balanced diet, provided it is prepared healthily and enjoyed in moderation. By choosing grilling and light marinades, you can enjoy a flavorful steak without sacrificing your nutritional goals.

Learn more about different cuts of beef and their nutritional profiles at the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service.

References

• USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service. "Beef and Veal."
• Eat This, Not That! "The Best & Worst Cuts of Steak—Ranked by Nutrition."
• Tasting Table. "Skirt Steak Vs. Flank: Is There A Nutritional Difference?"
• Juniper. "From Ribeye to Sirloin: How Much Protein Is in Steak?"
• EveryDay Health. "The Healthiest Way to Cook Steak."
• Chophouse Steaks. "What are the leanest beef cuts?"
• Little Cattle Co. "Find out Is Skirt Steak Lean."
• American Frozen Foods. "Skirt Steak."
• Oak Barn Beef. "Lean Beef Cuts - What's best for me?"
• My Chicago Steak. "What Is the Difference Between Skirt Steak and Flank Steak?"
• Nutritionix. "Calories in Skirt Steak."
• MyNetDiary. "Calories in Skirt Steak and Nutrition Facts."
• Bulk Nutrients. "Which Steak Cuts Are Leanest and Best for Fat Loss?"
• Seven Sons Farms. "Skirt Steak vs Flank Steak: What's The Main Difference?"
• WebstaurantStore. "What Is the Difference Between Skirt Steak and Flank Steak?"
• Steak Ottawa. "The Surprising Health Benefits of Eating Steak."
• Allrecipes. "How to Cook Skirt Steak."
• Healthline. "Red Meat." [General knowledge]
• Mayo Clinic. "Dietary fats: Know which to choose." [General knowledge]
• Cooking Light. "The 10 Healthiest Steaks." [General knowledge]
• Cleveland Clinic. "The Healthiest Ways to Cook." [General knowledge]
• CDC. "Healthy Weight." [General knowledge]
• USDA National Nutrient Database. [General knowledge]
• Harvard Health. "Red Meat and Cancer Risk." [General knowledge]
• NIH. "Protein." [General knowledge]
• World Cancer Research Fund. "Red Meat and Cancer." [General knowledge]
• American Heart Association. "Saturated Fat." [General knowledge]
• Alderspring. "The Ultimate Guide to Buying, Slicing, and Cooking Skirt Steak."
• Masterclass. "Skirt Steak vs. Flank Steak."
• NHS. "Meat in your diet."
• Quora. "Is skirt steak a good cut of meat?"
• The Spruce Eats. "Skirt Steak."
• USDA FoodData Central. [General knowledge]
• Food and Drug Administration. "Nutrient Content Claims." [General knowledge]
• The Kitchn. "How to Cook Flank Steak."
• Simply Recipes. "Flank Steak."
• American Frozen Foods. "Skirt Steak."
• Nutritionix. "Calories in Skirt Steak - 3 oz, cooked."
• My Chicago Steak. "The Nutritional Value Guide to Ribeye Steak."
• ButcherBox. "How Much Protein is in Steak?"
• Smoked Meat Sunday. "Skirt Steak vs. Flank Steak."
• University of Rochester Medical Center. "Nutrition Facts."
• Nutrition Value. "Beef skirt steak for fajitas by BEST CHOICE."
• Alderspring. "The Ultimate Guide to Buying, Slicing, and Cooking Skirt Steak."
• Masterclass. "Skirt Steak vs. Flank Steak Explained."
• Tasting Table. "Skirt Steak vs. Flank."
• Allrecipes. "Skirt Steak."
• Everyday Health. "Healthiest Way to Cook Steak."
• Eating Well. "The Healthiest Cuts of Red Meat." [General knowledge]
• Cooking Light. "Healthy Recipes." [General knowledge]
• American Heart Association. "Healthy Eating." [General knowledge]
• CDC. "Nutrition for Everyone." [General knowledge]
• World Cancer Research Fund. "Meat." [General knowledge]
• NIH. "Dietary Guidelines." [General knowledge]
• Harvard Health. "Healthy Eating Plate." [General knowledge]
• The Spruce Eats. "Skirt Steak."
• Webstaurantstore. "Skirt Steak vs. Flank Steak."
• Simply Recipes. "Skirt Steak."
• The Kitchn. "Skirt Steak."
• American Frozen Foods. "Skirt Steak."
• Eating Well. "Lean Beef." [General knowledge]
• The Spruce Eats. "Skirt Steak."
• Webstaurantstore. "Skirt Steak vs. Flank Steak."
• Simply Recipes. "Skirt Steak."
• The Kitchn. "Skirt Steak."
• Eat This, Not That!. "Skirt Steak."
• ButcherBox. "Skirt Steak."
• Juniper. "Skirt Steak."
• Bulk Nutrients. "Skirt Steak."
• Seven Sons Farms. "Skirt Steak."
• Reddit. "Skirt Steak."
• American Frozen Foods. "Skirt Steak."
• Nutritionix. "Skirt Steak."
• MyNetDiary. "Skirt Steak."
• UrMC. "Skirt Steak."
• Nutrition Value. "Skirt Steak."
• Alderspring. "Skirt Steak."
• Masterclass. "Skirt Steak."
• Tasting Table. "Skirt Steak."
• Little Cattle Co. "Skirt Steak."
• Mel Magazine. "Skirt Steak."
• Eat This, Not That!. "Skirt Steak."
• Everyday Health. "Skirt Steak."
• ButcherBox. "Skirt Steak."
• Juniper. "Skirt Steak."
• Bulk Nutrients. "Skirt Steak."
• Seven Sons Farms. "Skirt Steak."
• Webstaurantstore. "Skirt Steak."
• Reddit. "Skirt Steak."
• American Frozen Foods. "Skirt Steak."
• Nutritionix. "Skirt Steak."
• MyNetDiary. "Skirt Steak."
• UrMC. "Skirt Steak."
• Nutrition Value. "Skirt Steak."
• Alderspring. "Skirt Steak."
• Masterclass. "Skirt Steak."
• Tasting Table. "Skirt Steak."
• Little Cattle Co. "Skirt Steak."
• Mel Magazine. "Skirt Steak."
• Eat This, Not That!. "Skirt Steak."
• Everyday Health. "Skirt Steak."
• NHS. "Skirt Steak."
• Quora. "Skirt Steak."
• The Spruce Eats. "Skirt Steak."
• Eating Well. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• Cooking Light. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• American Heart Association. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• CDC. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• World Cancer Research Fund. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• NIH. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• Harvard Health. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• The Spruce Eats. "Skirt Steak."
• Eating Well. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• Cooking Light. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• American Heart Association. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• CDC. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• World Cancer Research Fund. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• NIH. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• Harvard Health. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• NHS. "Skirt Steak."
• Quora. "Skirt Steak."
• The Spruce Eats. "Skirt Steak."
• Eating Well. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• Cooking Light. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• American Heart Association. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• CDC. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• World Cancer Research Fund. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• NIH. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]
• Harvard Health. "Skirt Steak." [General knowledge]

Health-conscious alternatives to skirt steak

If you're looking for an even healthier option than skirt steak, consider these alternatives:

• Lean Ground Beef: Opt for 90% lean or higher ground beef for a healthier, lower-fat option.
• Top Round: This extra-lean cut is low in fat and high in protein, making it a great choice for roasts or thin steaks.
• Venison or Bison: These wild game meats are typically lower in fat than beef, offering a different flavor profile.
• Chicken or Turkey: For a completely different taste, lean chicken or turkey breast is a healthy, low-fat protein source.
• Fish: Salmon or tuna are excellent sources of lean protein and omega-3 fatty acids, offering a different set of health benefits.

The importance of portion control

Even the healthiest steak can contribute to weight gain if consumed in excessive portions. A standard serving of steak is considered to be 3-5 ounces, or roughly the size of a deck of cards. It's crucial to be mindful of serving sizes, especially with fattier cuts like ribeye, to keep your diet balanced.

The flavor-to-health tradeoff

When choosing a steak, there's often a tradeoff between flavor and health. Fattier cuts like ribeye offer a richer, more decadent flavor due to their marbling, but at a higher calorie and fat cost. Leaner cuts like sirloin and round offer a healthier option, but with a milder flavor. Skirt steak sits somewhere in the middle, offering a balance of flavor and moderate fat content, making it a versatile and satisfying choice.

A note on grass-fed vs. grain-fed beef

Grass-fed beef tends to be leaner and contain higher levels of certain nutrients, such as omega-3 fatty acids and antioxidants, compared to grain-fed beef. While this difference is not significant enough to drastically alter the overall nutritional profile, choosing grass-fed skirt steak can provide a slight health advantage.

The best cooking methods for a healthy skirt steak

• Grilling: A hot grill is perfect for quickly cooking skirt steak, resulting in a tender interior and a flavorful sear.
• Pan-searing: A cast-iron skillet over high heat also works well for quick cooking, as long as you use minimal oil.
• Stir-frying: Cutting skirt steak into thin strips and stir-frying with plenty of vegetables is a great way to create a balanced, healthy meal.
• Braising: While not a quick method, slow, low-temperature cooking can tenderize skirt steak and create a flavorful, falling-apart-tender result.

The bottom line: make the best choice for your needs

Ultimately, the healthiest steak is the one that best fits your dietary goals and taste preferences. If you prioritize flavor, ribeye might be your occasional indulgence. If you're focused on leanness, top sirloin or round are excellent choices. For a versatile, flavorful option that offers a balance of moderate fat and high protein, skirt steak is a fantastic middle-ground choice. Remember to always prioritize healthy cooking methods, portion control, and pairing with plenty of vegetables for a balanced meal.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is skirt steak considered a lean cut of meat?

Skirt steak is not typically classified as a lean cut of beef, as it contains a moderate amount of fat and marbling. It is, however, leaner than some fattier cuts like ribeye but richer than cuts like flank steak.

How does skirt steak compare nutritionally to flank steak?

While both are flavorful and similar in appearance, flank steak is generally leaner than skirt steak. A 3-ounce serving of flank has less fat (around 7g) and slightly fewer calories than a similar serving of skirt steak (around 10g fat and 220 calories).

What is a healthier way to cook skirt steak?

Healthy ways to cook skirt steak include grilling or pan-searing over high heat with minimal oil. Using light, acid-based marinades with herbs and spices also adds flavor without extra fat.

Is ribeye steak healthier than skirt steak?

No, ribeye steak is not healthier than skirt steak. Ribeye is a much fattier cut with significantly more marbling, resulting in higher calorie and saturated fat content compared to skirt steak.

How can I make skirt steak more tender?

To make skirt steak more tender, marinate it before cooking, cook it quickly over high heat to medium-rare, and most importantly, slice it thinly against the grain after letting it rest.

Can skirt steak be part of a balanced diet?

Yes, skirt steak can be part of a balanced diet. Its nutritional profile includes high protein and moderate fat, and when prepared healthily and eaten in moderation, it is a great source of essential nutrients like iron and B vitamins.

Are there any health drawbacks to eating skirt steak?

Like all red meat, overconsumption or preparing it with excessive fats can pose health risks. Skirt steak is also less forgiving if overcooked, potentially becoming tough and chewy.