The Core Difference: Natural vs. Synthetic Hormones
All milk contains natural bovine somatotropin (bST), a growth hormone found in cows. However, some conventional dairy farmers use recombinant bovine somatotropin (rBST), a synthetic version of bST, to increase milk production. This synthetic hormone is the primary concern for many consumers.
The Role of USDA Organic Certification
The USDA organic certification strictly prohibits the use of synthetic growth hormones like rBST/rBGH in dairy cows. This is a fundamental aspect of organic standards, ensuring that organic milk comes from cows not treated with these artificial hormones.
Comparing Hormone Levels in Organic vs. Conventional Milk
Research, such as a 2019 study by Emory University and The Organic Center, indicates that conventional milk has significantly higher levels of bovine growth hormone compared to organic milk. The study suggests these elevated levels in conventional milk are linked to the use of synthetic hormones, while levels in organic milk reflect natural biological processes.
Health and Animal Welfare Considerations
Concerns about rBGH use include potential animal welfare issues, such as increased risk of mastitis in cows, which can lead to higher antibiotic use in conventional farming. Organic farming prohibits antibiotics. While the FDA considers rBGH-treated milk safe for humans as bovine hormones are broken down during digestion, debates persist about the potential impact of increased levels of insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) associated with rBGH use. Organic milk consistently shows lower IGF-1 levels.
Navigating Milk Labels
Labels like "rBST-free" or "No artificial hormones" on conventional milk mean the cows weren't treated with synthetic hormones, but this doesn't equate to organic certification. The USDA organic label guarantees no synthetic hormones, along with other standards like organic feed, pasture access, and no antibiotics. For comprehensive avoidance of synthetic additives, the USDA organic seal is the most reliable indicator. More information can be found on the USDA Organic Program website.
Conventional vs. Organic Dairy: A Comparison
| Feature | Conventional Dairy | Organic Dairy |
|---|---|---|
| Synthetic Growth Hormones (rBGH/rBST) | Permitted by FDA in the U.S.; used by some farms. | Strictly prohibited. |
| Natural Bovine Growth Hormone (bGH) | Present in trace amounts, potentially higher with synthetic hormone use. | Present in trace amounts consistent with natural cycle. |
| Antibiotic Use | Allowed for treatment; milk withheld. | Prohibited; animal loses organic status if treated. |
| Feed | May contain GMOs, pesticides, conventional ingredients. | Must be 100% organic, non-GMO, no synthetic pesticides. |
| Pasture Access | Not required. | Requires year-round outdoor access and grazing. |
Conclusion
While natural growth hormones are present in all milk, certified organic milk is produced without synthetic growth hormones like rBGH or rBST due to USDA standards. Research confirms organic milk has significantly lower total growth hormone levels than conventional milk. Choosing organic milk is a way for consumers to avoid synthetic hormones and support practices aligned with organic standards for animal welfare and production.