Skip to content

Is Usnea Safe to Eat? Understanding the Risks and Cautions

4 min read

Multiple reported cases of severe liver damage and failure have been linked to the oral consumption of supplements containing usnic acid, a compound found in usnea. While a powerful antimicrobial agent, usnea carries significant risks when ingested and is not considered a safe dietary item.

Quick Summary

Despite a history of traditional use, the oral consumption of usnea is linked to severe liver toxicity due to its usnic acid content. This article details the serious risks associated with eating usnea and highlights why external application is a safer alternative.

Key Points

  • Internal Consumption is Dangerous: Usnea, especially when consumed in high doses or concentrated supplements, is linked to severe liver damage and potential liver failure due to its usnic acid content.

  • Topical Use is Safer: External applications like salves and oils are a more traditional and safer way to utilize usnea's antimicrobial properties for skin issues, though allergic reactions are possible.

  • Correct Identification is Crucial: Properly identify usnea by its distinctive white, elastic inner core to avoid mistaking it for toxic look-alikes.

  • Avoid If Pregnant or Have Liver Issues: Pregnant or breastfeeding women, individuals with liver disease, and children should not consume usnea internally.

  • Harvest Sustainably: Collect only fallen usnea from the forest floor, as it is a slow-growing lichen susceptible to over-harvesting.

  • Consult an Expert: Always speak with a healthcare provider or qualified herbalist before attempting any internal use of usnea to understand the risks involved.

  • Test Before Applying: Perform a patch test before applying any usnea preparation to the skin to ensure you do not have an allergic reaction.

In This Article

What is Usnea?

Usnea, commonly known as 'Old Man's Beard' or 'beard lichen,' is a complex organism that exists as a symbiotic relationship between a fungus and an alga. It is a fruticose lichen, meaning it has a bushy or hair-like structure that hangs from tree branches. Unlike parasitic plants, usnea does not take nutrients from its host tree; it simply uses the tree for support. Usnea is also a bioindicator of air quality, as it is highly sensitive to pollution and thrives only in clean environments.

Historically, various species of usnea have been used in traditional medicine across different cultures for their antimicrobial and wound-healing properties. The main bioactive compound responsible for its medicinal effects is usnic acid.

The Key Component: Usnic Acid

Usnic acid is a potent compound found in usnea that gives it its powerful antimicrobial and antifungal properties. In traditional remedies, this compound was primarily used topically to treat wounds, cuts, and fungal infections. It was also used in tinctures or teas for internal issues, but historical dosages were likely far lower and less concentrated than modern supplements.

The Liver Toxicity Concern

The primary reason usnea is not considered safe to eat is the risk of liver damage from usnic acid, especially when consumed in high concentrations. A wave of severe liver toxicity cases, including liver failure and death, were reported in the early 2000s, linked to weight-loss supplements containing usnic acid, such as LipoKinetix. While it's unclear if usnic acid was the sole cause, its hepatotoxicity was a significant factor. The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) subsequently issued a warning about the supplement.

Animal studies also confirm the liver-toxic effects of usnic acid in high doses. The mechanism of injury is thought to involve mitochondrial uncoupling, which disrupts cellular energy production in the liver. This evidence, combined with human cases, makes a strong case against the internal consumption of usnea, particularly in concentrated forms like supplements, teas, or tinctures without expert guidance.

Internal vs. External Use: A Safety Comparison

To highlight the difference in risk, here is a comparison between consuming usnea orally and applying it topically.

Feature Oral (Eating/Ingesting) Topical (Skin Application)
Primary Risk Severe liver damage, liver failure, stomach upset. Allergic reactions, contact dermatitis.
Associated Compound Usnic acid, which is highly concentrated in supplements. Less potent, usnic acid absorbed is minimal.
Traditional Context Used internally, but typically in less concentrated forms (teas, weak tinctures) and often during famine. Widely used for wound dressings, poultices, and salves.
Modern Safety Status Considered "possibly unsafe" and not recommended by health authorities. Considered "possibly safe" for most people, with risk of allergic reaction.
Recommendation Avoid internal consumption completely unless under medical supervision. Use with caution; perform a patch test to check for allergic reactions.

Safe Usage Practices and Identification

Given the significant risks, internal use of usnea is not advised for the average person. However, topical use, rooted in centuries of traditional practice, is a safer alternative for external issues. For any medicinal application, it is critical to consult a healthcare provider or a qualified herbalist.

The Importance of Correct Identification

Before any use, whether internal or external, correct identification is paramount. Misidentifying usnea could lead to serious health issues, as some lichens are toxic. A key identifier for usnea is its elastic white inner core. To test this, gently pull the outer grey-green sheath of a strand. If you see a white, string-like core inside, it is usnea. Avoid any lichen with a black core (like Spanish moss) or yellow parts, which may contain toxic vulpinic acid.

How to Safely Prepare and Apply Usnea Externally

For external use, consider making a salve or an infused oil. It's much safer than taking it internally and can leverage its antimicrobial properties for skin health. Here are some steps:

  • Harvest Sustainably: Collect only usnea that has naturally fallen from trees onto the forest floor, as it grows very slowly. This prevents over-harvesting and protects the ecosystem.
  • Clean and Prepare: Gently rinse the collected usnea in clean water to remove any debris. Air-dry the lichen completely before use or storage.
  • Make an Infused Oil: Finely chop the dried usnea and place it in a glass jar. Cover with a carrier oil like olive or sunflower oil. Infuse the oil over low heat for several hours or let it macerate for weeks in a warm, dark place.
  • Create a Salve: Once the oil is infused, strain out the lichen. Gently melt beeswax into the oil until it reaches the desired consistency. Pour into tins and allow to cool.
  • Patch Test: Always perform a patch test on a small area of skin before widespread application to check for allergic reactions.

Who Should Avoid Usnea?

For safety, certain groups should avoid using usnea in any form, particularly internally. This includes:

  • Pregnant and breastfeeding women due to a lack of safety research.
  • Individuals with pre-existing liver conditions or compromised liver function.
  • Anyone on medication, as usnea can potentially interact with other drugs.
  • Those with known allergies to lichens or fungi.
  • Children, as safety information is limited.

Conclusion

While usnea holds a place in traditional herbalism for its antimicrobial properties, particularly for external use, modern research has revealed significant safety concerns regarding its internal consumption. The risk of severe liver damage, often linked to concentrated usnic acid in oral supplements, makes eating usnea highly inadvisable for most people. The safest and most traditional use of usnea is for topical applications like salves and tinctures to treat skin issues, provided a patch test is performed first. When foraging for usnea, sustainable practices and correct identification are crucial. Always consult a healthcare professional before considering any internal use of usnea to understand the potentially life-threatening risks involved. For further information on the toxic effects of usnic acid, consult the resources available on the LiverTox website.

Frequently Asked Questions

Usnea is considered potentially unsafe to eat, especially in concentrated forms, due to its usnic acid content. In high doses, usnic acid has been linked to severe liver damage, liver failure, and death.

Yes, you can. The traditional and safer way to benefit from usnea's antimicrobial properties is through topical application, such as in salves, infused oils, or tinctures applied to skin, cuts, or wounds.

Usnic acid is a naturally occurring compound in usnea with strong antimicrobial and antifungal effects. When ingested orally in high concentrations, it can be toxic to the liver and has been associated with hepatotoxicity.

To identify usnea, look for a hair-like, greyish-green lichen hanging from trees. Gently pull the strand apart to reveal a characteristic white, elastic inner core. If the core is black or absent, it is not usnea.

While some historical accounts mention usnea being used as famine food, it was typically prepared to reduce bitterness, and safety risks were likely not understood. All usnea species contain usnic acid, and internal consumption is now known to carry significant risks.

Using usnea internally via teas or tinctures is not recommended without expert medical advice. While traditional practices exist, the risk of liver damage from usnic acid, especially at unknown or high dosages, is too great.

External application of usnea is considered much safer than internal consumption. However, some individuals may experience an allergic reaction, such as contact dermatitis. It is wise to perform a patch test first.

Usnea grows very slowly, sometimes less than a millimeter per decade. To prevent over-harvesting and protect this important part of the forest ecosystem, it's recommended to collect only the pieces that have naturally fallen to the ground.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.