Skip to content

Understanding the Claims: Why do men take breast milk?

4 min read

According to a 2015 study in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, researchers identified a growing trend of breast milk consumption among adults, sold on unregulated online marketplaces. This unusual practice prompts a question for many: Why do men take breast milk? This article will explore the claims, the reality, and the significant risks associated with this trend.

Quick Summary

This article examines the reasons why some men consume breast milk, often based on unsubstantiated health claims related to muscle growth and immunity. It clarifies that breast milk is nutritionally optimized for infants, not adults, and poses substantial health risks, especially when sourced unsafely online. The content highlights the false promises and encourages safer, evidence-based nutrition strategies.

Key Points

  • Unproven Health Claims: There is no scientific evidence to support the claims that breast milk offers superior nutritional benefits, such as muscle growth, for adult men.

  • High Health Risks: Obtaining breast milk from unregulated online sources carries a high risk of contracting infectious diseases, including HIV, hepatitis, and syphilis.

  • Bacterial Contamination: Numerous studies have found that breast milk sold online is frequently contaminated with harmful bacteria, including E. coli and Salmonella, due to improper handling and storage.

  • Nutritional Inefficiency: Breast milk has a lower protein content than cow's milk and is not optimized for adult dietary needs, making it an ineffective choice for bodybuilding compared to standard protein sources.

  • Sourcing is Dangerous: The FDA and other health experts strongly advise against purchasing breast milk online due to the unknown health status of the donor and the lack of pasteurization.

  • Underlying Motivations: Reasons for consumption range from misguided health beliefs and curiosity to sexual intimacy, highlighting the various factors behind this trend.

In This Article

The Unfounded 'Superfood' Myth

The idea that human breast milk is a 'superfood' for adult men, offering unique benefits for muscle growth or immunity, is a misconception not supported by scientific evidence. This notion often originates from online forums and anecdotal reports rather than clinical research. While breast milk is perfectly formulated for the rapid growth of human infants, the nutritional needs of a fully-grown adult are vastly different.

Comparing Nutritional Profiles

When examining the nutritional content, it becomes clear that breast milk is not the protein powerhouse some believe it to be. For muscle building, a man needs a much higher concentration of protein than what breast milk provides. The protein composition is different and less abundant than in other readily available milk sources, such as cow's milk.

The Placebo Effect

For some individuals who experience perceived benefits, it is likely a placebo effect. The psychological belief that they are consuming a 'miracle' supplement can lead them to feel better or push harder in their workouts. In reality, the 'gains' are attributable to their own training and discipline, not the breast milk itself.

The Serious Dangers of Unregulated Sources

The most significant risk of this trend comes from how the breast milk is acquired. Adult consumers are ineligible for safe, regulated milk banks intended for at-risk infants. This forces men to turn to online marketplaces, where sellers are not screened and the product's safety cannot be guaranteed. The potential health hazards are severe and far outweigh any unsubstantiated benefits.

Risk of Contamination and Disease Transmission

Breast milk is a bodily fluid and can carry infectious diseases. When obtained from an unknown donor, there is a risk of contracting serious illnesses.

  • Infectious diseases: Pathogens such as HIV, hepatitis B and C, and syphilis can all be transmitted through breast milk. Many of these can be present without the donor being aware, making the risk impossible to assess without screening.
  • Bacterial contamination: Studies on breast milk bought online have found a high percentage of samples are contaminated with bacteria, including harmful Gram-negative bacteria that can cause respiratory and digestive problems. This contamination often results from improper hygiene during expression, storage, and transport.
  • Adulteration: To increase volume and profit, some online sellers have been found to mix human breast milk with cow's milk or even infant formula. For adults with allergies or intolerances, this poses a risk.

Other Contaminants

Beyond infectious agents, the milk can be contaminated with various other substances. The donor's diet, medications, or use of recreational drugs can all affect the milk's contents and pose a risk to the consumer.

Table: Human Breast Milk vs. Cow's Milk (for adult nutrition)

Feature Human Breast Milk (Adult Consumption) Cow's Milk (Adult Consumption)
Nutritional Purpose Optimized for infant growth; not designed for adult needs. Readily digestible source of protein, calcium, and vitamins for adults.
Protein Content Lower protein concentration (approx. 0.8-0.9%). Higher protein concentration (approx. 3.4%).
Immune Benefits While containing antibodies for infants, adult benefits are unproven and primarily placebo. None beyond general nutritional support; not a source of human-specific antibodies.
Risk Profile High risk if from unregulated source due to infectious diseases, bacteria, and adulteration. Low risk when pasteurized and from regulated sources; standard food safety measures apply.
Sourcing Dangerous and illegal to buy from un-vetted online sources. Safe, regulated, and widely available from grocery stores.

The Real Reasons Men Consider Breast Milk

While the health claims are unsubstantiated, the motivations behind the practice vary. They can include curiosity about the taste, a desire for intimacy with a lactating partner, or fetishism. A small subset of cases may even relate to induced lactation in males, though this is rare and linked to specific medical conditions. It is important to distinguish these personal and intimate choices from the broader, risky trend of purchasing breast milk online for supposed health benefits.

Conclusion: Prioritizing Evidence-Based Nutrition

Ultimately, the practice of adult men consuming breast milk is a dangerous and misguided health trend. Claims of superior nutritional benefits for adults, particularly in the realm of bodybuilding, are not supported by science. The severe health risks associated with purchasing breast milk from unregulated online sources—including infectious diseases and bacterial contamination—far outweigh any perceived rewards. For safe and effective nutrition, men should rely on balanced diets with conventional protein sources and consult with healthcare professionals. For those intrigued by the topic due to intimate reasons with a partner, it is important to be aware of the safety considerations and potential disease transmission. Health professionals and regulators continue to warn against purchasing breast milk online, emphasizing the importance of leaving this unique nutrient source for the infants it was designed to nourish.

For more information on the risks of obtaining human milk from non-bank sources, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration provides helpful guidance on their website.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, there is no solid scientific evidence to prove that breast milk helps adult men build muscle. The nutritional composition is optimized for infants, and it has a lower protein concentration than other common milk sources.

The health risks are significant and include exposure to infectious diseases like HIV, hepatitis, and syphilis. Additionally, the milk can be contaminated with harmful bacteria due to improper handling and storage.

No, online marketplaces for breast milk are not regulated and pose serious health risks. Health officials strongly warn against buying or selling human milk on these platforms because sellers are not properly screened for diseases.

This belief is based on a flawed assumption that because breast milk provides immune benefits to infants, it will do the same for adults. Any perceived immune boost is likely a placebo effect, as there is no clinical data to support this claim for adults.

While generally considered safe between mutually-consenting partners with a known health history, there is still a risk of transmitting certain infectious diseases through breast milk. It's important to discuss any potential risks with a healthcare provider beforehand.

No, regulated human milk banks primarily screen and provide pasteurized breast milk for infants in critical medical need, not for adult consumption.

Safer alternatives include a balanced diet rich in protein, a doctor-approved supplement regimen, and conventional protein sources like whey or plant-based proteins. Always consult a healthcare provider for personalized nutrition advice.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.