The Core Rules of the Experiment
For his 2004 documentary, Morgan Spurlock set forth a clear, if highly restrictive, set of rules for his 30-day fast-food diet. These guidelines were the foundation of his self-experimentation and dictated every aspect of his eating habits during the filming process. By adhering to these parameters, Spurlock aimed to provide a controlled—though widely criticized—case study on the impact of exclusive fast-food consumption on the human body.
Exclusive McDonald's Diet
The most fundamental rule was that Spurlock could only eat and drink items available on the McDonald's menu for 30 consecutive days. This meant no outside food, no supplements, and no other beverages except for bottled water sold at McDonald's. This restriction ensured that the results would be directly linked to the fast-food chain's offerings. He also had to eat three full meals a day: breakfast, lunch, and dinner, every single day.
The 'Super Size' Obligation
Spurlock's most publicized rule was his obligation to 'Super Size' his meal whenever the option was explicitly offered by a cashier. He was not allowed to request the larger portion size himself, removing his personal bias from the upselling process. This rule directly highlighted the industry's role in promoting excessive consumption. Over the course of the experiment, he was prompted to 'Super Size' his meal nine times.
Mandatory Menu Consumption
To ensure he experienced the full range of McDonald's products, Spurlock mandated that he must eat every single item on the menu at least once during the 30-day period. This included everything from burgers and fries to salads and desserts. He managed to complete this requirement within the first nine days of the experiment.
Limited Physical Activity
Spurlock also set a guideline for his physical activity level to reflect that of an average American. He aimed for roughly 5,000 steps per day, though he admitted in the film to sometimes walking more, particularly when filming in New York City. This was an important parameter to control for the impact of exercise on weight gain and health. He did not engage in any intentional exercise routines during the experiment.
Medical Supervision
Throughout the month, Spurlock's health was monitored by a team of medical professionals, including a cardiologist, a gastroenterologist, and a general practitioner. These doctors performed regular check-ups to track the changes to his health, which included his blood pressure, cholesterol levels, and liver function.
Spurlock's Experiment vs. Typical Dietary Recommendations
| Aspect | Spurlock's Experiment Guideline | Typical Healthy Dietary Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| Food Source | Exclusively McDonald's menu items, including water. | A balanced variety of whole foods, including fruits, vegetables, lean proteins, and whole grains. |
| Meal Frequency | Three full meals per day, every day. | Consistent meals, but with flexibility for individual needs; mindful eating promoted. |
| Portion Control | 'Super Size' whenever offered, regardless of appetite. | Moderation and portion control based on caloric and nutritional needs. |
| Menu Variety | Must try every item at least once. | Variety encouraged across all food groups for balanced nutrients. |
| Beverages | Only McDonald's drinks, primarily high-sugar soda. | Plenty of water and low-sugar drinks. |
| Physical Activity | Limited to approximately 5,000 steps per day. | At least 30 minutes of moderate exercise most days of the week. |
| Medical Oversight | Regular monitoring for health impacts. | Periodic check-ups as part of routine preventative care. |
The Outcome of the Super Size Me Experiment
Following these guidelines, Spurlock's health deteriorated significantly over the 30 days. He experienced a dramatic increase in his weight, cholesterol, and body fat. He also suffered from mood swings, lethargy, and a decrease in libido, with doctors noting concerning signs of liver damage. The experiment served as a powerful, if unscientific, statement on the potential dangers of a high-fat, high-sugar, and low-nutrition diet. The documentary's end notes revealed that it took him a full fourteen months to lose the weight he had gained and return to his pre-experiment health metrics.
Controversies and Criticisms
While 'Super Size Me' was a popular and influential film, it has faced considerable criticism regarding its methodology. Critics pointed out that the experiment was a sensationalized performance rather than a scientifically rigorous study. The lack of a control group and the extreme nature of the diet were seen as significant flaws. Furthermore, Spurlock's decision not to release a full log of his daily food intake made it impossible for the results to be peer-reviewed or replicated. Some have argued that the rapid weight gain was due more to sheer overindulgence—consuming around 5,000 calories per day—than the inherent nature of fast food itself, especially when eaten in moderation. Despite the criticism, the film successfully initiated public conversations about fast-food marketing and nutrition.
Conclusion
By following a specific, rigid set of guidelines, Morgan Spurlock created a powerful cinematic narrative about the effects of an exclusive fast-food diet. His experiment was not designed as a clinical trial but as a shocking illustration of potential health risks, primarily driven by rules concerning diet exclusivity, forced super-sizing, and suppressed physical activity. These parameters, while controversial, served their purpose in generating dialogue about corporate influence and personal health choices. The documentary's impact was evident in McDonald's subsequent removal of the 'Super Size' option and its increased focus on healthier menu items. Ultimately, Spurlock's guidelines, and the experiment that resulted, provided a memorable warning about the dangers of excessive fast-food consumption.
Visit Study.com for more detailed lessons on the Super Size Me experiment.
