The Fundamental Myth: Why Plants Don't Produce Vitamin B12
Contrary to a common misconception, plants do not synthesize vitamin B12. This essential nutrient is created exclusively by microorganisms, such as bacteria and archaea. Animals, particularly herbivores, acquire B12 by ingesting these bacteria from soil and grass or from bacteria within their own digestive systems. This is why animal products have traditionally been the primary dietary source for humans. While claims about certain herbs or plants containing B12 persist, scientific consensus confirms these are not reliable sources.
The Role of Microbes in Plant-Based B12
Some plant-based foods appear to contain B12, but this is always the result of a symbiotic relationship with bacteria or contamination. For example, certain algae like Chlorella and purple laver (nori) contain B12 because they have associated B12-producing microbes. Similarly, some fermented products like tempeh may contain B12 due to bacterial activity during fermentation, but the levels are inconsistent and unreliable. Modern hygiene and food processing further reduce the chances of acquiring B12 through accidental microbial consumption from fresh produce.
Unreliable Plant-Derived Sources Often Cited
Several sources are frequently cited for plant-based B12, but their effectiveness is limited or unproven.
- Shiitake Mushrooms: Dried shiitake mushrooms contain a type of B12, but the amount is highly variable and often low. Relying on them alone to meet daily needs would require consuming large, impractical quantities.
- Algae (Nori, Spirulina): Dried purple laver (nori), used for sushi, contains a substantial amount of B12 from bacteria. However, some algae, including spirulina, contain inactive B12 analogues that can interfere with the absorption of true B12 and worsen a deficiency. For this reason, nori is not considered a sole reliable source.
- Fermented Foods: Certain fermented products like tempeh can contain some B12 due to contamination during production, but this is not guaranteed. Commercially produced fermented foods, especially in Western countries, should not be relied upon for consistent B12 levels.
Reliable Vegan Sources: Fortification and Supplements
For those on a plant-based diet, the only dependable sources of B12 are fortified foods and dietary supplements. This is the recommendation of major health organizations like the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. Fortified products ensure a consistent and bioavailable supply of the vitamin.
Comparison of B12 Sources
| Source | Type of B12 | Bioavailability | Reliability for Vegans | Daily Intake Requirements | 
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Animal Products | Naturally Occurring (Methylcobalamin, Adenosylcobalamin) | High | Not for Vegans | Met through consumption of meat, dairy, eggs | 
| Fortified Foods (Yeast, Cereals) | Cyanocobalamin | High and Consistent | High | Check food labels; one tablespoon of fortified nutritional yeast provides 100% DV | 
| Supplements | Cyanocobalamin or Methylcobalamin | High and Consistent | High | Dosage depends on factors like age and diet; consult a professional | 
| Fermented Foods (Tempeh) | Inconsistent/Bacterial Contamination | Variable | Very Low | Unreliable for meeting daily needs | 
| Algae (Nori, Chlorella) | Can be active, but variable | Variable | Low | Nori has active B12, but levels fluctuate significantly; Chlorella shows potential but needs more study | 
The Risks of Inactive B12 Analogues
An often-overlooked danger of relying on certain purported plant sources like spirulina is the presence of inactive B12 analogues, sometimes called pseudovitamin B12. These compounds are structurally similar to true B12 but are not biologically active in humans. Worse, they can interfere with the body's absorption and use of the active form of B12, effectively making a deficiency more severe. This is a key reason why experts advise against relying on untested natural sources.
Conclusion: How to Get Enough Vitamin B12
The notion of a herb being high in vitamin B12 is a popular myth that science and nutrition research have consistently debunked. For those following a plant-based diet, relying on any herb for a natural and reliable source of B12 is an unwise nutritional strategy. Instead, the most effective and safe approach is to consume B12-fortified foods, such as nutritional yeast, plant-based milks, and breakfast cereals. Dietary supplements are also a highly effective and reliable option. Individuals should consult with a healthcare professional or registered dietitian to ensure they are meeting their specific B12 requirements, especially since deficiency can lead to serious neurological issues. A well-planned plant-based diet is nutritionally adequate, but it must include a proven, reliable source of this vital nutrient.