Demystifying the Term "Chinese Spinach"
The phrase "Chinese spinach" can be confusing because it doesn't refer to a single type of vegetable, but rather a group of different leafy greens used in Chinese and other Asian cuisines. The most common varieties are amaranth and water spinach, but other greens can also be included. True spinach (Spinacia oleracea) is actually a different plant entirely, though its leaves share a similar appearance and can be used in similar ways. Understanding the key characteristics of each variety will help you choose the right one for your recipe.
The Two Main Contenders: Amaranth and Water Spinach
Amaranth Greens (Yin Choy / Xian Cai)
Amaranth greens are a group of species within the Amaranthus genus, often sold as "Chinese spinach". They are a warm-weather crop, thriving in heat and humidity, which makes them a staple in many tropical and subtropical cuisines. The leaves can be solid green or a striking mix of green and maroon/red. In Chinese markets, you might see them labeled by their Cantonese name, Yin Choy (苋菜), or Mandarin name, Xian Cai. Amaranth leaves have a mild, earthy, and nutty flavor that some describe as slightly sweet. The texture becomes tender and meaty when cooked, and the red varieties are known to release a vibrant, colorful pigment into cooking liquids. Nutritionally, they are superior to traditional spinach in protein, calcium, and iron content.
Water Spinach (Ong Choy / Kangkong)
Water spinach (Ipomoea aquatica) is a semi-aquatic vegetable with long, hollow stems and long, arrow-shaped leaves. It is known by many names across Southeast Asia, including Ong Choy in Cantonese, Kangkong in Malaysia and the Philippines, and Kongxincai (translating to "hollow-heart vegetable") in Mandarin. The leaves have a mild, slightly sweet flavor, while the hollow stems offer a crisp, juicy texture. Its ability to absorb flavors from sauces makes it a popular choice for stir-fries. In the United States, water spinach is sometimes classified as a noxious weed and regulated in certain states due to its aggressive growth habits.
How to Distinguish Between Amaranth and Water Spinach
While both are nutritious leafy greens, telling amaranth and water spinach apart is straightforward if you know what to look for. The simplest visual cue is the stem: amaranth has solid stems, while water spinach has characteristic hollow stems. Amaranth leaves are typically broader and can be variegated, whereas water spinach leaves are narrower and have a consistent green color.
| Feature | Amaranth Greens (Yin Choy) | Water Spinach (Ong Choy) | 
|---|---|---|
| Botanical Name | Amaranthus dubius and other species | Ipomoea aquatica | 
| Stem | Solid and tender | Hollow and crisp | 
| Leaf Shape | Oval to lanceolate, can be solid or variegated red/green | Narrow and elongated or arrow-shaped | 
| Flavor | Mild, earthy, and nutty | Mild and slightly sweet | 
| Cooking Liquid | Red varieties will bleed color into the water | No significant color change in liquid | 
| Growth Habit | Upright plant, grows in soil | Semi-aquatic, grows in water or damp soil | 
Other Greens Sometimes Labeled "Chinese Spinach"
- Malabar Spinach (Basella alba): A vine-like green that is not a true spinach but sometimes called "vine spinach" or "royal palace vegetable." When cooked, it develops a slightly slimy texture, similar to okra.
- Ceylon Spinach (Talinum triangulare): Another succulent green with a mild flavor, also known as waterleaf or cariru. It is used in soups and stews in some regional cuisines.
Culinary Uses and Preparation
Both amaranth and water spinach are highly versatile and typically cooked rather than eaten raw, though young leaves can be added to salads. A common method for both is a quick stir-fry with garlic and seasonings.
How to cook Amaranth Greens
- Stir-fry: Sauté with minced garlic until the leaves wilt. You can use oil and a bit of soy sauce or oyster sauce.
- Soup: Add to clear broths or soups, especially the red varieties, which will add a beautiful color to the liquid.
- Curry: In South Indian cuisine, it is used to make a dish called keerai masiyal, a seasoned puree.
How to cook Water Spinach
- Stir-fry (the classic method): A very popular preparation, often called kangkong belacan, involves stir-frying with garlic, chilies, and shrimp paste.
- Blanching: Quickly blanching the greens and serving with a dipping sauce preserves their crisp texture.
- Soup: The stems and leaves can be added to soups, providing a unique texture.
- Sautéing: Simply sauté with garlic and oil for a quick and easy side dish, a method perfected in many home kitchens.
Conclusion: Navigating the "Chinese Spinach" Market
When buying "Chinese spinach," it's essential to look beyond the generic label and identify whether you are purchasing amaranth greens or water spinach based on their appearance, particularly the stems. Amaranth greens offer a soft, earthy texture, while water spinach provides a crisper, hollow-stemmed experience. Both are healthy, delicious, and fundamental to a wide range of Asian dishes. Understanding their specific characteristics ensures you pick the perfect ingredient for your next culinary adventure. For more information on amaranth varieties, a specialty produce site can be a useful resource.