The seemingly simple question, "What is it called when you eat at 5pm?" reveals a complex tapestry of historical shifts, geographical variations, and social conventions. While for many, this early evening meal might be simply called 'dinner', for others it's unequivocally 'supper' or even 'tea'. Exploring these terms and their origins provides a fascinating glimpse into how our dining rituals have evolved.
Dinner vs. Supper: A Tale of Two Meals
The terms 'dinner' and 'supper' are often used interchangeably today for the main evening meal, but they have distinct historical roots. 'Dinner' comes from the Old French disner, meaning to 'break one's fast', and traditionally referred to the main meal of the day eaten at midday. Over time, particularly with the Industrial Revolution, the main meal shifted to the evening. 'Supper', from the Old French souper, originally meant a lighter evening meal.
Regional and Class-Based Variations
The distinction between 'dinner' and 'supper' often reflects regional and historical class differences. In parts of the American South and Midwest, 'dinner' traditionally meant the main midday meal, and 'supper' was the lighter evening meal. In the UK, 'tea' is a common term for the early evening meal, especially among the working class. These distinctions are less rigid now due to mobility and cultural blending.
The Role of Formality
The formality of the meal can also influence its name. 'Supper' is often associated with a casual, lighter meal, while 'dinner' can imply a more formal or substantial one. This can help differentiate the terms regardless of the time of day.
Is 5pm Dinner, Supper, or Something Else Entirely?
A 5pm meal falls in a transitional zone where definitions overlap. It can be called 'dinner' as an early evening meal. Alternatively, if a larger meal was eaten at midday, the 5pm meal might be a lighter 'supper'. In the UK, it could be called 'tea'. The name often depends on the meal's context, size, and purpose.
Common Meal Names and Their Timings
Here is a simple comparison of traditional meal names and their associated timings, showing how historical practice and regional variations play a role.
| Meal Name | Traditional Timing (Broadly) | Notes on Usage |
|---|---|---|
| Breakfast | Early morning, 6-9am | Universal term for breaking the night's fast. |
| Lunch | Midday, 12-1pm | Midday meal, shortened from 'luncheon'. |
| Dinner (Traditional) | Midday | Historically the main meal, shifted later with industrialization. |
| Dinner (Modern) | Evening, 6-9pm | Today's most common term for the main evening meal. |
| Supper | Late evening (Historically) | A light, late-night snack before bed. |
| Supper (Modern) | Evening, 5-7pm | Can refer to a lighter, informal evening meal. |
| Tea (UK) | Afternoon (light snack) or Evening (cooked meal) | Can be a snack at 4pm or a cooked dinner at 6pm. |
| Elevenses (UK) | Mid-morning, 11am | A light snack, typically tea and a biscuit. |
Why Does It Matter?
Understanding these distinctions offers insights into different lifestyles and cultural heritages. The evolution of meal names reflects social and economic changes. Recognizing these variations helps appreciate the diversity within language and traditions.
Conclusion
There's no single right answer for what a 5pm meal is called. It can be dinner, supper, or tea, depending on background and location. The most important aspect is clear communication. The blending of meal names reflects a modern society where traditions are fluid. Regardless of the name, the company often makes the meal most enjoyable.