Skip to content

What is really the best water to drink? A guide to optimal hydration

5 min read

The average person's body is composed of about 60% water, yet many are left wondering which type is truly optimal for health. The question of what is really the best water to drink is a complex one, with various options offering different benefits and drawbacks concerning purity, minerals, cost, and environmental impact.

Quick Summary

This guide compares common types of drinking water, including tap, filtered, spring, mineral, alkaline, and distilled. It covers their purity, mineral content, cost, and environmental impact to help individuals make an informed choice for their specific needs, considering factors like health, budget, and local water quality.

Key Points

  • No Single 'Best' Water: The ideal water depends on your personal needs, local tap water quality, and budget, as there is no universal "healthiest" option.

  • Filtered Tap Water Offers Balance: For most, a home filter on municipal tap water provides a cost-effective, safe, and environmentally friendly solution, improving taste and removing contaminants.

  • Consider Mineral Content: While mineral water provides essential minerals, purified options like distilled water and RO strip them away, which can be a concern if your diet is low in minerals.

  • Beware the Bottled Water Illusion: Bottled water isn't necessarily cleaner or safer than tap water, is more expensive, and significantly harms the environment through plastic waste.

  • Alkaline Water Health Claims Are Not Fully Proven: Scientific evidence for the broad health benefits of alkaline water is limited, and overconsumption could potentially disrupt your body's natural pH.

  • Check Local Water Quality: Start by understanding your local tap water report to determine if basic filtration is sufficient for your safety and taste preferences.

In This Article

The Importance of Water for the Human Body

Water is the lifeblood of our existence, essential for regulating body temperature, transporting nutrients, and flushing out waste. With so many choices available, from the faucet to specialty bottles, understanding the properties of each can help you make a more informed decision about your daily hydration.

Evaluating Your Water Options

Tap Water

Municipal tap water is often a safe and affordable option, especially in regions with high water quality standards. Public water systems are regulated by organizations like the EPA and are required to provide annual quality reports to consumers. However, the quality can vary greatly by location, and potential issues from aging infrastructure (like lead pipes) or treatment chemicals (like chlorine) can be a concern. A significant benefit is its cost-effectiveness and convenience, with minimal environmental impact compared to single-use bottled water.

Bottled Water (Spring and Mineral)

Bottled water is a massive industry, but the perception that it's inherently safer or purer than tap water is often misleading. Regulations for bottled water vary, and independent testing has sometimes revealed the presence of contaminants. Spring water comes from an underground source, naturally filtered and enriched with minerals, while mineral water must contain at least 250 parts per million of dissolved solids. The primary drawbacks are the high cost and the significant environmental toll of plastic waste, with microplastics also a potential concern.

Filtered Water

For many, filtered tap water offers the best of both worlds: safety and affordability. Using a home water filtration system, such as a pitcher, an under-sink unit, or a whole-house system, can effectively remove common contaminants like chlorine, lead, and some pesticides, improving taste and smell. Different filters target different impurities, and some can even be customized to retain beneficial minerals. It significantly reduces the environmental footprint associated with bottled water and is far more cost-effective in the long run.

Reverse Osmosis (RO) Water

RO is a powerful purification method that uses pressure to force water through a semipermeable membrane, removing nearly all contaminants, salts, and dissolved solids. This results in a very high level of purity, but it also strips away all beneficial minerals like calcium and magnesium. Some systems include a remineralization stage to add minerals back in, addressing potential health concerns associated with drinking demineralized water. RO systems can also be expensive and notoriously wasteful, though some newer models have improved efficiency.

Alkaline Water

Alkaline water has a higher pH level than neutral tap water, often ranging from 8 to 9.5. Proponents claim it can neutralize acidity in the body, fight free radicals, and improve hydration, though strong scientific evidence is limited and inconclusive. Natural alkaline water often contains minerals, while commercial alkaline water may be created artificially through electrolysis. Excessive consumption of alkaline water could potentially disrupt the body's natural pH balance. For those interested in the potential benefits, naturally sourced mineral water might be a safer, more balanced alternative.

Distilled Water

Distilled water is created by boiling water and condensing the steam, leaving behind minerals and contaminants. The result is exceptionally pure, tasteless water. While safe for short-term consumption, drinking it exclusively can lead to a deficiency in essential minerals, as it also pulls them from the body to maintain balance. For this reason, it is not recommended as a primary source of daily hydration but is useful for specific applications like medical equipment and irons to prevent mineral buildup.

Comparison Table: Water at a Glance

Type of Water Purity Mineral Content Pros Cons Cost Environmental Impact
Tap Water Varies by location Varies by location, often contains some Very affordable, convenient Potential contaminants, taste issues Very low Very low
Filtered Tap High (removes contaminants from tap) Retains minerals (depends on filter) Cost-effective, better taste, less waste Initial cost for filter, filter replacement Low Low
Bottled (Spring/Mineral) Variable, depends on brand High (especially mineral) Convenient, often good taste High cost, plastic waste, microplastics High High
Reverse Osmosis (RO) Very High Low to None (stripped) Highly purified, removes most contaminants Removes beneficial minerals, potentially wasteful Moderate to High Low (at home), High (bottled)
Alkaline Variable, depends on source Variable, often high Possible hydration benefits (unproven), better taste Expensive, health claims largely unverified High High (bottled)
Distilled Highest None Purest form, useful for appliances Lacks minerals, flat taste, not for long-term use Moderate Low (at home), Moderate (bottled)

Lists for Making an Informed Choice

Steps to Choosing the Right Water

  1. Assess your local tap water quality: Check your municipal water provider's annual report. This will give you a baseline of what's in your water. If you have a well, get it tested regularly.
  2. Consider your specific health needs: If you need to avoid certain minerals or contaminants due to health conditions, consult a doctor or specialist.
  3. Evaluate your budget: The cost of bottled water is significantly higher than tap, even with a filter investment. Consider the long-term costs.
  4. Prioritize environmental impact: If reducing plastic waste is important to you, filtered tap water or a home RO system is the clear winner over bottled water.
  5. Test for taste: Taste is subjective. Try different options to see what you prefer, especially after filtering. Filtered water often tastes better than unfiltered tap water.

Making Your Choice: Finding the Best Water for You

Ultimately, there is no single "best" water for everyone. For most people living in areas with good municipal water quality, a high-quality home filter is a cost-effective, environmentally friendly, and safe way to ensure pure, great-tasting drinking water. For those in areas with poor tap water quality, an RO system might offer the greatest peace of mind, provided a remineralization step is included or minerals are obtained through diet. While options like bottled spring and mineral water are convenient and mineral-rich, the environmental cost and expense are significant factors to weigh.

The best water for you is the one that meets your personal needs for purity, taste, mineral balance, and budget, while also aligning with your environmental values. Start with your tap water, understand its composition, and then decide if an added layer of filtration is the right choice for your optimal hydration.

For more information on water quality, check out the Environmental Working Group's (EWG) Tap Water Database

Conclusion

The quest to find the best water to drink depends entirely on individual circumstances, including local water quality, budget, and personal health goals. For many, a simple and effective solution is a home filtration system on affordable and regulated tap water. This approach offers superior quality and taste while drastically reducing the environmental and financial costs associated with constant bottled water purchases. By evaluating the pros and cons of each water type, from mineral-rich spring water to contaminant-free reverse osmosis, you can confidently choose the hydration method that best suits your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Not necessarily. Many brands of bottled water are simply bottled tap water, and the industry has less oversight than municipal water supplies. Filtered tap water is often a more cost-effective and environmentally friendly option.

While safe for short-term consumption, it is not recommended as your primary source of hydration long-term. The distillation process removes all minerals, and prolonged consumption could lead to mineral deficiencies if not balanced by diet.

Reverse osmosis is a highly effective purification method that removes almost all dissolved solids and minerals using a semipermeable membrane. Standard filtration uses a carbon block or other medium to target specific contaminants like chlorine and lead while typically leaving beneficial minerals in the water.

Scientific evidence supporting the health claims of alkaline water, such as slowing aging or preventing chronic disease, is limited and often funded by manufacturers. The body maintains a stable pH, so significant effects from slightly alkaline water are debated.

Yes, water naturally contains various minerals. Spring and mineral waters are known for their high mineral content, while tap water also contains trace minerals. However, most essential minerals are primarily absorbed through food.

Your choice of filter should depend on your local tap water report. Consider filters that address specific contaminants present in your area, such as chlorine, lead, or pesticides. A high-quality filter improves taste and removes harmful substances while remaining economical.

Drinking tap water is significantly better for the environment. It drastically reduces the plastic waste and energy consumption associated with the production, transportation, and disposal of single-use plastic bottles.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.