Ranking the Top Arby's Sandwiches
Arby's is known for having "the meats," and while the menu has expanded over the years, the best items often stick to their carnivorous roots. Deciding on a sandwich can be tough, so here is a breakdown of the fan favorites and critical darlings.
The Classic Roast Beef
The Classic Roast Beef sandwich is the original, and according to sales data, still the king. It features thinly sliced, slow-roasted beef piled high on a toasted sesame seed bun. Its simplicity is its strength, offering a pure, savory experience that is elevated by Arby's Sauce or Horsey Sauce. For a beefier meal, you can upgrade to the Double or Half Pound versions, offering more protein without adding much extra fat or carbs, especially if you skip the bun.
The Beef 'n Cheddar
Arby's signature sandwich for a reason, the Beef 'n Cheddar is a masterful combination of flavors and textures. Piled on a soft onion roll, it features the classic roast beef, rich and gooey cheddar cheese sauce, and zesty Red Ranch sauce. The onion bun and sweet-and-sour Red Ranch sauce provide a delicious contrast to the savory beef and creamy cheese, creating an unparalleled flavor profile that you can't get anywhere else.
The Reuben
Often surprisingly overlooked by first-timers, the Reuben is a standout for those who appreciate deli-style sandwiches. It features a generous portion of thinly sliced corned beef, Swiss cheese, tangy sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing, all served on marble rye bread. The corned beef is tender and flavorful, and the combination of tangy and salty ingredients provides a complex and satisfying taste that rivals many traditional deli versions.
The Smokehouse Brisket
For barbecue lovers, the Smokehouse Brisket is a must-try. Arby's slow-smokes their brisket for 13 hours, resulting in a tender and smoky meat. It's topped with crispy onion strings, cheddar cheese, and a smoky barbecue sauce on a toasted brioche bun. While some find the brisket a bit on the dry side for a fast-food chain, the smoky flavor and crunchy onion strings make it a respectable and hearty sandwich option.
The Unbeatable Sides at Arby's
Arby's sides are often just as famous as its sandwiches, with the most popular option even overshadowing the mains for some customers.
Best Sides at Arby's
- Curly Fries: The undisputed king of Arby's sides. These perfectly seasoned ringlets are crunchy, oily, and expertly spiced. They are great on their own but even better when dipped in Horsey or Arby's Sauce.
- Mozzarella Sticks: A perennial fan-favorite, these are deep-fried to a golden brown and filled with gooey, melted mozzarella. Many prefer dipping them in Horsey Sauce instead of the subpar marinara.
- Jalapeño Bites: Spicy and creamy, these battered and fried jalapeño halves filled with cream cheese are a fiery treat. They pair perfectly with the sweet Bronco Berry sauce.
Side-by-Side Comparison: Top Arby's Sandwiches
| Feature | Classic Roast Beef | Beef 'n Cheddar | Reuben | Smokehouse Brisket |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Meat | Thin-sliced roast beef | Roast beef | Thin-sliced corned beef | 13-hour smoked brisket |
| Cheese | None (add-on) | Cheddar cheese sauce | Melted Swiss | Melted cheddar |
| Toppings | Optional sauces | Red Ranch sauce | Sauerkraut, Thousand Island | Crispy onion strings, BBQ sauce |
| Bun | Sesame seed bun | Onion roll | Marble rye bread | Toasted brioche bun |
| Signature Feature | The original, simple perfection | Unique onion roll and cheese sauce | Authentic deli experience | Smoky flavor and crunchy onions |
| Best For... | Traditionalists & purists | Fans of a classic Arby's experience | Deli enthusiasts | Barbecue lovers |
Beyond the Classics: Dessert and More
Don't forget to save room for dessert. The Jamocha Shake is a creamy, coffee-and-chocolate blend that has been a fan favorite for years. The apple and cherry turnovers also offer a classic, flaky, and sweet finish to your meal. For those looking for a lighter, but still salty side, the classic Potato Cakes are another solid option.
Making the Best Choice for You
Ultimately, what's the best thing to eat at Arby's depends on your personal taste. If you're a purist, you can't go wrong with the Classic Roast Beef and a side of Curly Fries. For a more decadent and unique fast-food experience, the Beef 'n Cheddar is the undisputed choice. If you prefer bold and tangy flavors, the Reuben is an excellent alternative. While Arby's offers a wide variety of items that can be high in calories and sodium, making a well-informed choice allows for a delicious and satisfying meal. For example, opting for the Roast Beef Gyro offers a more balanced meal with vegetables and a flavorful sauce. Consider the menu, and choose what best satisfies your cravings, whether it's the iconic roast beef or one of the many other delightful items.
Here's what a food critic had to say about Arby's best sandwiches.
Conclusion: We Have the Winner
While personal preference is key, the Classic Beef 'n Cheddar stands out as the ultimate Arby's menu item for many. It embodies the essence of the brand, blending the signature roast beef with a decadent cheese sauce and the perfect onion roll. Paired with a side of iconic Curly Fries and a creamy Jamocha Shake, it creates a meal that is uniquely Arby's and impossible to replicate elsewhere. The Reuben is a strong contender for those who enjoy a different flavor profile, while the Classic Roast Beef remains the safe and satisfying original. Whatever you choose, you're guaranteed a filling, meaty experience that is a departure from the typical fast-food fare.
