The Core Imbalance: What Drives RED-S
At its heart, the cause of RED-S is a state of persistent low energy availability (LEA). This is not simply a matter of under-eating, but a critical energy imbalance where the body does not have enough fuel left over after training to perform its essential functions. When an athlete's energy expenditure from daily activities and exercise outweighs their energy intake from food, the body enters a state of preservation, shutting down or impairing non-essential systems to conserve energy. This cascade effect is the origin of the widespread symptoms associated with RED-S.
Factors Contributing to Low Energy Availability
Several factors, both intentional and unintentional, can lead to the energy deficit that causes RED-S. Often, a combination of these elements pushes an athlete into a state of LEA.
- Intentional under-fueling: Athletes may deliberately restrict calorie intake in an effort to lose weight or alter body composition, often due to aesthetic pressures from their sport (e.g., gymnastics, ballet) or personal body image concerns. They may mistakenly believe that a lower body weight will lead to better performance.
- Unintentional under-fueling: In some cases, athletes simply underestimate the massive energy requirements of their high-volume or high-intensity training. They may eat what feels like a normal amount of food, but it is insufficient to cover both their basal metabolic rate and their extensive exercise expenditure. This is common in endurance sports like running and cycling.
- Increased training load: A sudden increase in training intensity, duration, or volume without a corresponding increase in food intake can rapidly create an energy deficit. This is a frequent trigger, especially during competitive seasons.
- Poor nutritional timing and quality: Even with adequate daily calorie totals, poor timing or an inadequate balance of macronutrients (especially carbohydrates) around training sessions can lead to functional LEA. Proper fueling before, during, and after exercise is critical for energy availability.
- Disordered eating behaviors: A spectrum of disordered eating habits, which may not meet the criteria for a clinical eating disorder, can lead to LEA. Athletes may develop restrictive tendencies or unhealthy relationships with food due to the competitive environment or personal psychological factors.
The Physiological Consequences
Once LEA is established, the body's defensive response triggers a broad range of physiological changes that define the RED-S syndrome. These changes affect nearly every body system.
- Hormonal dysfunction: The energy crisis leads to a suppression of the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal (HPG) axis. In females, this reduces the production of estrogen, leading to irregular or absent periods (amenorrhea). In males, it lowers testosterone levels, impacting libido and strength.
- Metabolic rate suppression: The body attempts to conserve energy by slowing down the basal metabolic rate, making it harder to maintain body temperature and complicating the energy balance further.
- Compromised bone health: Low levels of sex hormones, particularly estrogen, impair bone formation and maintenance. This leads to decreased bone mineral density (osteopenia or osteoporosis) and significantly increases the risk of stress fractures and other bone injuries, especially in weight-bearing sports.
- Impaired immunity and illness: The body diverts energy away from the immune system, leaving the athlete more susceptible to illnesses, colds, and infections. Recovery from sickness also takes longer.
- Cardiovascular and gastrointestinal issues: Cardiovascular health can be negatively impacted, and gastrointestinal function, including gut motility and nutrient absorption, is impaired.
RED-S vs. Overtraining Syndrome
While closely linked, RED-S and Overtraining Syndrome (OTS) are distinct conditions. The primary difference lies in the root cause, though they often co-exist due to the high stress levels and poor recovery associated with RED-S.
| Aspect | Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (RED-S) | Overtraining Syndrome (OTS) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Cause | Chronic low energy availability (LEA). | Excessive training load combined with inadequate rest/recovery. |
| Key Driver | The energy deficit is the central issue, triggering a multi-system impairment. | The stress of training itself is the main factor, leading to a state of chronic fatigue and decreased performance. |
| Impact on Body | Widespread systemic effects affecting hormonal, metabolic, and bone health. | Impairs the nervous, hormonal, and immune systems, leading to exhaustion and a decline in performance. |
| Overlap | LEA is a risk factor for OTS, as the under-fueled body cannot adapt to high training loads. | OTS can contribute to LEA through high energy expenditure, but is not the sole cause. |
The Psychological Underpinnings of RED-S
It is crucial to recognize that psychological factors are intertwined with the physiological causes of RED-S. For many athletes, mental health issues contribute to and are worsened by the condition. The relentless drive for perfection, often combined with pressure from coaches or teammates, can lead to disordered eating behaviors. A decline in performance or mood swings resulting from RED-S can further increase anxiety and depression. Recognizing this psychological component is vital for a comprehensive treatment plan.
Conclusion
In summary, the cause of RED-S is the physiological stress response to a persistent mismatch between energy intake and energy expenditure, known as low energy availability (LEA). This imbalance, which can be intentional or unintentional, forces the body to prioritize immediate survival over long-term health and optimal performance. By suppressing crucial physiological functions such as hormonal regulation, bone building, and immune response, RED-S creates a cycle of health and performance detriments. Recognizing and addressing the root cause through a multi-disciplinary approach involving nutrition, training adjustments, and psychological support is essential for an athlete's full recovery.
Optional Outbound Link: For more detailed information on preventing and treating RED-S, a resource for athletes and practitioners can be found on the REDinSport website.