Common English Names and Regional Variations
Although there isn't one single, universally-recognized English name for panela, several terms are commonly used. The most direct translation is raw cane sugar or whole cane sugar, which accurately describe its unrefined nature. However, some of its regional names from other languages have also entered the English lexicon, leading to a bit of confusion for the uninitiated.
Piloncillo (Mexico)
Perhaps the most common alternative name encountered in English-speaking countries is piloncillo, from Mexico. Named for its distinctive cone or "pylon" shape, piloncillo is fundamentally the same product as panela: solidified, unrefined sugarcane juice. The name piloncillo is widely recognized, especially in the US, due to Mexican culinary influence.
Jaggery (South Asia and Africa)
Panela is often compared to or even called jaggery, especially in South Asian and parts of African cuisine. Jaggery is another type of non-centrifugal sugar, traditionally made from sugarcane or palm sap. While the products are very similar, subtle differences can exist based on the source plant and production methods. Nevertheless, it is a close relative and an accurate comparison.
Other Latin American aliases
In South America, panela goes by a number of other names that occasionally appear in English texts, including:
- Rapadura: Used in Brazil, Argentina, and parts of the Caribbean.
- Chancaca: Found in Chile, Peru, and Bolivia.
- Papelón: A common name in Venezuela.
Panela vs. Brown Sugar: A Key Distinction
A common mistake is to simply call panela "brown sugar." While they are similar in appearance, their production methods are vastly different, resulting in distinct flavors and textures.
| Feature | Panela (or Piloncillo) | Brown Sugar (American Style) |
|---|---|---|
| Processing | Minimally processed; evaporated and solidified pure sugarcane juice. | Highly refined white sugar with molasses added back in. |
| Flavor | Deep, complex caramel and molasses flavor with earthy, sometimes smoky notes. | Simpler, more straightforward sweetness with a molasses-like taste. |
| Texture | Hard, dense blocks or cones that require grating or melting. | Soft, moist, and pliable granulated crystals. |
| Nutrients | Retains more minerals and vitamins from the sugarcane juice, though in trace amounts. | Fewer trace minerals as a result of the refining process. |
How Panela is Made
The process of making panela is relatively simple and has been practiced for centuries. Sugarcane stalks are first crushed to extract the juice. This juice is then collected, filtered, and boiled in large vats. As the water evaporates, the liquid thickens into a syrup. This concentrated syrup is then poured into molds, where it cools and hardens into solid blocks, bricks, or cones. No centrifugation or chemical bleaching is involved, preserving the natural molasses and nutrients.
Culinary Uses for Panela
Panela's robust, caramel flavor makes it a versatile ingredient in the kitchen. It can be used as a simple sweetener or to add depth and complexity to a variety of dishes and beverages.
- Beverages: In Colombia, aguapanela is a popular drink made by dissolving panela in hot water with a squeeze of lime. It can also be used to sweeten coffee, tea, and smoothies.
- Desserts: The deep caramel flavor works wonderfully in desserts like flan, rice pudding (arroz con leche), and cookies.
- Savory Dishes: A touch of panela can be used in savory applications, such as marinades, sauces, and glazes for meats, adding a balanced sweetness.
- Syrups: It can be melted with water to create a rich syrup for pancakes, waffles, or cocktails.
A Final Word on Terminology
While the search for a single, universal English name for panela may be futile, the key takeaway is that the product is a delicious and versatile unrefined sweetener. Whether you find it labeled as panela, piloncillo, or simply raw cane sugar, understanding its origins and distinct flavor profile will help you make the best use of this ingredient in your cooking. For more on how to use piloncillo (the Mexican version of panela), King Arthur Baking offers a helpful guide: What is piloncillo? This sweetener makes great cookies, pan dulce, and more.
Conclusion
In summary, there is no single definitive English name for panela, with "raw cane sugar," "whole cane sugar," and regional names like "piloncillo" being the most common alternatives. This unrefined sugarcane product stands apart from typical brown sugar due to its simpler processing and more complex, nuanced flavor profile. Its versatility in both sweet and savory applications makes it a worthy ingredient for any home cook to explore, offering a richer and more rustic flavor than its refined counterparts.